The Avatar franchise currently stands as a trilogy, but which of James Cameron's sci-fi blockbusters is the best? The filmmaker responsible for cultural cornerstones like Aliens, the first two Terminator movies, and Titanic took audiences to the world of Pandora for the first time in 2009. The original, CGI-heavy film defied expectations, setting the box office ablaze to become the highest-grossing movie ever.
Cameron took his time expanding the franchise, making audiences wait until 2022 to see the continuation of Jake Sully and the Na'vi's stories. Avatar: The Way of Water and 2025's Avatar: Fire and Ash demonstrate the leap in technology necessary to bring the director's vision to life, as the story grew to focus on Jake and Neytiri's family, Quaritch's return, and many other aspects of Pandora.
With all three films now out, we can rank the Avatar movies and determine which one is the best that the franchise has to offer.
3 Avatar: Fire And Ash
Fire and Ash still proves to be a wildly good time
Avatar: Fire and Ash feels a lot like Avatar: The Way of Water, and for good reason. The third Avatar movie came to be after Cameron split the script for the second entry into two movies, resulting in the threequel sharing a lot of the second film's DNA.
Now three films deep, there is a feeling that Cameron is retreading similar beats that he's already covered, something Todd Gilchrist's Avatar: Fire and Ash review for Screen Rant noted. This can mostly be felt with the Sully family, as a lot of their arcs are direct continuations of similar ideas that were so important in the previous installment.
Beyond the story rehashes, there is also something less magical about Fire and Ash from a visual perspective. The first two movies came out so far apart that there is a distinct leap in the technological advancements on display. That's not the case here. While Fire and Ash is still visually stunning and puts just about every other blockbuster's CGI to shame, that awe-inspiring feeling of them is gone.
Yet, Fire and Ash still proves to be a wildly good time. Cameron hasn't forgotten how to deliver blockbuster thrills, and the familiar storylines build to new moments that can be quite effective. Lo'ak and Kiri's stories gain more prominence, while Spider is really at the heart of this time, with Jake and Quaritch dueling for him.
The newest aspects on display are Varang and the Ash People, and that is where Fire and Ash really sets itself apart from the other two movies. Oona Chaplin turns Varang into a terrifying and enchanting new threat. She's arguably the highlight of the film. And the power couple formed with Quaritch is captivating. It arguably needed even more of her.
There's still so much good in Avatar: Fire and Ash and moments that make it a blast to watch. It just still feels a bit less special than the previous two, with the franchise record runtime being felt at times, putting it at the bottom of this Avatar movies ranking.
2 Avatar
The technological advancements on display and the immersive use of 3D stood out in 2009, and they remain incredible all these years later.
The one that started it all, Avatar is a breathtaking piece of blockbuster filmmaking. The technological advancements on display and the immersive use of 3D stood out in 2009, and they remain incredible all these years later.
For as much flak as it gets at times for its limited characterizations of the leads, I've always thought Cameron does enough to make Jake, Neytiri, Quaritch, and even Grace effective. Stephen Lang is so good as the RDA colonel and at being the face of humanity's attacks against the Na'vi. Jake's journey of finding his true self within his avatar body is also well done.
Avatar takes its time to fully set up the world of Pandora, the Na'vi culture, and what humanity is after. Just about every moment feels purposeful. The mythology in play here does not come across as underdeveloped or rushed, helping audiences to learn about this story through Jake's eyes.
In traditional Cameron fashion, there are also some really great action set pieces. The grand finale is especially impressive and ensures the movie delivers a thrilling conclusion as the Na'vi clans unite against RDA forces for aerial and ground-based attacks that are wonderfully staged and executed.
Avatar will always gain some extra points for being the first one and the memories associated with it. But, it is not the best that Cameron has done in this franchise.
1 Avatar: The Way Of Water
Avatar: The Way of Water is bigger and better than what came before, holding the franchise's greatest story and visuals.
There is no doubt in my mind that Avatar: The Way of Water is the superior entry in this sci-fi trilogy. Coming 13 years after the original, the wait proved to be worth it, as the visual leap on display here is jaw-dropping.
Everything looks so real, making it difficult to differentiate where any practical elements stop and the visual effects work begins. This feeling is most apparent in any water-based scenes, as there is a stunning realism to how the Na'vi interact with liquid. You may even start to question if the Na'vi are real.
The Way of Water boasts the strongest storylines and characterizations in the franchise, too. Jake and Neytiri's struggle to find their place among the Metkayina clan, Lo'ak's troubles and friendship with Payakan, Kiri's mysterious origin, and Quaritch's rebirth are all done well. Then there is the emotional current through Neteyam protecting his siblings, dying as a result, and a tear-jerking reunion with Jake in the Spirit World.
This is also undoubtedly the biggest entry in the series from an action perspective. The Na'vi rebellion, the Sullys and Quaritch's team fighting in the woods, the tulkun hunts, and so much more are exhilarating. It all leads to the epic finale, keeping you on the edge of your seat for the entire thing, helping an over three-hour runtime fly by.
Avatar: The Way of Water is bigger and better than what came before, holding the franchise's greatest story and visuals. It more than deserves the title of being the best Avatar movie and has set the bar high for any future installments to try and dethrone it.
- Created by
- James Cameron
- First Film
- Avatar
- Latest Film
- Avatar: The Way of Water
- Upcoming Films
- Avatar: Fire and Ash, Avatar 4, Avatar 5
- Cast
- Sam Worthington, Zoe Saldana, Sigourney Weaver, Stephen Lang, Giovanni Ribisi, Kate Winslet, Cliff Curtis, CCH Pounder, Edie Falco, Jermaine Clement
- Movie(s)
- Avatar, Avatar: The Way of Water, Avatar: Fire and Ash, Avatar 4, Avatar 5