Summary
- Broad City Season 4 had a promising start but mostly fell flat, with the exception of the episodes "Florida" and "Friendiversary."
- The 2016 US Presidential Election had a noticeable impact on Season 4's story
- Broad City Season 5 started strong with a unique format in the premiere episode, "Stories," and ended on a tear-jerking note, showcasing the enduring friendship between Abbi and Ilana.
Nearly ten years after it premiered on Comedy Central, Broad City still holds up--though some seasons are better than others. Originally a web series, Broad City follows the lives of best friends Abbi Abrams and Ilana Wexler, two twenty-something Jewish women living in New York City in the late 2010s. With each new episode of one of the best Comedy Central shows, Abbi and Ilana find themselves--at times, separately and other times, together — wrapped up in some sort of absurd, inconvenient, or downright humiliating situation.
Both the characters of Abbi Abrams and Ilana Wexler and their onscreen friendship are based on the real-life actors who play them (and creators of the Broad City web series and TV show), Abbi Jacobson and Ilana Glazer. The characters are exaggerated versions of their true selves, though: Ilana the laidback, free-spirited commitment-phobe, and Abbi the neurotic, timid, aspiring artist. Throughout Broad City, Abbi and Ilana evolve and mature, but always manage to stay friends. Every season of Broad City has its high points and low points, but some are a lot stronger overall than others.
5 Broad City Season 4
Best Episodes: "Sliding Doors," "Florida," "Friendiversary"
Season 4 kicked off with a promising start by giving viewers the long-awaited origin story of Abbi and Ilana’s friendship, as well as an alternate-universe version of events in which a butterfly effect could have prevented Abbi and Ilana from ever becoming friends. Unfortunately, the season mostly fell flat after that, only picking up steam again in episode 7, “Florida,” in which Abbi and Ilana head down to the Sunshine State to clean out Ilana’s grandma Esther’s apartment. Season 4 redeems itself a little with the finale, "Friendiversary," but the intriguing murder mystery structure isn't enough to save this season from ranking last on this list.
One factor in season 4's placement was the results of the 2016 US Presidential Election, which cast a palpable pall over the whole season as Donald Trump was elected president just a few months before production began. Given Broad City's feminist overtones and vocal support of Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign, it was no surprise that Trump's win would impact the tone of the season. The name "Trump" is even bleeped out throughout the season as though it were an expletive, emphasizing how devastated the girls were about Trump becoming president.
One highlight of the season was The Nanny herself, Fran Drescher, making a guest appearance as Ilana’s aunt in “Florida.” Ilana somehow manages to pull off more and more impossible disguises in the scavenger hunt she set up for Abbi in "Friendiversary" which is another highlight. The joke reaches peak levels of absurdity when Ilana reveals that she "was the horse" that Abbi was riding earlier that day.
4 Broad City Season 5
Best Episodes: "Stories," "Along Came Molly," "Broad City"
Like season 4, the final season of Broad City started strong with the unique format of the premiere episode, "Stories," in which Abbi and Ilana set out to walk from "the tippity-top of Manhattan, to the tipping-bottom" for Abbi's 30th birthday. The ladies document their tumultuous journey through several Instagram stories, which serve as a framing device for almost the entire episode. Season 5 also managed to stick the landing with the penultimate episode and the series finale, both tear-jerking testaments to Abbi and Ilana's heartwarming and enduring friendship.
Unfortunately, the bulk of season 5 is pretty lackluster, relying on the premiere and finale to hold it up. Some highlights include the attention to detail in the Instagram stories in "Stories," including the emojis, stickers, polls, and tagged locations and user accounts. Another highlight is Ilana's aversion to Lincoln's desire to get married, hilariously exclaiming, "Lincoln, I'm 27. What am I, a child bride?" Lastly, the care put into the last two episodes was apparent from start to finish, and even if the rest of the season was only okay, Glazer and Jacobson's commitment to completing their characters' arc the right way was beautifully done.
3 Broad City Season 3
Best Episodes: "Two Chainz," "Game Over," "Burning Bridges"
Broad City season 3 is a real mixed bag: it features some of the show's most hilarious and emotional moments coupled with some that have aged the worst. Season 3 is more Abbi's season than Ilana's, though: while Ilana is getting fired and dumped and infested with rats, Abbi visits her father in her hometown of Philadelphia (albeit with Ilana by her side), and sparks a surprisingly sweet romance with her corny boss, Trey. While season 3 still possesses some of the same Broad City magic that made audiences fall in love with Abbi and Ilana in the first place, it's less consistent than the first two seasons.
