9-1-1’s divisive season 9 premiere event has wrapped up, but it exposes the ABC procedural’s biggest issue. Ever since Peter Krause’s Bobby Nash became 9-1-1’s most tragic death in season 8, the firefighter drama has been at a crossroads. Without its beloved LAFD Station 118 captain, the show had to change, but it couldn’t stray too far from its first-responder formula.

Thus, 9-1-1 season 9 was preceded by clashing opinions about what the post-Bobby Nash landscape should be. Unfortunately, from 9-1-1’s whale-swallowing accident to its three-part saga set in space, season 9 has started off on the wrong foot. The true fault, however, may lie in the 9-1-1 franchise’s very DNA — namely, its long and complicated history of season premiere disasters.

9-1-1's Opening Emergencies Are A Franchise Signature

The Dramatic Season Premieres Always Astound (For Better Or Worse)

Cruise ship in 9-1-1 season 7
Cruise ship in 9-1-1 season 7

9-1-1’s trend of opening each season with increasingly dramatic emergencies can be traced back to season 2. Granted, the season premiere itself is devoted to introducing its new characters — now cast mainstays Jennifer Love Hewitt (Maddie Han) and Ryan Guzman (Eddie Diaz) — but 9-1-1 season 2, episode 2 introduces a massive earthquake with ripple effects extending into the next episode.

From there, every season has begun with a major disaster or a flashy emergency that sets up the hidden “true” first conflict. Season 3 was the iconic three-part tsunami arc that saw Evan “Buck” Buckley (Oliver Stark) swept away in one of 9-1-1’s scariest near-death experiences. Season 4 started with the Hollywood Reservoir dam breaking, which caused a dangerous mudslide.

Season 5 took a different approach to 9-1-1’s intense disasters, opening with a ransomware attack that precipitated a city-wide blackout. The chaos reflected Athena Grant’s (Angela Bassett) storyline, as a dangerous criminal escaped and kidnapped her son. Season 6 started with a lackluster blimp crash, but the true opening emergency was Athena’s two-part event, solving a cold case in Florida.

Yet, despite season 6 having one of the best episodes in 9-1-1, season 7 reverted to ostentatious disasters with a three-episode cruise ship takeover, capsizing, and sinking. Season 8 began with a bizarre bee-tornado that set up Athena crash-landing a plane. Now, season 9’s whale-swallowing laid the foundation for Athena and Hen Wilson's (Aisha Hinds) absurd "lost in space" saga.

Why Opening Emergencies Stopped Working For 9-1-1

The Formula Quickly Morphed Into A Futile Cycle Of One-Upping

Buck in a beekeeper uniform in 9-1-1 season 8 episode 1
Buck in a beekeeper uniform in 9-1-1 season 8 episode 1

Originally, the high-octane premiere event helped drum up buzz for 9-1-1 and potentially bring in new fans. Naturally, the first-responder drama also peppered in dramatic moments throughout the season, often ending with another major multi-episode arc, like Maddie’s kidnapping in season 2 or Jonah’s (Bryce Durfee) reign of terror in season 5. Unfortunately, the opening disasters have lost their touch.

There have always been over-the-top emergencies in 9-1-1, but it now feels like a competition to see which season can start with the most ridiculous concept — and, most importantly, get away with it. Rather than setting up season-long storylines, 9-1-1’s premiere events have become a spectacle without any narrative grounding. To an extent, some highly promoted disasters retrospectively seem like clickbait.

New episodes of 9-1-1 air Thursday nights on ABC and stream next-day on Hulu.

9-1-1’s bee-nado tragedy was marketed as the dramatic disaster that would kick-start season 8. Yet, the deadly swarm was only used for a handful of calls, while an egregious amount of time was dedicated to Athena’s plane subplot. What’s worse is that, like almost every preceding opening emergency, it was all quickly forgotten and had no overarching impact on the plot.

Premiere events are inherently meant to set the tone for the entire season, but 9-1-1’s opening emergencies seemingly exist in a bubble. Unlike season 3’s tsunami, which had major ramifications for Eddie and Buck’s relationship, the vast majority of 9-1-1’s opening emergencies do nothing to serve the plot, characters, or underlying themes of the season.

Is There Still A Way For 9-1-1 To Save Its Opening Emergencies?

Either Way, ABC's Hit Procedural Needs A Big Change

Buck and Chris in 9-1-1 3x02

For all the eyeroll-worthy scientific impossibilities and dangerously taut suspensions of disbelief, 9-1-1 has proven that opening emergencies can be effective if used correctly. The ransomware blackout from season 5 was great at fusing a thrilling concept with a character’s personal development, but it admittedly isn’t the most memorable. Conversely, season 7’s cruise ship is unforgettable for all the wrong reasons.

Like 9-1-1’s gruesome injuries, the opening emergencies are unnecessary if they don’t serve a higher purpose. The heart of the show may be its focus on first-responder careers, but that heart only beats because of its lovable cast of characters. Viewers are already invested in the core ensemble and the soapy drama they experience without a preposterous trip to space.

If ABC absolutely can’t let go of its signature move, 9-1-1 needs to create premiere events that thematically match the rest of the season and aren’t just conversation fodder. Season 9 sending Athena to space may be an incredibly nuanced metaphor for her grief on paper, but the sheer inanity of it all detracts from any meaningful growth.

Truly, 9-1-1 would be better off abandoning its opening emergency trend entirely. Instead, season premieres should focus on character-driven plots — save natural disasters for when they make sense instead of forcing them to the forefront. 9-1-1 is dramatic enough on its own; without any narrative consequences, opening emergencies are just overkill.

6njuqsd3by2mjsdzm1p0moplzs3.jpg
410
8.8/10

9-1-1

Release Date
January 3, 2018
Network
ABC, FOX
Showrunner
Tim Minear
Directors
Bradley Buecker, John J. Gray, Brenna Malloy, Jennifer Lynch, David Grossman, Marita Grabiak, Gwyneth Horder-Payton, Jann Turner, James Wong, Marcus Stokes, Chad Lowe, Juan Carlos Coto, Christine Khalafian, Dawn Wilkinson, Maggie Kiley, Millicent Shelton, Sarah Boyd, Tasha Smith, Tessa Blake, Aisha Hinds, Kristen Reidel, Shauna Duggins, Jonathan Lawrence, Robert M. Williams Jr.
Writers
Tim Minear, Andrew Meyers, Taylor Wong, James Leffler, Molly Green, Christopher Monfette, Nadia Abass-Madden, Stacey R. Rose, Nicole Barraza Keim, Bob Goodman, Brad Falchuk, David Fury, Ryan Murphy, Ted Griffin, Erica L. Anderson, Matthew Hodgson, Zachary Reiter, Tonya Kong, Adam Penn, Aristotle Kousakis, Molly Green, Rashad Raisani, Ian Sobel
Angela Bassett as Athena Grant in 9-1-1
  • Headshot Of Angela Bassett In The 2024 Disney Upfront
    Angela Bassett
    Athena Grant
  • Headshot Of Peter Krause
    Peter Krause
    Bobby Nash

Creator(s)
Ryan Murphy, Brad Falchuk, Tim Minear