Now that MMORPG creature battler Temtem has received its long-awaited Update 1.0, many new players journeying to the mysterious islands of the Airborne Archipelago for the first time will have a crucial choice to make when it comes to selecting their Starter Temtem. Presenting perhaps the first serious challenge to the supremacy of the critically acclaimed Pokémon series when it comes to creature catching and collecting, Temtem arguably goes further than the Pokémon games ever have, featuring online creature battles, a full-blown suite of MMORPG features, and even console ports. Unsurprisingly, given its inspirations, Temtem also presents prospective players with the same conundrum that Pokémon players have faced over the course of eight generations of games: which of Temtem’s starters is best?

In Temtem, players take on the role of a Temtem Tamer, exploring the islands of the Airborne Archipelago, catching and collecting 164 species of Temtem, and battling against other players' NPCs. Players of the game have noted its many similarities with the Pokémon series, particularly in Temtem’s opening hours when players visit Temtem expert Professor Konstantinos at his lab and are offered a choice between three starting Temtem: the Crystal-type Crystle, Melee-type Smazee, and Mental-type Houchic.

Related: How to Get the Rock-Hopping Hook in Temtem

Naturally, there’s a good amount of debate over which Temtem starter is best, and it’s a discussion that the community has been having ever since Temtem sold 500,000 copies in its first month. However, as each starter offers a different style of play and has its respective strengths and weaknesses, it’s arguable that there’s no simple answer to this question.

Crystle: A Strong Early-Game Defense

Temtem Crystle Starter
Temtem Crystle Starter

Of the three starter Temtem, Crystle possesses the strongest all-around defense, with high starting HP, Defense, and Special Defense stats. This makes it the tank of the bunch, ideal for players just starting, as Crystle can take a fair amount of damage in battle before being knocked out. Its Crystal typing also gives it resistance against Electric and Mental-type techniques, which appear to be commonly used by Temtem in the starting area of Deniz. For that reason, it’s been a popular starting choice for players even before TemTem's official release date.

Crystle’s Attack stat is fairly solid, too, allowing players to dish out some damage while taking a few hits. All in all, it’s a great all-rounder with a rock-solid defense and a fair amount of hitting power. However, players should keep in mind that Crystle’s Speed stat is rather lackluster, so it’s often rather inconveniently shifted down the move order. On top of that, Crystle’s passive Trait Amphibian grants it a boost to its Speed and Attack stat after being hit with Water-type techniques, but this is a purely situational advantage, and players won’t often see its benefits in action.

Smazee: A Hard-Hitting, Fast Striker

Temtem Smazee Starter
Temtem Smazee Starter

Smazee’s strongest stats are Attack and Speed, and as such, it’s a good fit for Temtem players on all platforms looking to strike first and strike hard. Its Melee-type techniques are highly effective against Earth and Crystal-type Temtem, so Smazee excels at cracking the most formidable Temtem defenses. Its passive Trait Fever Rush also grants Smazee a boost to its Attack stat whenever it’s hit with a status condition such as Asleep or Poisoned. This has plenty of utility on the battlefield, allowing Smazee to inflict opponents with nasty status conditions using the knockout punch.

Related: Temtem Launching On PS5 In December Before Any Other Console Versions

However, players should note that although Smazee hits hard, it’s far less capable of taking a punch in return. Therefore, players choosing Smazee should prioritize building a strong squad by collecting more of Temtem’s critters early to cover its weaknesses. Smazee’s Defense and Special Defense stats are the lowest of the Starter Temtem, and as such, it’s particularly vulnerable to being hit. Mental-type techniques and Temtem will be the bane of any player choosing Smazee; as a Melee-type, Smazee is inherently weak against Mental-type techniques, and its low Special Defense only exacerbates that weakness. Smazee can hit hard, but players need to bear its weaknesses in mind.

Houchic: A Nuanced Special Attacker

Temtem Houchic Starter
Temtem Houchic Starter

Rounding out the three Starter Temtem is the Mental-type Houchic. Houchic’s strongest stats are Special Attack and Special Defense, making it an ideal pick for players who like a nuanced approach to battling. Players who choose Houchic will likely enjoy consistently compelling battles in Temtem as Houchic’s techniques have great synergy with its passive Trait Soft Touch. Soft Touch allows Houchic to do 20% extra damage to targets who are asleep and guarantees that they won’t wake up when attacked. Houchic starts with the Hypnosis technique, allowing players to take advantage of Soft Touch right from the moment they leave the professor’s lab.

Houchic’s Speed stat is also solid, and players can take advantage of this by unleashing status conditions and special attacks right from the very beginning of the game. It can be difficult for NPCs and other players alike to respond to this strategy in the early game, particularly when players are battling others who are just starting. However, choosing Houchic isn’t a guarantee that players will be able to win all their battles and earn easy money in Temtem. Unlike in Pokémon, all techniques have a Stamina cost, and Temtem that run out of stamina will be hit with negative effects that can prevent them from attacking or even knock them out entirely. In addition, Houchic’s Defense stat is low, and players should avoid getting carried away with unleashing too many special moves, as Houchic’s stamina in the early game won’t be able to keep up.

Overall, it’s easy to make the case that players just starting should choose Crystle as it’s the most well-rounded of the three. However, Smazee arguably fits players with a more aggressive playstyle, and choosing Houchic is a great way to get to grips with the all-important status conditions mechanic. However, players on all platforms, excluding last-gen consoles whose Temtem versions were canceled, will be glad to know that Temtem hasn’t followed Pokémon’s lead in one crucial way. Regardless of which starter players pick, they can still battle and capture the other two later in the game. The choice is still crucial, but there’s a little less pressure to figure out which starter is best.