Let’s face it: Even with the plethora of streaming services to choose from, sometimes, you just can’t beat the good old DVD. There is just something about a physical DVD that feels substantial: the feeling of holding something tangible in your hands and actually popping in a disk in your DVD player is something a streaming service can’t provide – and as far as DVDs go, you really can’t beat a good box set (yes, I still have my 8-piece Harry Potter box set sitting in my DVD collection). As most film aficionados would agree, having a box set of your favorite film is something to be proud of.

When it comes to the box set, the Criterion Collection is considered to be the gold standard of the DVD world. Established in 1984, The Criterion Collection is a collective of “important classic and contemporary films from around the world” in versions that are produced in the highest technical quality and has award-winning, original additions to the collection. They also boast to present each film in a way that the filmmaker would want it seen, presented in an utmost restoration state. These “Best Criterion Collection DVDs” are ranked to be best of the best by all film aficionados alike — read on to find out who landed in the best Criterion Collection DVDs category, curated for your next pandemic movie marathon. Just don’t forget the popcorn!

Editors choice

1. A Hard Day's Night

9.85 / 10
Read Reviews

Whether you’re a fan of the iconic English rock band, “The Beatles,” or just in the market for a really great musical-comedy, this film will surely not disappoint. A Hard Day’s Night, based on the song of the same name of course (as the famous tune pops in my head), follows the band as they spend an unruly 36 hours in London: complete with an exceptional soundtrack, hoards of adoring fans, and the slapstick comedic antics of John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison, and Ringo Starr – all before their televised concert performance.

Directed by Richard Lester, this 1964 film takes place during the height of “Beatlemania” — and we can all imagine how crazy that could be. Throw in Paul McCartney’s slippery grandfather, played by actor Wilfrid Brambell, and you’re up for a roaring good time! This special edition commemorative DVD from The Criterion Collection, released especially for the film’s 50th anniversary, features a new 4K digital restoration, a newly remixed 5.1 surround sound soundtrack, an audio commentary with the cast & crew, various interviews & documentaries, and much more.

Get swept up in the “Beatlemania” fun with this award-winning musical comedy, nominated for seven awards from the Grammies to the Oscars and having two wins; along with high praises from critics: with Time magazine rating the film as “one of the 100 all-time great films” and being labeled “one of the most influential of all musical films.”

Key Features
  • New 4K digital restoration
  • Newly remixed 5.1 surround sound soundtrack
  • Various interviews & documentaries
  • Hours of supplemental materials
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection (Direct)
  • Run Time: 1 hour 27 minutes
Pros
  • Released for the film’s 50th anniversary
  • Additional award-winning documentaries and media
  • Collector's item
Cons
  • Might not be as re-watchable as others
Buy This Product
A Hard Day's Night
Premium pick

2. 1984

9.65 / 10
Read Reviews

An iconic film adaptation of the classic novel by George Orwell, 1984 tells a frightening tale of a dictatorial oppressive regime. This dark sci-fi drama features an all-star cast, including such names as John Hurt as Winston Smith, Richard Burton as O'Brien, and Suzanna Hamilton as Julia, Smith’s love interest. Entwined within this film is a story of love and rebellion: we follow the life of low-ranking government employee Smith (Hurt) as he risks it all and pushes against an oppressive government when he gets himself involved in an affair with the defiant Julia (Hamilton).

Approved by the film’s director Michael Radford, this special edition DVD is jam-packed with tons of movie extras. Viewers can expect a new 4K digital restoration, never-seen-before interviews with director Michael Radford and cinematographer Roger Deakins, behind-the-scenes footage, two different music scores: one by Eurythmics and the other by composer Dominic Muldowney, and many more.

1984 is a dire look at a dictatorial oppressive regime that strips everyone of their individuality and personal thoughts, both on a political and a personal level. A gripping film, this iconic story is a must-have for all film aficionados — and remember, Big Brother is always watching.

Key Features
  • New 4K digital restoration
  • Behind-the-scenes footage
  • Two scores: one by Eurythmics and one by composer Dominic Muldowney
  • Supplemental materials
Specifications
  • Studio: The Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 50 minutes
Pros
  • New interviews with director Michael Radford and cinematographer Roger Deakins
  • New interview with David Ryan, author of George Orwell on Screen
  • An essay by writer and performer A. L. Kennedy
Cons
  • The film’s depiction of the dystopian reality does not dive enough into the book's thought-provoking messages
Buy This Product
Best value

3. Godzilla

9.56 / 10
Read Reviews

This film needs no introduction — Godzilla is a monster film classic: and it just doesn’t get better than this 2-disc set from The Criterion Collection. Directed by Ishiro Honda, this original 1954 film in Japanese (with English subtitles of course) is an iconic story of a massive, radioactive monster in Japan during a time when the country is under nuclear attacks and such. Godzilla, a dearly loved international symbol of destruction, is viewed in full glory in this must-have film that has frankly become a cult favorite — and rightfully so may we add. Included in this box set also comes Godzilla, King of the Monsters, a 1956 Americanized version of the film.

