The Nintendo Wii U has to be the biggest commercial failure among the big four console manufacturers in gaming history. To put things in perspective, the PlayStation 5 is currently projected to be outselling the Xbox Series X|S three to one, but the estimated Xbox Series X|S sales numbers would be outselling the Wii U around three to one. While the Wii U had some strong games, those that didn't come to Switch have largely been sidelined.

One title that remains a Wii U exclusive is Devil's Third. Developed by Valhalla Game Studios, Devil's Third was in the hands of former Team Ninja members, including genius game creator Tomonobu Itagaki. While it was massively ahead of its time, it had the entire deck stacked against it. I truly believe that if it were a multiplatform title and came out when it was originally supposed to, around 2013, it would have been the next Call of Duty.

Devil's Third Has A Fun Campaign

Still An Enjoyable Experience Today

Ivan facing off against Ninja-like enemies in Devil's Third.
Ivan facing off against Ninja-like enemies in Devil's Third.

While the core of Devil's Third was the multiplayer, the campaign also proved to be a fun time, although not to the same quality as the developer's past work. The original crew at Team Ninja, including Itagaki, made some of the best games of all time in the action department, and you can see many traits of those classics in Devil's Third.

Just like the obliteration techniques in Ninja Gaiden 2, Devil's Third's executions look and feel extremely satisfying. While boss fights with minions are an often-hated element of action games, this team always nails the feature, adding depth to the fight, and the boss would be much worse without them.

Replaying the campaign, especially in Score Attack mode, remains a fun romp, but there are issues. For one, the game runs terribly on the Wii U, and Devil's Third is a rare title that I would actually recommend playing on an emulator for a consistent 60fps. The other big problem is that guns are far too overpowered.

Devil's Third excels in its hybrid slashing and shooting gameplay. However, you can play 90 percent of this game using exclusively ranged weapons. They're way too strong, and ammo is plentiful. The game's much more fun when you're actively switching between melee and ranged combat, but it's a shame that many played Devil's Third using mostly guns, since they're such a viable strategy. Thankfully, that's where the multiplayer comes into play.

Devil's Third's Multiplayer Was Game-Changing

Paving The Way For Games Like Fallout 76 & Helldivers 2

While the campaign has some faults, Devil's Third is most remembered for its multiplayer. Director Tomonobu Itagaki (of Dead or Alive and Ninja Gaiden fame) is still saddened by the game's critical and commercial failure. However, in an interview with Retro Gamer magazine, he stated that he was "really happy that we got some praise for the multiplayer." He should be, because it was incredibly game-changing.

First off, the combat played so much better in the multiplayer compared to the campaign, with melee and ranged options being far more balanced. Then, there's the big innovation, which was the territory and clan system. Players could form their own clans, and these weren't just a social element like crews in GTA Online.

Devil's Third's multiplayer sadly only lasted 16 months before being taken offline. There's no official or even unofficial way to play the multiplayer now.

These clans were built to dominate online, taking control of territories in a similar manner to what Helldivers 2 did nine years later. You could negotiate with other clans with the intention of making peace, like Superman, or just go all-out to destroy them and reclaim their land. Spying is even a game mechanic, so you can play as a double agent as well, tearing apart a clan from the inside.

This led to a ton of online drama that you rarely see in multiplayer action games like this. The multiplayer of Devil's Third is more akin to a war game than a slasher-shooter hybrid. Your clan can even build its own fortress, with a customization system similar to making settlements in Fallout 4. While you can spend a ton of time building this masterpiece of a fortress, it can always come crashing down from enemy clans. This echoes Fallout again, resembling Fallout 76's option to nuke player camps.

Even small things, like multiplayer rewards in the campaign, were ahead of their time. The XP tokens for beating the campaign that appear in recent Call of Duty games resemble Devil's Third's concept of golden eggs you can earn while replaying campaign missions.

In The Wrong Place At The Wrong Time

Sadly, It Never Stood A Chance

Ivan holding a grenade in Devil's Third.
Ivan holding a grenade in Devil's Third.

After a legendary career marked by numerous critical and commercial successes, Director Tomonobu Itagaki remains bitter about Devil's Third, and to be fair, many of the reasons this game flopped are external. Devil's Third was originally planned to be an Xbox 360 exclusive, published by Xbox Game Studios, but that fell through after Xbox demanded the title have Kinect support, a decision that makes as much sense as raising the Xbox Series X's price to $600.

Then, it was going to be published by THQ, as shown off in an incredible 2012 trailer, but that also fell through due to THQ's bankruptcy in 2013. With the lack of publishing funding, the game was in development hell until Nintendo finally agreed to publish the game as a Wii U exclusive, similar to Bayonetta 2.

While it's great that the title was released at all, thanks to Nintendo, being a Wii U exclusive killed any chances for success. Unlike Bayonetta 2, which was a single-player experience, the core of Devil's Third was the online play, which demands a multiplatform release for it to be a huge hit. Look at PlayStation's Helldivers 2, which is coming to Xbox, the competitor's platform, because it's vital for live-service multiplayer games to come out on every platform available.

When your online multiplayer action war game is exclusive to a console selling significantly worse than the Xbox Series X|S, it's going to be dead on arrival. To boot, the game looks very outdated for a 2015 title, probably because it was supposed to come out in 2013 or 2014 before publishing troubles got in the way.

I think that if Devil's Third came out when it was initially planned to and released on Xbox 360/Xbox One, PS3/PS4, and PC, it could have been huge. There's still no online multiplayer slash-shooter hybrid on the market today, and considering the title's innovative war game elements, I do feel Itagaki's pain regarding its failure. It's worth checking out this Nintendo Wii U hidden gem, if you can pay the steep price tag for a physical copy.

Source: Nintendo of America/YouTube, Retro Gamer/Pocketmags

Systems
Released
November 12, 2015
ESRB
Mature 17+
Developer(s)
Valhalla Game Studios, Nintendo SPD
Publisher(s)
Nexon, Nintendo
Engine
Unreal Engine 3
Multiplayer
Online Multiplayer

Genre(s)
Action, Hack and Slash, First-Person Shooter