Some highlights of season 3 include episode 3, “Game Over,” which marks Ilana's long overdue termination from Deals, Deals, Deals for sharing a bestiality video on the company's official social media accounts. The episode features Ilana wearing a dog hoodie as a crop top, a mistake she’s made not once, not twice, but thrice. "Game Over" also introduced the brilliant phrase “early Randomcore” (with a reference to the old viral video, “Salad Fingers”) to the lexicon to describe a particular style of Internet humor during the early days of YouTube.
Another highlight of season 3 is episode 8 titled "Burning Bridges," in which Ilana’s not-so-casual sexual partner, Lincoln, breaks things off with her, much to Ilana’s devastation. Abbi goes on her first date with Trey, much to her embarrassment. Abbi spends the evening running back and forth between her date with Trey and Ilana's parents' anniversary dinner, which is taking place at the same restaurant, to hide her fling with Trey from Ilana. This whole bit is a parody of the infamous restaurant scene from Mrs. Doubtfire--one of the stars of the film, Mara Wilson, even made a rare cameo in the episode as a waitress.
2 Broad City Season 1
Best Episodes: "Fattest Asses," "Stolen Phone," "The Last Supper"
Broad City season 1 is where it all began. The series premiere starts with a solid introduction to our protagonists that brilliantly establishes their personalities and dynamics with each other. The opening scene shows Abbi and Ilana on a video call discussing plans to get tickets to a secret pop-up Lil Wayne concert when Abbi discovers that Ilana is having sex with Lincoln as they speak.
A major highlight of season 1 is episode 5, “Fattest Asses,” in which Abbi and Ilana hit up a rooftop party, each on their quest: Ilana to let loose from her "stressful" job and get back in touch with the "real" her as opposed to "work" her and Abbi to be less nice and stop letting people take advantage of her. They end up going home with a pair of roommate DJs, who keep trying to manufacture an impromptu foursome. This episode also marks the first of many appearances of Abbi’s iconic blue bodycon dress, which is one of the earliest running gags on Broad City.
Another highlight is the season finale (guest-starring executive producer Amy Poehler), in which Abbi and Ilana celebrate Abbi's birthday with a fancy dinner gifted by Abbi's parents. The elegance of the evening is tainted by Abbi discovering that she's had a used condom stuck inside her for four days and Ilana's severe allergic reaction to shellfish, which sends her into anaphylactic shock. The two of them end their evening at the ER reciting their bucket lists, which include "go to a pug farm," "do heroin," and "be held in Abbi's arms," the last of which Ilana accomplished that night.
1 Broad City Season 2
Best Episodes: "Knockoffs," "Hashtag FOMO," "Kirk Steele," "St. Marks"
Of all five seasons, season 2 feels the most quintessential Broad City. That same authentic humor from season 1 successfully carries over into Broad City's sophomore season. While there are so many highlights from season 2 to choose from, a couple of major standouts are the alter egos: In episode 5, "Hashtag FOMO," viewers are introduced to Val, Abbi's jazz-singing alter ego who only comes out when she's blackout drunk. Ilana meets "Val" when Abbi leads them to an underground, 1930s cabaret-style speakeasy, and proceeds to perform onstage in character. Episode 8, "Kirk Steele," marks the introduction of the titular, frosted-tipped porn star alter ego, who turns out to be a younger Trey.
However, the biggest highlight of Broad City season 2 has to be episode 4, "Knockoffs." Viewers were introduced to Ilana's parents, Bobbi and Arthur Wexler, who are in town from Long Island to sit Shiva for Ilana's recently deceased grandmother, Esther. As for Abbi, "Knockoffs" marks her first and only sexual encounter with her neighbor, Jeremy, whom she has a huge crush on. Abbi pegs for the first time, an act she is forced to explain to Ilana's whole family at Esther's Shiva after Bobbi finds the strap-on dildo in her bag. Between Bobbi's obsession with knockoff designer bags and Ilana declaring Abbi a "peg-asus," "Knockoffs" is chock-full of comedic gems.



































































