Featured in this monstrous box set are tons of movie extras that Godzilla fans will thoroughly enjoy, like a new high-def digital restoration on both films – so you can ensure your viewing experience will be even better, audio commentaries by film historian David Kalat, interviews with actors Akira Takarada and Haruo Nakajima as well as special effects technicians Yoshio Irie and Eizo Kaimai, plus an interview with Godzilla score composer Akira Ifukube, and a featurette showcasing the photographic effects of the film, and many, many more goodies. Okay, there’s no doubt about it: This two-disc box set will indeed be a prized possession for any Godzilla fans.

Key Features
  • 2-disc box set
  • Interviews with actors Akira Takarada and Haruo Nakajima
  • Also includes Godzilla, King of the Monsters
  • Supplemental materials
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 36 minutes
Pros
  • Audio commentaries by film historian David Kalat
  • Interview with Godzilla score composer Akira Ifukube
  • Featurette showcasing the film's photographic effects
Cons
  • Whites are blown out on occasion in the film
Buy This Product

This witty comedy from the genius mind of director Wes Anderson brings his audience to the opulent Grand Budapest Hotel. Set among the old-world splendor of Europe during the time between the World Wars, the delightful film stars big names such as Ralph Fiennes as concierge Monsieur Gustave, Bill Murray, Tilda Swinton, Owen Wilson, Adrien Brody, Jude Law and Edward Norton among many other stars. In the 2014 comedy-drama, M.Gustave (Fiennes) is framed for the murder of wealthy widow (Swinton) – therefore setting off a scheme involving a theft of a priceless Renaissance painting and a quest for fortune, in which Gustave and his protégé, Zero (Tony Revolori), establish an unwavering bond throughout the process.

With breathtaking scenes and a touching look at friendship, combined with a slight sadness at the grandeur of a vanishing world, this film is one of Anderson’s best works. The Grand Budapest Hotel earned a total of $172.9 million in box office revenue worldwide, resulting in Anderson’s highest-grossing feature as of yet, and not to mention, the film also racked up numerous awards and nominations.

This director-approved 2-disc set features a glorious 2K digital transfer, audio commentary with Director Wes Anderson, filmmaker Roman Coppola, and actor Jeff Goldblum. There are also storyboard animatics of selected scenes, a behind-the-scenes look at the making of the film, cast & crew interviews, pieces by critic Richard Brody, and lots of other movie goodies.

Key Features
  • 2K digital transfer
  • Storyboard animatics
  • 2-disc DVD set
  • Supplemental meterials
Specifications
  • Studio: The Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 40 minutes
Pros
  • Audio commentaries
  • Behind-the-scenes footage
  • Interviews with the cast & crew
Cons
  • Unique style might not be for everyone
Buy This Product
The Grand Budapest Hotel

With over 4000 reviews, Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me proves to be quite a popular title. In the film, we follow the last week in the life of Laura Palmer (played by Sheryl Lee), a popular high school student leading a double life in Twin Peaks, a fictional town in Washington. We also follow the murder investigation of Teresa Banks (played by Pamela Gidley) in this prequel to the tv series by the same name, “Twin Peaks”, that ran from 1990 to 1991. Starring alongside Sheryl Lee and Pamela Gidley is an all-star cast consisting of Ray Wise, Dana Ashbrook, Kiefer Sutherland, Kyle MacLachlan, and David Bowie, just to name a few.

Another notable film by director David Lynch, this 2-disc set of Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me features bonuses such as a newly restored 4K digital transfer, an alternate original 2.0 surround sound soundtrack, and a 5.1 surround sound soundtrack, 90 minutes of deleted and alternate takes from the film - labeled “The Missing Pieces”, an interview with actress Sheryl Lee, and a 2014 interview by Lynch with Sheryl Lee, Ray Wise, and Grace Zabriskie.

Once called “One of David Lynch’s most terrifying, heartbreaking films”, this 1992 psychological horror flick will surely be a gem in any mystery & crime buff’s DVD collection.

