Baldur's Gate 3 offers you a staggering amount of choice as it throws you headfirst into gathering your party and saving Faerûn. Everything from the allies you gather and the powers you gain to how you complete deeply personal side quests is up to you, and that includes your character's morality. While playing as the hero is all well and good, there is something to be said for the strange freedom of a truly evil playthrough, which everyone should try at least once.

While a good evil playthrough can involve just making the most evil choices you can in Baldur's Gate 3, it's better to plan ahead a little for maximum twisted fun. With that in mind, there are some tips to keep in mind and choices to keep an eye out for to help you on your way to the dark side. From devious plotting to embracing the chaos, prepare for your next adventure with these helpful suggestions.

10 Plan Ahead When It Comes To Companions

Being Evil Will Lose You Some Friends

One of the first things to think about when planning an evil playthrough is what companions you'll want with you. Not everyone is going to stick around if you start going down a darker path, although there are plenty of companions for BG3 evil playthroughs. While some companions like Astarion and Lae'zel are fine with whatever you might choose, other party members like Gale or Shadowheart might need a little convincing to stay by your side.

Planning ahead for companions will also help when choosing which class to play. While a perfectly balanced party isn't strictly needed for BG3, if you know ahead of time that you're going to be building a tanky character, there is less pressure to keep Karlach in the party. And if all else fails, you always have the option to speak to Withers about recruiting some hirelings.

9 Recruit Minthara

Minthara Is A Must Have Evil Companion

Speaking of companions, if you’re planning to venture forth into Faerûn and do your worst, you’ll want to recruit Minthara. Minthara was originally envisioned to be the evil companion option and a counterpoint to Halsin, and I think she’s still best used in that capacity. You can recruit Minthara in one of two ways: either by raiding the Emerald Grove in Act 1 or knocking her out and rescuing her from Moonrise Towers in Act 2.

Minthara offers a unique point of view with her background as a drow woman factoring into how she views the world. Minthara approves of dialogues and choices that result in you gaining power and respects a more blunt attitude when speaking with others. On top of that, she has some fantastic spells and abilities such as Misty Step, divine smite, and vow of enmity, which make her a formidable force in battle.

8 Side With Auntie Ethel

Ethel Is A Powerful Friend To Have

Auntie Ethel is the seemingly harmless old woman who can first be encountered in the Emerald Grove selling her potions to the refugees. However, appearances can be deceiving, and should you take her invitation to visit her humble home, you’ll soon learn that this sweet little old lady is, in fact, a powerful hag. This, of course, opens up the opportunity to do some awful things, as Ethel can be sided with at several points in the story.

There are three types of hags in the world of the Forgotten Realms: sea hags, night hags, and green hags. Judging by her use of disguises, it’s safe to assume Ethel is a green hag.

Even if things come to blows in Act 1 when trying to free Mayrina, Ethel may still try to strike a deal with the party. This is a great option as it grants you Auntie Ethel's Hair, a powerful item that permanently increases a character's ability score by one when used. Ethel can also be recruited as an ally in Act 3 by killing Lora, and she'll be able to make five creatures invisible during the final battle.

7 Become An Unholy Assassin

Side With Sarevok & The Murder Tribunal

At times, being evil is about sowing chaos, and sometimes you can do so for practical reasons. When tracking down Orin, you'll come face to face with her grandfather and returning Baldur's Gate character Sarevok at the Murder Tribunal. He'll ask if you want to become an Unholy Assassin for Bhaal, and if you want access to some fantastic gear, your answer should be yes.

To become an Unholy Assassin, you'll first have to kill the annoying Investigator Valeria, who is chained down in a side room. You'll then have to kill both Minsc and Jaheira, which will obviously cause other companions to disapprove. However, by becoming an Unholy Assassin, you'll gain access to Echo of Abazigal, a secret BG3 merchant who sells some fantastic gear, such as the rare Bhaalist Armour and the Dread Iron Dagger.

6 Help Mizora Achieve Her Goals

Mizora Is Tons Of Fun During Evil Playthroughs

A big factor in any BG3 playthrough is gathering allies for the final fight, and there are some great evil allies available for the final battle. One of these is Mizora, Wyll’s patron and potential lover for you, who has her own agenda as she seeks power to impress Zariel. Getting Mizora’s help is very simple, but it does require following her instructions and encouraging Wyll to do the same.

Firstly, you’ll need to help Wyll kill Karlach, which will rob you of a potential party member but will get Wyll the Infernal Robe. Mizora will need to be rescued from Moonrise Towers, making sure to bring Wyll along to get the Infernal Rapier as a reward. Finally, you should encourage Wyll to keep his pact with Mizora to get her personal help in the final battle as a bonus for being so cruel.

