2013's "Battle of the Atom" is the X-Men's most under-rated event. In 2013, as part of the X-Men's 50th anniversary celebration, Marvel published what promised to be the most explosive crossover event to date. "Battle of the Atom" explored the X-Men's past, present, and future, placing the time-lost All-New X-Men at the center of a phenomenal event.

In 2012, legendary comic book writer Brian Bendis had taken charge of the X-Men franchise. He swiftly launched one of the most controversial - and radical - X-Men stories of the decade; he had the original X-Men travel forward in time to the present-day Marvel Universe. This approach divided the X-Men fanbase, with some fascinated to see the original X-Men develop in different ways, while others were appalled at an arc they considered disrespectful to decades of continuity. Most assumed the All-New X-Men would inevitably be returned to their own time sooner or later, and so they treated this whole arc as nothing more than a gimmick.

Related: X-Men's Age of Apocalypse Is Still Marvel's Best What If? Story

"Battle of the Atom" is essentially Bendis' response to that criticism. The story opens with a shocking scene in which the All-New Cyclops is almost killed, and the present-day Cyclops begins to blink out of existence. Suddenly the X-Men - and comic book readers - realized they knew less about time travel than they thought. Bendis was drawing on different theories of temporal mechanics, and upping the ante to introduce a new element of risk. Unfortunately, not many readers understood this ambitious approach, and still fewer were willing to abandon their prior preconceptions.

All-New X-Men fighting Sentinels

The debate about temporal mechanics conceals a powerful theme; the question of whether a person can choose their own destiny, or is instead slave to forces beyond their control. Cyclops and Jean Grey had been horrified at the future timeline they saw, with Jean in particular struggling because she had downloaded her entire future life story telepathically. Neither were willing to consign themselves to returning to the past, where they assumed Charles Xavier would simply erase their knowledge so everything happened as it was supposed to. As a result, the two were struggling to deal with their attraction to one another, desperate to avoid the doomed relationship they had foreseen. Jean had even gone so far as to kiss Beast in the hope of sending her life down a very different direction. But, in "Battle of the Atom," these two teenagers' desire to blaze their own trail ironically led them to spend time together, to quietly eye one another up, and to realize afresh how much they cared about one another.

It didn't take long for matters to become even more complex, when a group of future X-Men arrived on the scene attempting to send the All-New X-Men home. This turned out to be a misdirect; these weren't X-Men at all, but rather they were a future Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. "Battle of the Atom" gradually opened up a fascinating new timeline, one that contrasted markedly with the ones previously seen in X-Men comics. Most future timelines are dystopian, but the future glimpsed in "Battle of the Atom" was a complex world where both good and bad things had happened. It felt more original, and frankly far more creative, than any timeline seen since 1981's "Days of Future Past."

Unfortunately, as fantastic as the concept behind "Battle of the Atom" may be, it just didn't quite work. The problem with this kind of crossover is that every member of the creative team needs to be on the same page, and there were subtle disconnects that pointed to disagreement between the writers. Meanwhile, many readers approached "Battle of the Atom" assuming it would end with the All-New X-Men sent back in time, and they were disappointed at the lack of resolution. The event had essentially been missold - and as a result, it never really had a chance at all.

More: How Did Professor X Survive Being Killed By Cyclops In AvX?