The Cold Case reboot at CBS is reportedly not moving forward. The crime procedural aired on CBS for seven seasons from 2003 to 2010, following Detective Lilly Rush (Kathryn Morris), a homicide Detective with the Philadelphia Police Department who specializes in cold cases and, for most of the show, partners with Detective Scotty Valens (Danny Pino). In April 2024, it was reported that the network was in negotiations with Warner Bros. TV for a Cold Case reboot from the show's original creator, Meredith Stiehm.

Now, months after the revival was first reported, the negotiations have reportedly reached a breaking point. According to Deadline, the Cold Case reboot is no longer moving forward at CBS. The report specifies that the project "didn’t make it past the deal-making stage."

Why The Cold Case Reboot Isn't Moving Forward

The Two Sides Were Unable To Reach An Agreement

With Meredith Stiehm returning as the lead writer, the Cold Case reboot was set 15 years after the original series ended and would have followed an all-new team of determined detectives investigating cold cases throughout the Southwest. Unlike the original series, which was based in Philadelphia, the new setting would have offered the opportunity to introduce a fresh cast of characters. Even so, Danny Pino reportedly had informal discussions about reprising his role as Detective Scotty Valens, while there was also a possibility that Kathryn Morris could have appeared in a limited capacity as Detective Lilly Rush.

At the time the Cold Case reboot was initially reported in April 2024​​​​​​​, negotiations between CBS and Warner Bros. TV had already been ongoing for quite some time, and the two sides were still nowhere closer to an agreement. The two sides reportedly faced similar obstacles as when they were negotiating a renewal of East New York in 2023, and CBS requested additional streaming rights. After months of back-and-forth, those negotiations ultimately fell through and now the Cold Case reboot isn't moving forward, likely due to similar issues.

Our Take On The Cold Case Reboot Not Moving Forward

It's Probably For The Best

Danny Pino and Kathryn Morris in Cold Case promotional still
Danny Pino and Kathryn Morris in Cold Case promotional still

The Cold Case reboot not moving forward is probably for the best. There is currently an inundation of crime and police procedural shows on network television from NCIS, Law & Order, Criminal Minds, and more. While a Cold Case reboot may have appealed to die-hard fans of the show's original run, it would have unlikely been able to stand out among the crowded competition. Additionally, without the return of Kathryn Morris as Detective Lilly Rush or Danny Pino as Detective Scotty Valen, it's unlikely the Cold Case reboot would have carried much appeal anyway.

Source: Deadline

0323710_poster_w780-1.jpg
24
9.8/10

Cold Case

Release Date
2003 - 2010-00-00
Network
CBS
Directors
Alex Zakrzewski, Kevin Bray, Holly Dale, Paris Barclay, Roxann Dawson, Chris Fisher, Jeannot Szwarc, Mark Pellington, David Von Ancken, David Barrett, James Whitmore Jr., Agnieszka Holland, Marcos Siega, Tim Matheson, John Peters, Tim Hunter, Bill Eagles, Craig Ross Jr., David Straiton, Donald E. Thorin Jr., Emilio Estevez, Greg Yaitanes, John F. Showalter, John Finn
Writers
Veena Sud, Liz W. Garcia, Greg Plageman, Tyler Bensinger, Sean Whitesell, Christopher Silber, Gavin Harris, Jennifer Johnson, Elwood Reid, Erica Shelton Kodish, Jan Oxenberg, Taylor Elmore, Andrea Newman, Karin Lewicki, Jay Beattie, Kim Newton, Ryan Farley, Adam Glass, Dan Dworkin, Stacy Kravetz, Denise Thé, Chris Mundy, Danny Pino, Elle Triedman
  • Headshot Of Kathryn Morris
    Kathryn Morris
    Lilly Rush
  • Headshot Of Danny Pino
    Danny Pino
    Scotty Valens
Seasons
7
Main Genre
Crime
Creator(s)
Meredith Stiehm