Summary

  • Ebert loved Hellboy, describing it as "vibrating with energy" and praising the talents of Guillermo del Toro and Ron Perlman.
  • Ebert enjoyed The Amazing Spider-Man, calling it the "second best" Spider-Man movie and appreciating its action scenes.
  • Ebert thought The Crow was a "stunning work of visual style" and the best comic book universe adaptation he had seen.

The late Roger Ebert remains one of the most noted film critics of a generation, and he held a certain affection for comic book movies. For many years, Ebert was considered the defining voice among film critics. Known for his ability to bridge the gap between in-depth cinematic analysis and language accessible to the less-versed in filmmaking jargon, Ebert’s work as a critic spanned 45 years. Over the course of his career, Roger Ebert was known to love terrible movies on occasion, but largely his work formed a key part of the critical consensus on new releases spanning decades.

The nature of Ebert’s career warranted a particularly wide palate for film, serving as a critic for movies across practically every genre imaginable. Although Ebert died in 2013, just as the movies of the MCU were hitting their stride and achieving massive success, the famed critic harbored a keen appreciation of comic book movies. A fan of its grandiose scale and imagery, Ebert was vocal in his love for the genre. Despite the fact that many critics are quick to voice their disdain for the rise of superhero cinema, here are 10 comic book movies that Roger Ebert loved.

10 Ebert Enjoyed Hellboy's Combination of Guillermo Del Toro & Ron Perlman

Ebert's score: 3.5/4 stars

Ron Perlman as Hellboy in Hellboy (2004) with his hands on his legs
Ron Perlman as Hellboy in Hellboy (2004) with his hands on his legs

Based on Mike Mignola's comic book series of the same name, 2004's Hellboy combined the talents of director Guillermo del Toro with Ron Perlman, who starred as the titular demonic paranormal investigator. Ebert gave the film a positive review, describing it as “vibrating with energy,” and that he could “sense the zeal and joy in its making.” Ebert also praised its star, describing Perlman as “an actor in the process of making an impossible character really work.” From his comments and the impressive rating, it’s clear that Ebert was a fan of Del Toro’s work on the film.

9 Ebert Thought The Amazing Spider-Man Was A Solid Reboot

Ebert's score: 3.5/4 stars

Though Andrew Garfield appeared in multiple Spider-Man movies, the only one released ahead of Ebert’s death was his first, The Amazing Spider-Man. Ebert enjoyed the rebooted origin story of the iconic hero, dubbing it the “second best” Spider-Man movie and praising multiple elements of Marc Webb’s film. Though he questioned the necessity of a reboot so soon after Raimi’s trilogy, he believed The Amazing Spider-Man was “a more thoughtful film,” and that “its action scenes are easier to follow in space and time.” Considering Ebert’s appreciation of Raimi’s movies, his remarks about Garfield’s Spider-Man should be considered particularly high praise.

01376729_poster_w780.jpg

In Andrew Garfield's first film as the iconic Marvel superhero, Peter Parker gains his powers and his alter ego as Spider-Man. Meanwhile, the Lizard is a growing threat, and Spider-Man must use his newfound abilities to save the day.
 

Cast
Andrew Garfield, Emma Stone, Rhys Ifans, Denis Leary, Martin Sheen, Sally Field, Irrfan Khan, Campbell Scott, Embeth Davidtz, Chris Zylka, Max Charles, C. Thomas Howell, Jake Keiffer, Kari Coleman, Michael Barra, Leif Gantvoort, Andy Pessoa, Hannah Marks, Kelsey Asbille, Kevin McCorkle, Andy Gladbach, Ring Hendricks-Tellefsen, Barbara Eve Harris, Stan Lee, Danielle Burgio
Runtime
136 minutes
Director
Marc Webb
Writers
James Vanderbilt, Alvin Sargent, Steve Kloves
Franchise(s)
Spider-Man

8 Ebert Liked The Crow's Atmospheric Nature

Ebert's score: 3.5/4 stars

Brandon Lee looking menacing in The Crow

Now known as a cult classic, The Crow is a macabre piece of Hollywood history. Starring Brandon Lee, the son of Bruce Lee, in his debut, it also saw an on-set accident that resulted in the actor's death. The story follows Eric Draven (Lee), a musician killed on the eve of his wedding who returns from the dead to exact revenge on his killers. The morbid irony wasn’t lost on Ebert, who appreciated the film, describing it as “a stunning work of visual style” and “the best version of a comic book universe [he’d] seen.”

the crow poster TLDR vertical
The Crow
15
8.3/10
Release Date
May 11, 1994

The Crow, directed by Alex Proyas, follows Eric Draven, portrayed by Brandon Lee, as he returns from the dead to avenge his and his fiancée's tragic murders. Set in a moody, atmospheric cityscape, the film blends elements of supernatural and action as Draven seeks retribution against the criminals responsible.

