Brooklyn Nine-Nine ended in September 2021 and left its audience with a heartwarming conclusion (in which the iconic members of the 99th precinct continue to stay in touch through their old workplace traditions after their lives lead them down diverging paths). The levity of the conclusion was satisfying and left much to reminisce about the last 8 seasons of the series, including the iconic cold opens.
The Brooklyn Nine-Nine cold opens are punchy, witty and memorable in the way they create emotion and tension to build humor in a short scene. The avid fans of the show had something to say about their thoughts on some of the best cold opens on Reddit.
The Red Hat
Captain Holt walks into the precinct wearing an egregious red hat. The bullpen is silent as he confidently moves to his office. The scene pans to the confused, concerned, and offput reactions of his coworkers as he passes them. Captain Holt turns to his coworkers when he reaches the door to his quarters and exclaims "Fine, I was trying something, and it didn't work!"
One Redditor pixelunicorns noted that this scene "always made [them] laugh," showing appreciation for the way Peralta wordlessly captures a photo of the captain in the hat, starstruck by the ridiculousness of the moment. This cold open really successfully plays on the physical comedy of the presence and emotion of each character as they process the scene, and the hilarity when Holt cries out indignant, true to character in a circumstance that is not very common for the poignant captain.
The Gang Pranks Captain Holt
In this cold open, Captain Holt has an overjoyed reaction toward a prank that is entirely too underwhelming for his co-workers. After setting up the scene with intense deliberation about how the members of the 99th precinct should go about pranking Captain Holt without causing a disturbance, they settle on a very underwhelming change to the meeting room, by moving the podium a marginal shift to the left.
Redittor meh3191 notes this cold open as being one of their "favorites" due to the amused reaction Holt displays when he discovers how his team pranked him. Holt goes on to call his husband about it, making it out to seem like the best prank ever. It's certainly one of the most underappreciated cold opens that deserves a lot more love from the fans.
Jake's Arch Nemesis and Terry's Lack of One
One Redditor YourKnightHarsh posted a clip of this cold open claiming it could "be a contender for the best." In the scene, Terry counters Peralta when he declares he doesn't have an arch nemesis unlike Jake, because he actually solves all of his cases. Jake is, comedically, taken aback, with a reaction that sells how deeply the jab struck for him.
This cold open is sold by the way the scene captures each nuanced expression in the intense stare-down between Terry and Jake after Terry drops the huge truth bomb against Jake. It's also particularly funny for having pointed out one of Jake's flaws as a detective in a way that is deserving after the way he behaves in the brief.
Dianne Wiest Infection
Charles makes a musical theatre pun, to which Jake does not explode with any reaction. The pair have a stare off with two entertaining expressions until the cut-off end of the cold open when Charles excitedly explains the joke "LIKE YEAST!"
The comedic power of the anti-joke Charles creates in explaining his own pun is not lost on OzzyAtom, who believed it to be the "BEST cold open." The comedic timing of the intro cutting off Charles' unnecessary addition to the original joke also makes the cold open more animated, in that the show itself too, rejects Charles' awkwardly executed attempt at a "classic Jake" type of pun.
Holt's First Marshmallow
The gang all has a go at impressions of Captain Holt, the scenario, him eating a marshmallow. The group uses distinguished and unimpressed vocabulary to describe the characteristics and experience of eating a marshmallow, all with Holt's trademark intone.
Holt's unexpected and entertaining reaction, along with Charles' unlikely victory in the competition is appreciated by Redditor sideofman, who lists some of their "favorite cold open". In contrast to the group, Charles giggles in a very non-Holt like fashion when prompted to act like Holt eating a marshmallow. In a surprising and hilarious turn of events Charles' impression is actually the most accurate, which is a rare win for Charles, delivered with a very unconventional reaction from Captain Holt.
Amy's Late to Work
The gang proposes outlandish guesses or reasons why Amy, who in a lovably nerdy fashion, is always punctual, could possibly be late to work. The comedy and suspense builds with each guess, and when she arrives, she confirms her excuse, which matched Holt's, the least glamorous reason. He responds with a hearty "HOT DAMN!"
One Redditor, chellynaeb, states that Holt's energetic declaration of "hot damn" makes this "one of the funniest cold open." Holt demonstrates a surprisingly accurate knowledge of Amy's character, and feels rightfully victorious both of which combine to create an unexpected and humorous scene to kick off the show.
"Thanks Dad"
Jake calls Captain Holt dad in a Freudian slip, to which Holt makes a string of follow up jokes, taunting Jake for the slip up, which he vehemently denies. Everyone in the precinct, including Jake's perp tease him about the slip up with increasingly funny puns and retorts to his denial.
Redditor LockmanCapulet made a post in appreciation of the whole sequence, which they claimed their "favorite" bit in the show altogether. The scene reaches its peak at the end, when Holt proposes they discuss the incident over a game of catch, in a joking manner much like the rest of the precinct, only in the end Jake gives in and admits he would like that, and no longer denies the slip-up.
Soup Pants
Detective Peralta pieces together that Captain Holt is sitting in his office not wearing any pants. He follows up on his theory through extensive attempts to prove it correct, and ultimately, Holt admits the truth and confirms Jake's theory to stop his time-wasting efforts. In his victorious celebration Jake makes the same fatal mistake that led to Holt's pantlessness in the first place.
One Redditor, Etagnirps, commented on their "favorite" part of the scene right at the end, when Jake says to Amy, "Look at us, just three people with pants on, having a normal conversation." The hilarity of this open is not lost throughout the various hoops Jake jumps through to achieve his goal, only to end up in an Icarus situation where he got too close to glory and paid the price for it.
Backstreet Boys
Detective Peralta has a lineup of five unexpectedly incredible singers harmonize "I Want It That Way" by the Backstreet Boys to solve a murder and, as he gets so into the moment, he forgets the singing is a crucial clue that leads the witness next to him to identify her brother's killer.
Redditor LeptomyrmexRuficeps notes this open in particular as being a known "fan favorite." Part of what makes the scene feel so lively is the absurdity that Detective Peralta would even request the lineup of suspects to start singing, let alone one of the best songs played in Brooklyn Nine-Nine. The performance is so breath-taking that the objective is lost on the detective, even while he stands next to a grieving family member.
The Full Bullpen
For PhanThief95, their "favorite" cold open is the "Full Bullpen," which sees Jake try to slide across the entire floor in his socks while the rest of the detectives cheer him on. However, right near the finish line, the elevator opens, revealing Captain Holt.
Everyone's faces switch to shock and dread in anticipation of the Captain's response to such shenanigans in the workplace, and potentially getting slammed into by a sliding detective Peralta. Jake slides right into the elevator and the doors close. However, it is Captain Holt's reaction that really sells it as he holds Jake's hand up high and excitedly shouts "THE FULL BULLPEN!"