Key Features
  • 2-disc set
  • 90 minutes of deleted and alternate scenes from the film, labeled "The Missing Pieces"
  • 4K digital transfer
  • Interview by David Lynch with actors Sheryl Lee, Ray Wise, and Grace Zabriskie
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 2 hours 15 minutes
Pros
  • Alternate original 2.0 surround sound soundtrack
  • 5.1 surround soundtrack
  • Once called “One of David Lynch’s most terrifying, heartbreaking films”
Cons
  • No audio commentary
Buy This Product
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me

An adaptation of the 1898 sci-fi novel by H. G. Wells, The War of the Worlds sets foot in a small California town where a meteor-like object has descended and is affecting the town in mysterious ways, like stopping the clocks. With all clocks stopped, we see a menacing fleet of hovering UFOs – the alien invasion has begun. Directed by Byron Haskin and featuring names such as Gene Barry as Dr. Clayton Forrester, and Ann Robinson as Sylvia van Buren, this film explores this Martian-invaded world in full, brilliant, Technicolor and Oscar-winning special effects.

Features with this special edition DVD include a sublime 4K digital restoration, an audio commentary by filmmaker Joe Dante, film historian Bob Burns, and author Bill Warren, as well as a rare audio interview with producer George Pal from 1970. Also included with this DVD is a new 5.1 surround-sound soundtrack developed by sound designer Ben Burtt, an in-depth look at the film’s restoration process, and a 2005 documentary on the making of the film named The Sky is Falling, among many other treasured morsels. In addition, audiences are treated to a 1940 radio program featuring a conversation between actor/director/producer/screenwriter Orson Welles and the original author of the novel, H. G. Wells. Newly restored, this iconic film is a visually stunning representation of early sci-fi flicks.

Key Features
  • 4K digital restoration
  • Programs on the film's visual and sound effects
  • An 1970 audio interview with producer George Pal
  • Radio adaptation from 1938, directed and narrated by Orson Welles
Specifications
  • Studio: The Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 25 minutes
Pros
  • New 5.1 surround-sound soundtrack
  • A making of the film
  • In-depth look at the film’s restoration process
Cons
  • Non-Sci-fi fans might not enjoy it
Buy This Product
The War of the Worlds

A favorite amongst mystery-film aficionados, Mulholland Dr. is one of renowned director ‏David Lynch’s best works. Naomi Watts brilliantly stars as the aspiring actress Betty Elms as she becomes entangled in a search for identity when she meets Rita, a woman suffering from amnesia due to a car accident, played by actress Laura Harring. In this 2001 neo-noir, we see bright-eyed L.A. newcomer Betty (Watts) and Rita (Harring) fall in love as she helps Rita remember who she is – meanwhile involving such characters like a Hollywood movie director (played by actor Justin Theroux).

Features in this 2-disc special edition DVD set includes a newly restored 4K digital transfer, interviews with Lynch, Naomi Watts, Laura Harring, composer Angelo Badalamenti, and casting director Johanna Ray, as well as an interview with Lynch and the film’s cast, plus other footage from the set of Mulholland Dr. – guaranteed to satisfy any fans of the film.

Combined with Lynch’s intoxicating view of Los Angeles in Mulholland Dr. – which is the perfect backdrop for these mysterious characters, plus a story of love, and the brilliant acting served, makes this film a contemporary revolutionary masterpiece.

Key Features
  • 2-disc special edition set
  • Interview with David Lynch and the film’s cast
  • Newly restored 4K digital transfer
  • Extra footage from the set of the movie
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection (Direct)
  • Run Time: 2 hours 27 minutes
Pros
  • Lots of movie extras
  • interviews and essays
  • Booklet featuring a 2005 interview with David Lynch by filmmaker/writer Chris Rodley
Cons
  • Might be confusing and hard to follow for some viewers
Buy This Product
Mulholland Dr.

Directed by Arthur Hiller and starring names such as Peter Falk and Alan Arkin, this hilarious comedy is not your average “meet-the-parents” flick. The audience meets two men who are as different to each other as can be – Sheldon Kornpett D.D.S. (Arkin), a mild-mannered dentist from New Jersey and Vince Ricardo, a man that’s into some *ahem* “dubious activities” let us just say. In this classic 1979 film, laugh your butt off as the audience are taken on a 48-hour adventure filled with a series of events from the New Jersey suburbs to the hot & tropical Honduras, involving the CIA, Central American dictators (yes, you heard that right), and other government administrations: all before when Kornpett’s daughter is marrying Ricado’s son.

This special edition comedy classic features an exquisite 2K digital restoration, a new commentary with director Arthur Hiller, actors Alan Arkin and Peter Falk, and writer Andrew Bergman, as well as, a recent interview with Alan Arkin. Also included is In Support of The In-Laws, an interview with actor Ed Begley Jr., who plays Barry Lutz, and other names such as Nancy Dussault, James Hong, and David Paymer. If you are a fan of this classic comedy, then this Criterion Collection copy is the best you can get!