Cast
Brandon Lee, Rochelle Davis, Ernie Hudson, Michael Wincott, Bai Ling, Sofia Shinas, Anna Thomson, David Patrick Kelly, Angel David, Laurence Mason, michael massee, Tony Todd, Jon Polito, Bill Raymond, Marco Rodríguez, Kim Sykes, Rock Taulbee, Norman Max Maxwell, Jeff Cadiente, Henry Kingi Jr., Erik Stabenau, Cassandra Lawton, Lou Criscuolo, Todd Brenner, Joe West, Thomas Rosales Jr., Jeff Imada, Tierre Turner, Tim Parati
Runtime
102 Minutes
Director
Alex Proyas
Writers
David J. Schow, John Shirley
Franchise(s)
The Crow

7 Blade II Impressed Ebert More Than The Original

Ebert's score: 3.5/4 stars

Nomak and Wesley Snipes' Blade fighting in Blade II (2002)
Nomak and Wesley Snipes' Blade fighting in Blade II (2002)

Blade II is widely considered the best movie of the Blade trilogy, known for its brilliant action sequences. Directed by Guillermo Del Toro, the film follows Marvel’s vampire-hunting hero as he joins forces with his sworn enemies to fight a new species of bloodsucker known as the Reapers. Ebert enjoyed the film, believing it an improvement on its predecessor, and describing it as “a really rather brilliant vomitorium of viscera, a comic book with dreams of becoming a textbook for mad surgeons.” Ebert’s praise for the movie specifically cited its impressive visual effects and Del Toro’s direction.

0153797_poster_w780.jpg
Blade II
8.6/10
Release Date
March 22, 2002
Cast
Wesley Snipes, Kris Kristofferson, Ron Perlman, Leonor Varela, Norman Reedus, Thomas Kretschmann, Luke Goss, Matt Schulze, Danny John-Jules, Donnie Yen, Karel Roden, Marit Velle Kile, Tony Curran, Daz Crawford, Santiago Segura, Samuel Le, Marek Vašut, Pete Lee-Wilson, Paul Kasey, Andrea Miltner, Ladislav Beran, Jiří Maria Sieber, Bridge Markland, Jamie Wilson, Stuart Luis
Runtime
117 minutes
Director
Guillermo del Toro
Writers
David S. Goyer, Marv Wolfman, Gene Colan
Franchise
Blade Trilogy

6 Ebert Thought Superman II Perfectly Represented The Hero

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

Christopher Reeve's Superman bows to Terence Stamp's Zod in Superman II
Christopher Reeve's Superman bows to Terence Stamp's Zod in Superman II

Superman II picked up the Man of Steel’s story from the end of Richard Donner’s 1978 film Superman, introducing the Kryptonian villain General Zod. Ebert offered some very high praise for the film, giving it a perfect score and musing on some of its deeper themes. His review acknowledges that director Richard Lester “permits satire to make its way into the film more easily” and that “he draws out Christopher Reeve, whose performance in the title role is sly, knowing, and yet still appropriately square.” It’s clear that Ebert enjoyed Superman II, and considered it an excellent sequel.

5 Batman Begins

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

Batman (Christian Bale) stands stoically inside a warehouse as he prepares to fight some thugs in Batman Begins
Batman stands stoically inside a warehouse as he prepares to fight some thugs.

Ebert was fond of Christopher Nolan’s Batman Begins, and gave the first film of his trilogy a glowing review. Ebert described Batman Begins as “the Batman movie [he’d] been waiting for,” stating that “the character resonates more deeply with [him] than the other comic superheroes.” His favorable review cited many aspects of the film as particularly noteworthy, appreciating the more thoughtful approach to adapting the hero’s origin story. Ebert even comments on the many different live-action versions of Batman, and suggests that Christian Bale’s could well become the definitive iteration.

0144341_poster_w780.jpg
Batman Begins
110
8.9/10
Release Date
June 15, 2005

Batman Begins is the inaugural film in Christopher Nolan's Batman trilogy, featuring Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne. Released in 2005, it follows Wayne as he transforms into Batman to combat the pervasive corruption in Gotham City, creating a new identity to fight crime outside the system.

Cast
Christian Bale, Michael Caine, Liam Neeson, Katie Holmes, Gary Oldman, Cillian Murphy, Tom Wilkinson, Rutger Hauer, Ken Watanabe, Mark Boone Junior, Linus Roache, Morgan Freeman, Larry Holden, Gerard Murphy, Colin McFarlane, Sara Stewart, Gus Lewis, Richard Brake, Rade Šerbedžija, Emma Lockhart, Christine Adams, Catherine Porter, John Nolan, Karen David, Jonathan D. Ellis
Runtime
140 minutes
Writers
Christopher Nolan, Bob Kane, David S. Goyer
Distributor(s)
Warner Bros. Pictures

4 Iron Man

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

Coming as it did at the very beginning of the MCU’s movie timeline, Ebert had no way of knowing quite how important a film Iron Man would become. Even so, the famed critic thoroughly enjoyed the film, offering a great deal of praise for Robert Downey Jr.’s performance and assessing how perfect a casting decision it was. He explains: “Tony Stark is created from the persona Downey has fashioned through many movies: irreverent, quirky, self-deprecating, [and] wise-cracking,” precisely communicating exactly what it is about Iron Man that made it such an important film for the MCU.

