The Dark Souls trilogy has its own ups and downs, but as an overall package, it's easily one of the more iconic franchises in video game history, selling over 40 million copies across all platforms (if you include the Remastered release). That said, we have recently passed a decade since the release of Dark Souls 3, with the series remaining relatively quiet since then.

FromSoftware has obviously been pretty busy in the intervening period, dropping some other all-time classics along the way, including the sprawling, beloved RPG Elden Ring. What the developer's future plans are (beyond the release of The Duskbloods on Nintendo Switch 2) remains pretty unclear, and fans can't agree on what exactly they want them to do next.

Dark Souls 3 image from trailer-1

Over on Reddit, one user shared a post in which they contended that their ideal scenario would be FromSoftware bringing out a fourth Dark Souls game, rather than potentially focusing on a sequel to Elden Ring.

Though they were far from alone in that opinion, many of the responses disagreed vehemently for a variety of reasons. "I'd rather not. Dark Souls 3 ended on an almost perfect note for the franchise and I'd rather just leave the story where it ended," one comment read.

While others want a more linear experience to return next time out, though not as part of the Dark Souls series. "I think they excelled in small map design. I loved Elden Ring, but I felt more drawn and compelled to every aspect of the story when it was more contained rather than scattered like ashes to the nine winds. I would play for hours until rediscovering a character and their arc," one response added.

"I don’t necessarily want Dark Souls 4, but definitely want a new game that’s more Dark Souls than it is Elden Ring, if that makes sense," a third said.

Another put forward an entirely different FromSoftware game as the blueprint for the future, saying, "I’ll do you one better. I don’t want either [of them]. The Souls formula has gone as far as it can to the point there’s nothing more you can do with these combat mechanisms. To offer the challenge which is essential to the game’s formula, the bosses are now just way overtuned. Sekiro proved FromSoft can do something different, so that’s where I want the future to be. Give us new stuff and not more iterations of a 17-year-old formula."

FromSoftware game protagonists from Elden Ring, Bloodborne, DS3, Sekiro, and others
FromSoftware game protagonists from Elden Ring, Bloodborne, DS3, Sekiro, and others

Whatever FromSoftware is cooking up, we know they have several unannounced projects in the work. Whether it's a follow-up to one of their already beloved releases like Dark Souls or something entirely new, we're sure there will be plenty of people lining up to see what it is.

mixcollage-07-dec-2024-08-39-am-2204.jpg
Action RPG
Systems
Top Critic Avg: 90/100 Critics Rec: 94%
Released
March 24, 2016
ESRB
M for Mature: Blood Violence
Developer(s)
From Software
Publisher(s)
Bandai Namco Entertainment, From Software
Engine
havok, proprietary engine
Multiplayer
Online Co-Op, Online Multiplayer
Franchise
Dark Souls

Genre(s)
Action RPG