Oliver Queen opened up the Arrowverse with a mission to avenge his city, and drive out corruption, but his ultimate ending was a major disappointment. The CW did a pretty great job of adapting DC Comics stories and characters creating one of the most successful and expansive shared universes on TV. However, it wasn't perfect.

Aside from a couple of shows that felt out of place, or tired and underdeveloped story arcs, there were also elements of the Arrowverse that were incredibly confusing. For instance, the crossovers were often exciting events, but they did mess with the flow of each individual show and hero due to the colossal events that occurred mid-season.

And beyond that, there is how the Arrowverse itself ultimately ended. As DC Studios set its sights on rebooting their efforts in a more unified way, all the DC shows were unfortunate casualties of cancellation. But the ending for Oliver Queen, the character who kicked everything off, has to be the most disappointing of them all.

Oliver Queen Deserved A Better Sendoff In The Arrowverse

the-flash-oliver-queen-diggle-crisis-infinite-earths

Prior to Arrow's debut in 2012, the character wasn't among the most recognizable or favorable heroes. With the popularity of the MCU, Hawkeye appeared to be a more interesting take on a superhero sharpshooter, but Arrow successfully elevated Queen to become one of the most recognizable heroes for modern audiences.

While Arrow was eventually overshadowed by the success and popularity of shows like The Flash and Supergirl, Oliver continued to have a special spot in the Arrowverse, and often, he served as a leader among the heroes during the crossover events. So it makes sense that during the Crisis on Infinite Earth's story arc, Oliver is responsible for saving the multiverse.

After experiencing incredible hardships, and already being killed and landing in Purgatory, Oliver returned as the Spectre, an almost all-powerful being who was able to defeat the Anti-Monitor, and sacrifice himself to create a new multiverse where his friends and loved ones would be able to survive and thrive long after his death.

But despite becoming the hero of the story, and giving his life to preserve the Arrowverse that he helped to create, this ending ultimately felt ill-considered, and it made for an awkward and disappointing end to the story of Oliver Queen.

Oliver's Story Should Have Ended In Arrow, Not During A Crossover

Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen in a Tuxedo in Arrow
Stephen Amell as Oliver Queen in a Tuxedo in Arrow

As with all Arrowverse crossover events, Crisis on Infinite Earths was a story told in several parts, with episodes appearing in separate shows. That meant that Arrow hosted part four of a five-part story in their final season. Specifically, this episode was listed as Arrow season 8, episode 8.

But the final part of that saga then jumps over to Legends of Tomorrow, before Arrow continues on for a further two episodes after Oliver's sacrifice on a different show. Just from the perspective of clarity and honoring Oliver's story, this was an incredibly confusing way to kill off the main character.

As much as fans of the Arrowverse might have been excited to engage with crossovers, putting such a pivotal moment in another series, and only delivering the penultimate part of that saga in Arrow's final season, before moving swiftly on, created confusion, and forced fans to watch other shows that they may not have been following.

Ultimately, this was a huge disservice to Oliver's story, and one that soured the entire event, leading to a lot of confusion and frustration among slightly more casual fans, and a surprisingly pivotal event arriving unexpectedly for even the most dedicated Arrowverse fans.

Crisis On Infinite Earths Was Not The Conclusion Arrow Needed

Oliver, Felicity, and William sit together in the Arrow episode "Star City Slayer"
Oliver, Felicity, and William sit together in Arrow Star City Slayer

I respect and appreciate that turning Oliver Queen into the Spectre, and having him give his life to save the multiverse, was a smart way to pay tribute to the hero who made the Arrowverse possible. But the method of delivery, and this arc as an ending felt disappointing considering everything that came before.

Oliver Queen experienced incredible growth and development throughout his time in the Arrowverse. He went from being an angry and vengeful vigilante who picked up a bow and arrow in order to eliminate personal targets on a list, to a man who learned what it means to be a hero. As a father, a mayor, a man, and a friend, Oliver became so much more than a symbol.

Of course, it's these very attributes that led him to deliver his final sacrifice on behalf of the people he loved, but Oliver deserved more. At the very least, he deserved his story to conclude on his show, and give him a proper send-off that was focused on his journey. Instead, it was crammed into a much larger story.

Even if the Arrow series upheld his death in a sacrifice, it would have made more sense to have this play out in the series finale. It was nice to see a time skip where his daughter grew up to follow his legacy, and learn about his reunion with Felicity, but seeing his story wrapped up on his own Arrowverse show would have enhanced that greatly.