78lptwv72etnqfw9cobyi0dwdja.jpg
Iron Man
119
9.2/10
Release Date
April 30, 2008

Iron Man is the first film in the long-running Marvel Cinematic Universe franchise. Robert Downey Jr. stars as Tony Stark, a billionaire inventor who builds a powerful suit of armor to survive captivity and later uses his creation to protect humanity, embarking on a perilous journey.

Cast
Robert Downey Jr., Terrence Howard, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow, Leslie Bibb, Shaun Toub, Faran Tahir, Clark Gregg, Bill Smitrovich, Sayed Badreya, Paul Bettany, Jon Favreau, Peter Billingsley, Tim Guinee, Will Lyman, Tom Morello, Marco Khan, Daston Kalili, Ido Mor, Kevin Foster, Garret Noël, Eileen Weisinger, Ahmed Ahmed, Fahim Fazli, Gerard Sanders
Runtime
126 minutes
Director
Jon Favreau
Writers
Mark Fergus, Matt Holloway, Art Marcum, Hawk Ostby

3 Superman

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

Christopher Reeve as Superman floating in the sky with the Metropolis cityscape behind him.
Christopher Reeve as Superman floating in the sky with the Metropolis cityscape behind him.

Often credited as the film that built the foundation of modern superhero movies, Richard Donner’s 1978 film Superman brought the titular hero to life in groundbreaking fashion. Ebert was a big fan of the film, labeling it “a wondrous combination of all the old-fashioned things we never really get tired of.” Ebert’s review gushed about the cleverly written humor and awe-inspiring special effects, describing the latter as “as good in their way as any you've seen.” In his assessment of the film, Ebert communicated exactly the reasons that superhero cinema has remained such a dominant box office force.

2 The Dark Knight

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

The Dark Knight is commonly considered one of the best superhero movies ever made, and Ebert held the film in similarly high regard. Describing the battle between Batman and the Joker as having “more depth and poetry than we might have expected,” Ebert gave the film a glowing review that also waxed poetic on the way in which it elevated the genre, explaining that “these stories touch on deep fears, traumas, fantasies and hopes.” Ebert’s appreciation for The Dark Knight earned Nolan’s film a perfect rating, making it another comic book movie that the renowned critic truly loved.

01386160_poster_w780.jpg
The Dark Knight
10/10
165
9.5/10
Release Date
July 16, 2008

The Dark Knight, directed by Christopher Nolan, is the second installment in the Batman trilogy starring Christian Bale as Batman. Released in 2008, the film follows Batman’s alliance with Jim Gordon and Harvey Dent as they combat the organized crime that threatens Gotham, facing the menacing Joker.

Cast
Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Aaron Eckhart, Gary Oldman, Michael Caine, Morgan Freeman, Monique Gabriela Curnen, Ron Dean, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Cillian Murphy, Chin Han, Nestor Carbonell, Eric Roberts, Ritchie Coster, Anthony Michael Hall, Keith Szarabajka, Colin McFarlane, Joshua Harto, Melinda McGraw, Nathan Gamble, Michael Vieau, Michael Stoyanov, William Smillie, Danny Goldring, Michael Jai White
Runtime
152 minutes
Writers
Christopher Nolan, Bob Kane, Jonathan Nolan, David S. Goyer

1 Spider-Man 2

Ebert's score: 4/4 stars

The train passengers looking at Tobey Maguire as Spider-Man in Spider-Man 2
The train passengers looking at Tobey Maguire as Spider-Man in Spider-Man 2

The second film in Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy, Spider-Man 2, is widely considered the best of the three, and Ebert agreed. In fact, Ebert described the film as being “what a superhero movie should be,” praising its perfectly balanced tone and adaptation of the source material. Ebert identified that the film’s biggest strength was its exploration of the human side of the titular hero, going as far as to dub it “the best superhero movie since the modern genre was launched,” and from his praise, it’s clear that Roger Ebert considered himself a fan of comic book movies.

01357305_poster_w780.jpg
Spider-Man 2
103
9.1/10
Release Date
June 30, 2004

After defeating the Green Goblin, Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man struggles with self-doubt in both his superhero career and his personal life. But when Alfred Molina's Doctor Octopus threatens Peter Parker's loved ones, the web-crawler must stay true to his heroic purpose and don the mask once again in this second installment of Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy.

Cast
Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst, James Franco, Alfred Molina, Rosemary Harris, J.K. Simmons, Donna Murphy, Daniel Gillies, Dylan Baker, Bill Nunn, Vanessa Ferlito, Aasif Mandvi, Willem Dafoe, Cliff Robertson, Ted Raimi, Elizabeth Banks, Bruce Campbell, Gregg Edelman, Elya Baskin, Mageina Tovah, Daniel Dae Kim, Hal Sparks, Joel McHale, Stan Lee, Kelly Connell
Runtime
127 minutes
Director
Sam Raimi
Writers
Alvin Sargent, Alfred Gough, Miles Millar, Michael Chabon