Ana de Armas and Ben Affleck's off-screen relationship might be over, but audiences are still trickling onto Hulu to watch their starring performances in Deep Water. Steamy scenes showcase their chemistry, but their characters' arguments perhaps reflect their eventual split.
The movie unpacks the failing marriage of Affleck's Vic Van Allen and de Armas' Melinda Van Allen as Vic grows increasingly jealous of his wife's extramarital relationships with new men. They engage in a battle of wits as Vic tries to uncover Melinda's affairs and Melinda tries to figure out why her beaus continue to disappear. When their friends catch wind of Vic's rumored killing, each characters' intelligence is unpacked.
Joel Dash
Brendan C. Miller's Joel is the first of Melinda's boyfriends whom audiences meet in Deep Water. He's introduced when she and Vic attend the first of several parties presented in the story. Joel is a musician who takes it upon himself to talk to Vic and thank him for "being cool" about his and Melinda's extramarital relationship.
It is hard to make a case for Joel's intelligence. Vic threatens him, and he nevertheless attends a dinner at his house afterward. Instead of using critical thinking to unpack Vic's threats, Joel naively believes Melinda when she says Vic is kidding. She even tells Vic that Joel is indeed "dumb."
Tony Cameron
Tony is Melinda's ex-boyfriend who shows up in the latter half of the film. He is played by Finn Wittrock, whom fans might remember as Dandy in American Horror Story: Freakshow. Tony joins the Van Allens for dinner where Melinda brings up their sexual history.
Tony shows a lack of reasoning. He picks up on Vic's standoffish behavior when he visits his house, but days later hops in a car with him without a second thought. Even though he has seen evidence that Vic isn't happy with him or his relationship with Melinda, Tony puts himself in harm's way and pays the ultimate price.
Charlie De Lisle
Jacob Elordi plays Charlie De Lisle. Fans might know Elordi from his role as Nate, one of the more intelligent characters in HBO's Euphoria. His character in Deep Water, however, is less developed. As such, it is harder to pin down how smart he is.
However, Charlie shows a lack of intellectual curiosity. He seems to float along in the movie, and like Melinda's other lovers, not taking stock of the fact that Vic clearly is not enjoying Charlie's tryst with his wife. Fans might say Charlie's lack of observational skills leads to his untimely end.
Grant
Lil Rel Howery plays Grant, one of Vic's friends. He appears most frequently during the several parties that the couple attends throughout the story. Grant is one of Deep Water's most likable characters and shows he is a good friend in conversation.
Grant presents his intelligence in his chats with Vic. He questions his buddy about his unhappy marriage, and Melinda's actions that appear to cause him pain. Grant shows intellectual curiosity in his attempt to understand Vic's position.
Mary Washington
Mary is played by Devyn Tyler. She appears early on in the film, as the first person to speak to Vic about Melinda's cavalier flaunting of her relationships outside her marriage. She confronts him about Melinda's behavior and voices her concerns to him.
Mary speaks eloquently, showing emotional intelligence in her even-handed discussion with Vic, handling the subject of Vic and Melinda's marriage with care while not mincing her words. She observes Melinda's actions and draws conclusions, and illustrates intellectual curiosity in asking Vic to confirm or deny her suspicions.
Don Wilson
Tracy Letts's Don Wilson is one of the film's antagonists. Vic and Melinda meet him during a dinner party where he tells them he is a screenwriter, and he learns about Vic's past in creating a computer chip that becomes used in drone warfare. Don loudly and proudly shows his intelligence consistently throughout the film.
He presents several moments of critical thinking. When Vic tells him about his invention, Don unpacks the moral issue implicit in its use. After hearing rumors about Vic's possible murder streak, he uses his past as possible evidence. Don is intellectually curious and continues to dig into his life, eventually finding his theories are true. If only he hadn't committed a certain driving faux pas.
Vic Van Allen
Affleck's Vic is the protagonist in Deep Water. As such, his smarts are on display in several actions he takes. His career background implies smarts, as audiences learn he has created a computer chip that becomes used on a large scale in drone warfare. Grant tells Don that Vic is "a genius."
However, Vic shows a lack of emotional intelligence that edges him out of the smartest role in the movie. He presents a lack of foresight when he kills Tony in a fit of passion, with no plan to cover up the body. His mind is clouded by his obsession with Melinda, leaving their relationship in a toxic state for most of the film.
Melinda Van Allen
De Armas appears in several highly-rated films, and here she plays Melinda. At first glance, Melinda might appear to be foolish considering her obnoxious and brazen behavior. However, she reveals herself to be one of the smartest characters in the story.
She tells him the life they lead, with a family and child, was "[Vic's] choice." However, she knows that Vic will not leave her, so she lives her life as if they have already split. She shows critical thinking when she tells Vic she isn't scared of him because she "is the thing [he] killed for." She shows intellectual curiosity in investigating Vic's snail room and uncovering the mystery of Tony's disappearance.