It’s interesting that even though Sophie on Apple TV+ original series Surface could not remember any details about her life before her traumatic brain injury, she still seemed to have a pretty good sense of what was going on, who could potentially tell her the truth, and who might be lying to her.
Given that the show is filled with characters who have high-paying careers and Ivy League educations, it’s no surprise that each of the few main characters ranks high when it comes to smarts. But some are higher on the academic scale while others possess what many like to call “street smarts.”
Harrison
Harrison is a smart person, as evidenced by his job as a wealthy businessman. He is also seemingly always there to support his friend. But fans don’t get to see much of his intelligence on display since he is often too busy trying to encourage James to go out and have fun and making snide remarks about Sophie.
He may be smarter than he comes across, but it isn't easy to see through the only lens viewers get, which is his interactions with James and Sophie. The character is fairly one-dimensional, there merely to support the plot. Thus, his intelligence can’t be fairly assessed.
James
James has some smarts given his abilities at his job. But as is revealed in the flashback episodes, he also lacked the confidence and drive until Sophie helped him break through the walls. He had too much of a moral compass to lie to his clients, but when Sophie opened his eyes to the fact that the game was rigged against him unless he did just that, he finally had the confidence to do what needed to be done to prove himself.
Thus, James – played by Oliver Jackson-Cohen who, in terms of where else you’ve seen the cast of Surface, fans might recognize from The Haunting of Hill House, is intelligent. But applying his intelligence is where he lacks skill. His intelligence also comes into question given his trusting nature and blinders when it comes to Sophie. While his love for his wife should be admired, he let too many obvious things slide when even fans could see what was happening.
Caroline
Caroline appears to be a self-made woman, wealthy, successful, and smart enough to do what she wants when she wants. She has made a name for herself, and while she appears to keep people at arm’s length, she also has a tight-knit group of friends, including both James and Sophie.
However, fans question her morality and motives in keeping critical secrets from Sophie in hopes she could wipe a slate clean and start a fractured friendship over from scratch. It was unfair, and while it might not reflect on her overall intelligence, it does reflect negatively on her emotional intelligence.
Baden
Baden – played by Stephan James who also played one of the most intelligent characters on Homecoming - was able to keep his occupation as an undercover detective secret for so long from the criminals he was working to take down. He did this while maintaining a relationship with Sophie behind her husband’s back. It shows that he was crafty, clever, and knew how to navigate difficult situations. That takes a lot of smarts as well as courage.
While he should have known better than to get caught up in Sophie’s case and come back into her life at a time when she was trying to rebuild, it was clear he did it out of genuine concern for her. He was also smart enough to let Sophie reveal details about her life when she was ready to do it instead of forcing her to do so. His strong emotional intelligence is one of the reasons she fell for him in the first place.
Hannah
As a therapist, Hannah studied for years to get her degree, which makes her academically intelligent. But her job also requires a lot of emotional intelligence, being able to read people, draw information from them, and deduce what might be causing issues in their lives or their mental health. Fans could easily see her sitting across from some of the TV characters who accurately portray mental illness.
She was smart enough to keep the truth about Sophie’s mother from her and beautifully navigated their relationship to try and keep Sophie out of harm’s way, both from others and herself.
Sophie
While many questions remain unanswered about Sophie, who she was, and her true intentions that day on the ferry, she comes across as someone who, before her brain injury, was up to no good, in some way.
She planned and orchestrated so many things, like selling jewelry to try the experimental treatment she wanted to have. But it was the tremendous skill she demonstrated when trying to help James make a name for himself in the investment business that truly impressed fans. While she was, in effect, manipulating people, in her eyes, it was for the greater good. Her tactics weren’t always admirable, but it took a lot of smarts to pull off everything that she did.