BioShock fans have been waiting a long time for updates regarding the next installment in the franchise, BioShock 4, but after the most recent announcements regarding the game's development struggles, I think they should be careful what they wish for. It's entirely possible the next BioShock game will ruin the franchise's nearly flawless streak.

Over the weekend, BioShock fans got some disappointing updates, with the original BioShock remake being canceled entirely and the narrative for BioShock 4 failing a review from 2K. With 2K citing narrative issues as the primary cause for BioShock 4's shakeup, I am somewhat concerned about the franchise's future and wonder if we really need another BioShock game at all.

After Learning Of BioShock 4’s Struggles, I’m Not Sure We Need It

If BioShock 4 Can't Deliver A Unique & Worthy Story, It's A Pass For Me

Bioshock title screen

I'll caveat this by saying that there are several things BioShock 4 could do to change my opinion completely, but as it stands, I am very skeptical about its future. The fact that 2K cited narrative as the core reason for leadership changes on the project gives me a bad feeling that the people in charge cannot agree on the best way to continue the saga.

If BioShock 4's story isn't on par with the previous three entries, I'd rather developers let sleeping dogs lie and abandon the project entirely. BioShock 4 needs a worthy story and setting that is on par with the previous games, and anything of lower quality isn't going to be worth it after this long of a wait.

Fans have been waiting a LONG time for the next entry in their beloved franchise, and a lackluster story cannot be remedied by even the most innovative and groundbreaking gameplay. This is a franchise rooted in its unique and immersive world and characters, and its story is arguably far more important than the gameplay itself.

BioShock Already Has A Satisfying Trilogy

BioShock 4 Needs To Deliver In A Major Way

A statue of Andrew Ryan with the motto of Rapture written in gold on a red banner in Bioshock.
A statue of Andrew Ryan with the motto of Rapture written in gold on a red banner in Bioshock.

It could be that changing leadership of BioShock 4's development is the right move, and the next attempt at a narrative will be a home run, but that seems overly optimistic. The reality is that BioShock already has a pretty satisfying trilogy that doesn't necessarily need another entry.

Unless the next game is simply mind-blowing when it comes to both narrative and gameplay, I don't think most fans are going to be interested. BioShock 4 might attempt to close the loop on specific plot points in previous games or resolve unanswered questions, but this might end up being unsatisfying for many players.

Overall, while BioShock 4 has a lot of potential and could end up being an incredible game, I'm more concerned than ever after the recent news that it's going to be a complete train wreck and fail to deliver the experience that fans deserve after all these years. Fans should be careful what they wish for when it comes to BioShock 4, as it might not end up being the masterpiece they're hoping for.

Bioshock 4
Systems
Released
February 26, 2013
ESRB
m
Developer(s)
Cloud Chamber
Publisher(s)
2K Games
Engine
Unreal Engine 3
Franchise
BioShock

Genre(s)
FPS