Summary

  • The DCEU features some confusing dialogue that has sometimes contradicted previous characterizations and undermined the movies.
  • The inclusion of certain lines, like the Joker's inappropriate remark, have derailed important scenes and felt out of place.
  • Some dialogue, like Superman's "Save Martha" line, has caused contention among audiences and seemed clunky and unjustified.

The DCEU is celebrated for its compelling stories, but it still features some rather confusing dialogue. The DCEU timeline has spanned an impressive 10 years, spawning numerous renowned movies adapting DC Comics' characters and stories. Numerous beloved superheroes and villains have been adapted through their interconnected narratives. While these characters are familiar to many audiences, they have sometimes delivered some unexpected and illogical dialogue.

The DCEU franchise famously varies from movie to movie, but on the whole, they are deftly crafted and highly compelling. However, there were some notable issues so conspicuous that they were addressed by filmmakers and even subsequent movies. One of the best examples of this is the dialogue, which has sometimes been incredibly confounding. Some of these were wildly out of place, contradictory, or even undermined previous characterizations and movies. Though the franchise is rebooting, there are still several upcoming DCEU movies, which can hopefully elucidate some of these perplexing lines.

10 “A Hundred Years Ago I Walked Away From Mankind; From A Century Of Horrors… Men Made A World Where Standing Together Is Impossible.”

Wonder Woman In Batman v Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)

Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman together as the Trinity in Batman V Superman Dawn Of Justice (2016)
Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman together as the Trinity in Batman V Superman Dawn Of Justice (2016)

Release Date
March 25, 2016
Runtime
152 minutes
Director
Zack Synder
Studio
Warner Bros. Pictures

At the end of Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, Bruce Wayne discovered Wonder Woman's identity. Initially, Diana's instinct was to distance herself from Bruce to preserve her anonymity. During the movie's conclusion, feeling her secret secure with Bruce, she opened up about her past, stating “A hundred years ago I walked away from mankind; from a century of horrors… Men made a world where standing together is impossible.” This suggested that she abandoned humankind, which directly undermined her characterization in Wonder Woman. The controversial line was discussed in a Wonder Woman 1984 moment, which sought to rebalance the character.

9 "Besides, Who's Gonna Give You A Reach-Around?"

The Joker In Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)

Jared Leto's Knightmare Joker, pointing to himself in Zack Snyder's Justice League pic
Jared Leto's Knightmare Joker, pointing to himself in Zack Snyder's Justice League pic

Release Date
March 18, 2021
Runtime
242 minutes
Director
Zack Synder

Jared Leto's Joker made a surprise appearance in the epilogue of Zack Snyder's Justice League. While his inclusion was certainly unexpected, one of his lines of dialogue was particularly confounding. The Joker pontificated on the nature of his and Batman's relationship and explained why Batman will never truly defeat the Joker because they need each other - a common conversation between the adversaries. However, the Joker quickly followed this with "Besides, who's gonna give you a reach-around?" The line was jarring compared to the scene's importance; not quite shocking enough to fit the Joker's character but also so sexual and unprompted that it derailed the entire scene.

8 “Save Martha!”

Superman In Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)

A blended image depicting batman and superman's faces during their fight in batman v Superman
A blended image depicting batman and superman's faces during their fight in batman v Superman

One of the DCEU's most baffling lines occurred in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Just as Batman appeared to be winning the eponymous climactic battle, Superman muttered "Save Martha," referring to his mother who was being held hostage by Lex Luthor. This staggered Batman because his deceased mother's name was also Martha. The moment caused the pair to cease their altercation, but it proved a point of contention among audiences. It was strange for Superman to refer to his mother as "Martha" without legitimate justification. "Save my mother" would have been far more appropriate, but as so much of the movie hinged on this point, the clunky line remained.

7 “Kal-El, No!”

Wonder Woman In Justice League (2017)

Release Date
November 17, 2017
Runtime
120 Minutes
Director
Zack Synder
Writers
Chris Terrio, Joss Whedon

During Justice League (and Zack Snyder's Justice League), the eponymous superheroes battled a confused Superman after his resurrection. Preparing to fight, Wonder Woman cried out, "Kal-El no!," using Superman's original Kryptonian name. Superman typically favored "Clark Kent" as his alter-ego throughout the DCEU, and while his fellow Justice League members were likely aware of his previous name, they never really used it. As a result, the line felt forced and appeared to suggest some exclusive affinity between the two heroes that hadn't been depicted thus far. The equivalent would be Superman calling Wonder Woman "Princess Diana of Themyscira" - factually correct but completely incongruous.