5 Hand Aylin Over To Lorroakan

Free Her From One Prison Then Put Her In Another

While helping Mizora gains you an ally you might not otherwise have had, sometimes being evil can lose you support. However, in the case of Lorroakan and Aylin, doing the wrong thing is so unbelievably evil that it's hard to ignore. After searching for the Nightsong throughout acts 1 and 2, you should make sure that Shadowheart doesn't kill her, as this will ensure everyone at the Last Light Inn is safe and Aylin can be reunited with her love, Isobel.

However, once you've arrived in Baldur's Gate, head over to Sorcerous Sundries and speak with Lorroakan, the wizard who has been sending adventuring parties out looking for the Nightsong. It is revealed that Lorroakan knew full well that the Nightsong was a person, and he intends to trap her in another soul cage to make himself immortal. There is no mechanical benefit to siding with Lorroakan, but the coldness of handing her over is a must for any evil character.

4 Let A Redeemed Kagha Be Killed

Let Arabella's Parents Do The Dirty Work

Being evil isn’t always about immediately killing all in your path, and helping people in the short term can sometimes lead to a bigger fallout. One of the best examples of this takes place in Act 1, where the party will find a young tiefling girl being held by the druids for stealing their idol. To cause maximum damage, you should allow Kagha to kill Arabella before informing her heartbroken parents.

However, to really twist the knife, you should then help redeem Kagha by completing the side quest “Investigate Kagha” and convincing her to side against the Shadow Druids. From there, rescue Halsin, and make sure to save the grove from the goblins before getting ready for the party in camp with the tiefling refugees. At the party, Arabella's grief-stricken parents will confront and poison an apologetic Kagha.

3 Play As The Dark Urge

Explore Exclusive Options With This Origin

To really get the most out of an evil playthrough, you should try playing as the Dark Urge. I can't recommend this Origin enough, as it ties into the main storyline to a much greater degree than the other Origins or Tav while still allowing you to imprint an original personality on the character. As one might expect from a character called the Dark Urge, when playing as them, you'll have murderous urges throughout the game, which you can either resist or give in to.

On top of the next level of connection to the main plot, when playing as the Dark Urge, you'll get access to dialogue options that are otherwise unavailable. There are also plenty of new cutscenes that are exclusive to the Dark Urge, as well as more opportunities for carnage. Finally, you'll get great gear like the Deathstalker's Mantle, which will turn you invisible for two turns after killing someone.

2 Corrupt & Betray Companions

You Can Make Their Lives So Much Worse

No evil playthrough would be complete without a healthy dose of corruption and betrayal, and your beloved companions make the perfect targets. There are plenty of opportunities to really hurt those around you, from twisting them into the worst version of themselves to outright treachery. If you put your mind to it, there is a way to hurt almost every companion, ensuring they get the worst possible endings after the final battle.

A good example of this is helping free Shadowheart from Shar’s influence and to embrace Selune, only to then turn her over to Viconia in Act 3 to have her memories wiped. Another example is encouraging Astarion to complete Cazador’s ritual and become an Ascended Vampire to continue the cycle of abuse. For some extra evil bonus points, after completing the ritual, you could then help the Gur kill the newly Ascended Astarion.

1 Don't Do An Evil Playthrough First

Take The Time To Get To Know The Game

My final tip for anyone looking to do an evil playthrough is to not pick that path for the first time you play the game. Evil playthrough can be a lot of fun, but sometimes the best outcomes can come from meta-gaming a little and knowing how quests resolve in order to achieve the result you want. Violence isn't always the best choice when looking to be evil in an RPG.

Evil playthroughs of any game, especially Baldur's Gate 3, can sometimes result in you missing out on certain storylines or quests because of characters dying or becoming enemies with you. The story will also feel very different and at times play out in a noticeably different way from when you choose the heroic route. While I do recommend evil playthroughs to explore all the routes BG3 has to offer, they're best left until you’re more familiar with the storyline.

mixcollage-08-dec-2024-02-20-pm-5221.jpg

Your Rating

Baldur's Gate 3
Systems
Top Critic Avg: 96/100 Critics Rec: 96%
Released
August 3, 2023
ESRB
Mature 17+ / Blood and Gore, Partial Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language, Violence
Developer(s)
Larian Studios
Publisher(s)
Larian Studios
Engine
Divinity 4.0

Genre(s)
RPG