Summary
- Cities: Skylines 2 is currently experiencing significant performance issues, potentially hindering gameplay and preventing players from fully enjoying the game.
- The game's rendering of individual NPC teeth, without adjusting detail based on proximity or resource allocation, is unnecessarily draining performance and causing further issues.
- The developer, Colossal Order, used a character design tool that generated detailed NPCs without optimization, leading to the need for an overhaul or an implementation of a level of detail system to improve performance.
Cities: Skylines 2 has proven essentially unplayable for many people, and a potential reason for the situation is strangely granular and more than a little bit silly. As a follow-up to the hugely successful city building simulator Cities: Skylines, the newest game from developer Colossal Order Ltd. had some major shoes to fill. It's possible that the game will be able to live up to its predecessor, but it's difficult to have a conversation about features and improvements when performance is getting in the way of doing much of anything.
It's not particularly surprising that a complex sim like Cities: Skylines 2 could run into some frame rate issues once planning gets complex enough, as the sheer amount of calculations being made and resources being handled has some inherent potential for slowdown. At the moment, however, even many strong PCs can't handle the game well at all, suggesting the need for some post-launch optimization if it's going to have the staying power of its predecessor. The developer has already offered reassurance that Cities: Skylines 2 fixes are coming, but taking care of everything that's currently wrong could require going in unusual directions.
Cities: Skylines 2 Is Rendering Individual NPC Teeth
NPCs in a city builder generally act as minor decorations — occasionally engaging to watch, but mostly from a bird's-eye view. Consequently, a distant overhead view doesn't need to render them as anything more than basic low-poly models, but Cities: Skylines 2 seems to have missed the memo in that regard. As pointed out by Hexcoder0 on Reddit, the game appears to render model detail down to individual teeth without any system in place to adjust the detail depending on proximity or resource allocation, posing what would obviously be a significant drain on performance for no good reason at all.
Why Cities: Skylines 2 NPCs Are So Detailed
A behind the scenes post from Colossal Order goes into detail on the process of crafting NPCs for Cities: Skylines 2, and it helps to explain why there's so much unnecessary detail involved. As explained in the post, Colossal Order used a character design tool called Popul8, which procedurally generates models in batches that they reviewed and tweaked for inclusion. The model complexity allows for cool features like NPCs changing clothing according to the weather, but no optimization to remove irrelevant details like teeth appears to have ever been performed.
Overhauling and optimizing the NPC system seems like it may be a challenge, but leaving it as is will likely continue to make performance a non-starter on many PCs. At the very least, the inclusion of a robust LOD (level of detail) system to handle just how many of these details are being rendered at any given time seems like a necessity. Cities: Skylines 2 is certainly impressive in many regards, but one detail that it could absolutely do without is a full row of teeth for every NPC that crowds its streets.
A statement from Paradox and Colossal Order on this issue follows:
Citizen lifepath feature does not tie to citizen geometry and does not affect the performance figures of the characters.
We know the characters require further work, as they are currently missing their LODs which affect some parts of performance. We are working on bringing these to the game along general LODs improvements across all game assets. Characters feature a lot of details that, while seemingly unnecessary now, will become relevant in the future of the project.
Source: Hexcoder0/Reddit, Colossal Order