6 “He Said You Were The Thirstiest Young Woman He’d Ever Met”

Martha Kent In Justice League (2017)

Clark Kent reunited with Martha and Lois in Zack Snyder's Justice League

Justice League offered another bizarre and confusing line when Martha Kent and Lois Lane were discussing Lois's career as a journalist. Matha commented that her son, Clark Kent, had claimed Lois would win another Pulitzer Prize, saying that he'd called her the "thirstiest young woman he'd ever met," before quickly correcting herself to "hungriest." The line brought an unnecessary sexual element that made the encounter highly inappropriate and improbable for a conversation between a man's mother and his partner. Martha discussing Lois' sexual frustration was an extremely odd choice, particularly considering how inconsequential it was to the narrative.

5 “I Thought She Was With You.”

Batman In Batman v Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)

The poster from Batman V Superman showing Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman looking grim
The poster from Batman V Superman showing Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman looking grim

Dawn of Justice proffered another confusing line when Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman unite. As the trio embarked on their mission, Batman remarked to Superman, "I thought she was with you," referring to Wonder Woman. However, it was Batman and Wonder Woman who had worked together extensively up until this point in the movie. The line could have been referencing the two super-powered beings compared to Batman's human skill set, but that's not how it came across. Instead, it appeared as if Batman had completely forgotten what had happened up to that juncture, seemingly oblivious to Wonder Woman's contribution.

4 "Many Are Asking The Question, 'Was This A Natural Disaster Or Something Else?'"

Newsreader In Aquaman (2018)Jason Momoa as Aquaman standing in a laboratory in the DCEU's Aquaman

Release Date
December 21, 2018
Runtime
143 Minutes
Director
James Wan

During Aquaman's first act, the villain Ocean Master orchestrated a global tidal wave, intentionally stranding worldwide warships and dredging up oceanic debris. The carnage was reported on by the news media, but despite the very obvious targeting, a news reporter inexplicably wondered, "Was this a natural disaster or something else?" It was absurd to question whether such precise devastation could have been a random natural occurrence. While the notion of a tidal wave having specific targets may seem implausible, the synchronized worldwide impact unequivocally suggested a deliberate act, and should have dispelled any notion of it being "something else."

3 “These Scars We Have, Make Us Who We Are. We’re Not Meant To Go Back And Fix Them. Don’t Let Your Tragedy Define You.”

Batman In The Flash (2023)

Release Date
June 16, 2023
Runtime
144 minutes
Director
Andy Muschietti

During The Flash, Batman gave the Flash a heartfelt and emotional sense of closure when he explained that his past trauma could not be undone. Batman explained, "The scars we have, make us who we are. We're not meant to go back and fix them. Don't let your tragedy define you." While a beautiful sentiment, the statement was also a complete contradiction. If the Flash became the person he was because of his scars, then he also must surely be defined by them. Both statements cannot be considered correct as they directly undermine each other. While it was an incredibly touching moment, the conflicting nature of the Dark Knight's words didn't escape some audience questioning.

2 “Would You Live For Me?”

The Joker In Suicide Squad (2016)

Release Date
August 5, 2016
Runtime
123 minutes
Director
David Ayer

There were many things wrong with Jared Leto's Joker in Suicide Squad, but his line preceding Harley Quinn's jump into the acid bath is particularly perplexing. Asking Harley if she would die for him, he stopped himself, saying that would be too easy. He then asked, "Would you live for me?" Joker clearly wanted Harley to kill herself - unaware she would survive the ordeal - so changing his question was completely counter-intuitive. He had already ascertained that she would indeed jump if he desired, so asking this second question would surely work against his wishes. Nevertheless, after Harley agreed to "live" for him, she still jumped.

1 “Each Member Was Chosen For His Or Her Own Completely Unique Set Of Abilities.”

Amanda Waller In The Suicide Squad (2021)

Viola Davis as Amanda Waller, looking concerned in a mission room in Suicide Squad
Viola Davis as Amanda Waller, looking concerned in a mission room in Suicide Squad

During an early scene in The Suicide Squad, Amanda Waller delivered a highly contradictory piece of dialogue. The creator of the titular antihero troupe explained that "Each member was chosen for his or her own completely unique set of abilities." However, a major subplot throughout the movie is the undeniable similarities between Peacekeeper and Bloodshot. The pair repeatedly clash over their respective weaponry and fighting prowess. Waller's description of each character's uniqueness was quickly proven completely incorrect - which is even more confusing considering Waller assembled the team personally. Waller should have known this, so her assertion was completely unfounded, and one of the DCEU's most confusing lines.