Summary
- Betrayals were a recurring theme in The Walking Dead, with characters like Simon, Carol, and Shane turning on their friends for self-preservation.
- From Simon's failed coup against Negan to Carol's banishment by Rick, these betrayals had lasting impacts on the story and characters.
- Even allies like Daryl and Maggie betrayed Rick when they planned to kill Negan behind his back, showcasing the complex and ever-changing dynamics of trust in the post-apocalyptic world.
Treachery was a recurring theme across The Walking Dead's 11-season story, with multiple characters committing shocking acts of betrayal. Despite its post-apocalyptic setting, zombies were only part of the problem for Rick, Michonne, Daryl, and all the others in The Walking Dead. Since the beginning of the series, conflict with their fellow survivors was integral to the story.
Many of the core group's toughest battles were with outside forces, but that only accounts for some of their troubles. Several challenges came from within. A long list of Walking Dead characters, some of which being people who had become trustworthy, turned on their friends. Self-preservation was arguably the most common motive, but there were instances where these decisions were much more complex. For one reason or another, betrayal after betrayal occurred in The Walking Dead, with quite a few leaving lasting impressions.
10 Simon Betrays Negan
The Walking Dead season 8
In The Walking Dead, even the show's villains had their fair share of traitors. Introduced as Negan's right-hand man, Steven Ogg's Simon was depicted as a person whose heartlessness made him a perfect fit for the Saviors; having no qualms about killing innocent people, Simon was able to do whatever horrible task Negan asked of him without hesitation. But as time passed, this aspect of Simon's character became a worsening issue for Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Negan. Simon's decision to wipe out the Hilltop against orders escalated tensions between the two, which eventually reached a breaking point.
Simon, who had developed enough confidence by this point to make a move against Negan, tried to start a coup. Simon's scheme fell apart when he was betrayed by Dwight. Simon's treachery ultimately cost him his life when his failure led to the character fighting a duel to the death with Negan.
9 Carol Kills Tyreese's Friends And Gets Banished By Rick
The Walking Dead season 4
Rick and Carol were strong allies for much of the series, but there was a time when Rick wanted nothing to do with her. After investigating the deaths of Karen and David, Tyreese's two companions, Rick came to the stunning conclusion at the end of season 4's "Isolation" that the murderer was Carol, who killed them believing that their illnesses would bring the group down. In response to her betrayal, Rick banished her, but eventually came to accept that Carol did the right thing.
8 Shane Gets Otis Killed
The Walking Dead season 2
Shane was guilty of many crimes in The Walking Dead, one being what happened to Otis. When Rick's group was staying at Herschel's farm in The Walking Dead season 2, Shane and Otis were forced to run from zombies. Seeing an opportunity to ensure his survival, Shane shot Otis in the leg, essentially making him a sacrificial lamb for the zombies. Shane had already been on his way to becoming a villain, with Otis' death being the tipping point that erased any remaining redeemable qualities the character still had.
7 Daryl & Maggie Betray Rick
The Walking Dead season 9
By making the controversial choice to spare Negan in season 8, Rick unintentionally hurt the bonds he had formed with two of his closest allies. Fiercely opposing the move, Maggie and Daryl orchestrate a plan to kill Negan behind Rick's back. Successfully tricking Rick, Daryl wound up in a brutal fist fight with Rick, which helped put Maggie in a position where she could take down Negan. She relented, though, when she realized that the villain had already been broken. As for Rick and Daryl, their friendship survived Daryl's betrayal. Even so, the two coming to blows after years of being "brothers" makes it one of their most emotionally significant scenes together.
6 Shane Tries To Kill Rick
The Walking Dead season 2
The slow collapse of Rick and Shane's friendship came to a head in The Walking Dead season 2's penultimate episode, "Better Angels." After luring Rick away from the group under false pretenses, Shane secretly intended to shoot Rick and take over as leader, unaware that Rick had already come to the sad realization that he was about to be betrayed. Rick being pushed to kill his best friend solidified the scene's status as one of the most pivotal moments in Rick Grimes' Walking Dead journey.
5 Eugene Decides To Stay With Negan
The Walking Dead season 7
The main characters faced one of their biggest betrayals to date when Rosita and Sasha tried to rescue Eugene, who had been a prisoner of the Saviors for weeks. But unbeknownst to them, Eugene had settled in quite well, having surprisingly found some level of acceptance with the Saviors. Rosita faced a huge shock when Eugene refused to leave with them. For that reason, Eugene had to be counted as an enemy throughout the All-Out War. Whether he genuinely wanted to be a Savior or not, Eugene's betrayal of Rick's group shaped his story for the remainder of season 7 and all of season 8.
4 Eugene Betrays The Saviors
The Walking Dead season 8
Eugene perpetrated not one, but two major betrayals during The Walking Dead's long run. Exactly when he decided to turn on Negan is unclear, nor can it be said with certainty that he had stayed with the Saviors with the intention of taking them down from within. In any case, Eugene secured his redemption in The Walking Dead season 8 finale when it was revealed that he purposely made faulty ammunition for Negan's soldiers. His act of revolt helped turn the tide and was enough for him to regain the lost trust of his friends.
3 Nicholas Causes Noah's Death
The Walking Dead season 6
The blame for one of the most gruesome deaths to occur in the history of The Walking Dead falls on Nicholas. Noah's introduction painted him as someone who could eventually grow into yet another mainstay of the group, and perhaps a fan favorite. That possibility was put to rest in season 6 when Glenn, Nicholas, and Noah tried to escape from a building together. Putting himself first, Nicholas let Noah get eaten by zombies so that he could get away. His downward spiral worsened from there, resulting in Nicholas trying to kill Glenn and eventually taking his own life during the infamous dumpster scene that nearly doomed Glenn.
2 Dwight Betrays Negan
The Walking Dead season 8
Unlike some of the others to happen on the show, Dwight's betrayal wasn't shocking in any sense, but wasn't any less meaningful for it. In fact, Negan's horrible treatment of Dwight made a break between them inevitable. Negan consistently took advantage of Dwight's loyalty, even going as far as taking his wife, Sherry, as his own. Dwight let this happen, but decided in season 8 that he had finally had enough. Switching sides and forming a reluctant alliance with Rick, Dwight turned traitor, helped bring about Negan's downfall, and in doing so, laid the groundwork for him to enjoy a long journey on Fear the Walking Dead as a hero.
1 Jadis Betrays Rick
The Walking Dead season 7
In his pursuit of allies against Negan, Rick seemingly picked up a huge one when he managed to gain the support of Oceanside ahead of the All-Out War. Though he wasn't exactly on friendly terms with Jadis, he at least had cause to think they'd help. After all, they too were being used by the Saviors. Rick's odds of beating Negan took a major blow in the season 7 finale when the Scavengers held the Alexandrians at gunpoint. As Jadis admitted, she changed her mind after making a more beneficial arrangement with Negan.
This moment wasn't exactly a point of no return for Jadis, though, since she was a member of Alexandria by season 9. However, it's reflective of the person Jadis has always been in The Walking Dead; her villainous deeds in The Walking Dead: World Beyond go to show that even now, Jadis can't be trusted. Jadis' original betrayal of Rick was a clear sign of what she's capable of.