Soon a new generation of super soldiers will be upon us as The United States of Captain America slowly approaches, a story that will introduce Cap to different Captain Americas from around The United States. With a vast amount of new Caps coming, perhaps fans should look back to the ones they've already had.
Many people have donned the stars and stripes, but some have been better than others. Some have had tenures with the shield that have been legendary, some have only held the shield for a cup of coffee, and some have used it to do terrible things.
Stevil
Looking back, Secret Empire was a pretty cool story, but it's impossible to look at Stevil's time as Captain America as anything less than an affront to the moniker. The fan-dubbed Stevil is a warped version of Steve Rogers who was altered by Red Skull's use of The Cosmic Cube to be a Hydra sleeper agent.
Not only was the reveal that Cap was pro-Hydra shocking, but his subsequent takeover of the organization and later the country was equally effective. Soon both Sam Wilson and the real Steve Rogers would team up to dethrone this imposter.
William Burnside
When Marvel brought Cap back to join The Avengers, they accidentally created a continuity issue, as Cap had made a few notable appearances after he was supposed to have gone into the ice. This included a less than stellar run in the '50s with Cap and Bucky battling communists.
This Captain America was retconned to be William Burnside, a deranged Captain America fanboy who took up the mantle on his own misguided volition. Burnside was beaten by Cap and his partner The Falcon, he was then manipulated into becoming the leader of a Neo-Nazi group known as The Grand Director.
John Walker
John Walker has received a bit of attention lately, as his brief period as a deeply problematic Captain America has been covered by The Falcon & The Winter Soldier. Walker's tenure as Cap in the comics wasn't much better, as his time wielding the shield after Steve Rogers became disillusioned by the government was rife with problems.
During the time he was Captain America, Walker's brutal actions led to the death of his parents, which resulted in him violently murdering their killers. Pretty soon after this event, Walker voluntarily handed the shield back to Rogers before becoming US Agent.
William Naslund
If fate was on his side, William Naslund's time as Captain America could have been far more notable. Formerly the hero known as Spirit of '76, Naslund was selected by President Harry Truman to don the red, white, and blue tights when Captain America went into the ice.
Teaming up with Fred Davis as Bucky, Naslund teamed up with the team known as The All-Winners Squad. While the team was attempting to stop the android Adam II's attempt to assassinate future president John F. Kennedy, Naslund was murdered.
Clint Barton
The fact that Clint Barton was a better Captain America for one night than Stevil, Burnside, and Walker combined has got to be sobering for those three. After Steve Rogers was killed in the aftermath of Civil War, Tony Stark gave the shield to none other than Hawkeye himself, Clint Barton.
Barton proved to be skilled with the shield, using it to help The Young Avengers battle D-List villain Firebrand. However, a pep talk from Kate Bishop saw Barton relinquish the shield, prompting Stark to pass the mantle to the person that Rogers wanted it passed to.
Bucky Barnes
Bucky Barnes wasn't in a great place at the time, as he had murdered several people as the brainwashed assassin The Winter Soldier. In fact, when Tony Stark handed him the mantle as part of Steve Rogers' wishes, Bucky asked for his memories as The Winter Soldier to be erased.
Bucky was certainly an interesting Captain America, leading The Avengers and wearing one of the coolest Cap suits in history. Even when Steve Rogers came back from the dead, Bucky still fought as Captain America, as Steve had become the director of SHIELD.
Jeffery Mace
Once known as the hero Patriot, Jeffery Mace was assisting The All-Winner's Squad battle Adam II when he came across Naslund's dead body. In a panic, he donned the suit and helped finish the fight before telling Naslund's teammates the truth. Mace would join The Squad as Cap, becoming good friends with Fred Davis.
Mace's story has a somewhat happy ending, as after a long period of battle and hardships he got to be the first Captain America to retire. He then married his sidekick Betty Ross aka Golden Girl and would live a normal life before dying of cancer.
Sam Wilson
Currently Captain America in The MCU, Sam Wilson is easily the second most iconic Captain America next to Steve Rogers, and for good reason. When Steve Rogers was turned into an old man, he entrusted his former partner The Falcon with the moniker of Captain America.
Though his time as Cap was met with ill-conceived backlash, in the storyline, Sam proved how worthy he was of the shield, battling snake cults, lycanthropy, and racism across the country. Though the end of his run wasn't as strong as it should have been, Sam Wilson's time as Captain America will be remembered for generations to come.
Isaiah Bradley
Truth: Red, White, and Black is a glimpse at an element of World War II that America would like to forget, as its protagonist Isaiah Bradley is forced to overcome the widespread racism of the time to become his own Captain America. Put in a platoon of Black soldiers who were experimented on with the Super Soldier Serum, Bradley stole the Cap suit when Rogers was unable to carry out a mission.
To say that this didn't go well would be an understatement, as he was captured by Hitler, escaped by the skin of his teeth, and later imprisoned for stealing the uniform, but still maintained his core goodness. After being pardoned, Bradley's mind regressed to that of a child due to receiving a faulty dose of the serum, but he has nonetheless become a legend in the superhero community.
Steve Rogers
The original Captain America and perhaps still the best. Steve Rogers has a pretty unfair advantage over the other people who have donned the stars and stripes, as he has been Captain America for the longest time.
Watching Steve Rogers evolve as the decades have passed has engrossed comic book readers for a long time, with the character receiving mostly consistent characterization. Though he has vacated the role a few times, Steve Rogers will always come back to fight evil as The Star-Spangled Man with a plan.