A Back to the Future theory explains why there are significant differences between the letter Marty wrote to Doc in 1955 and the one revealed to Marty in 1985. The friendship between Dr. Emmett “Doc” Brown and Marty McFly is at the heart of Back to the Future, Back to the Future Part II, and Back to the Future Part III. There is certainly a sweet, fun dynamic between them along with a sense that wherever they might be in time, Marty and Doc will try to protect and help each other.
There is no better illustration of this than in Marty’s attempts to change the events leading to Doc being shot by terrorists immediately before Marty takes the DeLorean time machine from 1985 to 1955. After persuading the younger version of Doc to help him get home, Marty writes a warning letter to his friend but Doc refuses to read it and rips it up. When Marty McFly returns to 1985, he arrives too late to stop the terrorists from shooting Doc again at Lone Pine Mall. As it turns out, though, his friend is still alive as he was wearing a bulletproof vest. By way of explanation, old Doc Brown then shows him the patched-up letter that Marty had written in 1955.
There is, however, a major issue with the letter. The one from 1985 looks very different from the one that Marty, whose character changes markedly throughout the trilogy, is seen writing in Lou’s Café in 1955. The otherwise identical words are laid out differently and the paper has a Lou’s Café letterhead on it instead of being blank. Even so, according to a theory (via Reddit), a simple and reasonable explanation for these differences does exist.
Back To The Future Theory Explains Why Marty's Letter Is Different
In simple terms, this theory suggests that Marty McFly writes two letters to Doc Brown. The suggestion is that Back to the Future shows the initial writing of the letter and then omits the part where Marty, heeding Doc’s advice that “no man should know too much about his own future,” has second thoughts. He rips up that letter before changing his mind and rewriting it. It is therefore this second letter that he gives to the younger Doc Brown, who then rips it up himself before taping it back together and taking the action to save himself in 1985.
The Problems With This Back To The Future Theory
As elegant as this explanation is for this Back to the Future inconsistency, there are some problems with it. The most glaring of these is that the handwriting on the letters doesn’t seem to match. Individual words and letters only have a passing resemblance to each other, with the signatures looking particularly different. More than this, the way these words are laid out on the page is so completely distinct that it’s hard to believe that, despite the same words being used in each letter, the same person writes them.
The wording is another slight problem. As much as it is fair to assume that such an important message requires Marty, who was originally played by Eric Stoltz, to take the time to find the right words, using the same words for both letters does seem a little unlikely. It simply feels more intuitive to believe that a second version was worded differently, especially given the differences in the handwriting.
Other Explanations For Marty McFly's Letter Changing In Back To The Future
The obvious explanation is that the difference between the two letters is due to a simple continuity error in Back to the Future. However, this isn’t as much fun as adding to the many Back to the Future theories that exist. In this way, it’s more interesting to look at alterations to the timeline as an explanation for the differences between the letters. After all, as the ending of Back to the Future shows, the members of the McFly family and world-class bully Biff Tannen are changed by Marty’s actions in 1955.
The problem with this is the concept of time travel used in Back to the Future is not the same as it is in Avengers: Endgame. Although Back to the Future Part II’s internal logic in time travel can be considered a little arbitrary, Back to the Future is dealing with essentially linear time travel. As such, while backward time travel does change events in the movie, this doesn’t mean that it can cause physical changes to a piece of paper or how the writing is laid out on it after it is written.
The current craze for multiverses in movies like Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness offers another probable reason for the differences. In this case, the suggestion would be that there is a Back to the Future multiverse with multiple versions of Marty McFly and Doc Brown and universes where Doc reads the letter and others where he doesn’t. The difference in the letters will therefore come about because when Marty travels back to 1985, he jumps into the wrong universe.
Obviously, there is no explanation for how or why this jump came about as it is an idea that doesn't quite work within the internal logic of this time travel franchise. What is more significant is what this and other theories say about the love people still have for the movie. After so many years they are still looking to explain and understand the slightest mistake, nuance, or easter egg in Back to The Future. Whether or not any of these are possible or even likely, is another thing altogether. Nevertheless, as a potential explanation for the difference between the letters seen onscreen in Back to the Future, the genius theory of Marty writing two letters is elegant and simple enough to make it plausible.