Key Features
  • 2K digital restoration
  • Audio commentary from 2003
  • A booklet featuring an essay by comedy writer Stephen Winer
  • Supplemental material
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 43 minutes
Pros
  • Interview with Ed Begley Jr. and other actors from the film
  • A 2011 recollection of the making of the film by the director
  • A new interview with Alan Arkin
Cons
  • A little light on special features compared to some other Criterion Collection releases
Buy This Product
The In-Laws

Mystery and crime movie buffs will relish this classic 1959 film produced and directed by Austro-Hungarian, Otto Preminger. Based on a 1958 novel with the same name, written by Robert Traver, aka Michigan Supreme Court Justice John Voelker, it is a story based on a true murder case in which Voelker acted as the defense attorney. So it is no surprise that Anatomy of a Murder is a superbly gripping film that exemplifies a true portrayal of a courtroom trial.

This groundbreaking film stars such names as James Stewart as small-town Michigan lawyer Paul Biegler, Lee Remick as Laura Manion, and Ben Gazzara as Lt. Frederick Manion, among others. Audiences are left at the edge of their seats as they are taken through the murder trial of a young Army lieutenant, Lt. Frederick Manion (Gazzara), who is on trial for the murder of the local tavern owner who Manion believes has raped his wife (Remick).

This 2-disc set comes with lots of movie extras such as a new digital restoration, an exploration into Duke Ellington’s score by critic Gary Giddins, behind-the-scenes photos, and news footage taken from the set, among many others. With a musical score by the legendary Duke Ellington and seven Oscar nominations, Anatomy of a Murder is a film that belongs in every film aficionado’s collection.

Key Features
  • 2-disc DVD set
  • Digital restoration
  • Newsreel footage from the set
  • New alternate 5.1 soundtrack
  • Musical score by the legendary Duke Ellington
Specifications
  • Studio: Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 2 hours 41 minutes
Pros
  • Duke Ellington’s score is explored in a new interview with Critic Gary Giddins
  • Behind-the-scenes photographs
  • Excerpts from a 1967 episode of Firing Line
Cons
  • No audio commentary
Buy This Product
Anatomy of a Murder

This dark film is considered to be “one of the most haunting and perverse film noirs of the 1940s.” Adapted from the sordid bestseller by William Lindsay Gresham, Nightmare Alley gives viewers a twisted look behind the, well, hypothetical circus tent. Find out what lurks behind the cheery facade of a traveling carnival and its dark secrets. Starring Tyrone Power as Stanton Carlisle, aka "The Great Stanton", the film also stars names such as Joan Blondell, Coleen Gray, and Helen Walker. Watch as this group of misfits made up of, um, sketchy characters to say the least, get wrapped up in a world of suspicious intents, deceit, and an accidental murder; which ultimately leads to the demise of “The Great Stanton”.

Movie extras in this special edition disk from The Criterion Collection include a new 4K digital restoration, an audio commentary with film historians James Ursini and Alain Silver, an interview with critic Imogen Sara Smith, as well as an interview with performer and historian Todd Robbins and a 2007 interview with actor Coleen Gray. Also included is a 10-minute audio excerpt from a 1971 interview with filmmaker Henry King, in which he discusses actor Tyrone Power.

Key Features
  • 4K digital restoration
  • Interviews with critic Imogen Sara Smith, and performer Todd Robbins, and actor Coleen Gray
  • Audio commentary featuring film historians James Ursini and Alain Silver
  • Supplemental materials
Specifications
  • Studio: The Criterion Collection
  • Run Time: 1 hour 51 minutes
Pros
  • The original uncompressed monaural soundtrack
  • An essay by film critic and screenwriter Kim Morgan
  • 10-minute audio excerpt of an interview with filmmaker Henry King
Cons
  • The original trailer is textless and lacks narration
Buy This Product
Nightmare Alley

Okay folks, so there you have it: the best Criterion Collection DVDs. With over 1,000 special editions titles to choose from, one thing is for sure: from classics of Hong Kong cinema, such as the World of Wong Kar Wai collector’s set, to more classic sets like Martin Scorsese’s World Cinema Project No. 4, you really can’t go wrong with Criterion Collection DVDs.

More About The Criterion Collection

The Criterion Collection, aka Criterion, is a home-video company specializing in restoring, licensing, and distributing "important classic and contemporary films." While there is a common misconception that films in the Criterion Collection are more “hoity-toity” to say the least, in reality, titles in the collection span from popular Blockbusters to more independent and lesser-known films.

The target audience of the Criterion Collection includes film and media students, film aficionados, and both public & private libraries. Over the years, the Criterion Collection has released special editions of films in VHS (gosh, remember those?), LaserDisc, DVD, Betamax, Blu-ray, and Ultra HD Blu-ray formats. All films in the Criterion Collection go through the royal treatment: a spanking-new restoration and multiple bonus features like audio commentaries and “making of” featurettes. They also operate an online streaming service called The Criterion Channel, where all Criterion films and their accompanying extras are available.