WARNING: This article contains SPOILERS for Doomsday Clock #2
-
After Watchmen ended, Dr. Manhattan's joined the DC Universe - with one Doomsday Clock theory suggesting he was reborn as a famous DC superhero. It may seem like an outlandish idea, and an even more direct link between the worlds of Watchmen and DC Comics than fans expected when Doomsday Clock was announced. The official sequel to the Watchmen story promised to be one even comic book fans could respect and appreciate. And already, writer Geoff Johns has teased a shocking reveal about Dr. Manhattan's existing role in the DC Universe.
Just two issues in Doomsday Clock is proving to be an intriguing continuation of Watchmen's narrative. Johns has introduced a new Rorschach, delivered a tragic 'true' ending to Watchmen, and teased the possibility of secret connections between the worlds and characters. But in Issue #2, the team-up of Ozymandias and Rorschach comes to DC's Universe in search of Dr. Manhattan... or whatever name he's now going by in this world of superheroes.
In the process, dropping a suggestion that is guaranteed to have comic fans debating, speculating, and possibly even dreading the coming reveals.
RELATED: How is Rorschach Back in Doomsday Clock?
Dr. Manhattan Came To DC's Universe After 'Watchmen'
When the premise for Doomsday Clock was revealed to be "Watchmen heroes meet DC," few assumed that meeting would be literal, more than figurative. But in Issue #2, the Watchmen heroes literally enter DC's universe, tunneling through space and time to leap from their own world in 1992 to the modern DC timeline in 2017. The goal remains the same for Ozymandias, the world's greatest criminal who murdered three million innocent New Yorkers, hoping it would save mankind. With the world back on the brink, only Dr. Manhattan's god-like powers can save it... but he has to find him, first.
To do that Ozymandias a.k.a. Adrian Veidt has turned to his intellect. His run-in with Manhattan in the final act of Watchmen gave him a clue, and the ability to hone in on Manhattan's molecular footprint. By tracking it, Ozymandias could, in theory, follow Dr. Manhattan to wherever it is he disappeared to after the events of Watchmen soured him on humanity. But that's easier said than done, requiring Veidt to achieve quantum tunneling... since Dr. Manhattan didn't go to a far-off place, but a far-off universe.
The DC Universe, to be more exact. And when he got there... well, let's just say that the world's smartest man, and its greatest vigilante detective concoct a theory. Not only is it possible for Dr. Manhattan to seek out a new universe, but he may decide it's time to put himself into it as something more than the scientist he once was.
Did Dr. Manhattan Become Superman?
Since a being of Dr. Manhattan's power would be easy to find, Veidt does some digging (along with Rorschach) into superhuman phenomena. But for all the similarities between the world of the Watchmen's past and this future of DC's, the biggest difference is one every Watchmen reader already knows. In the world dreamed up by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, Dr. Manhattan's powers made him one of a kind among costumed vigilantes. But in DC's world, certified superhumans are a dime a dozen. Which, as Rorschach points out, may be confirmation of Dr. Manhattan's handiwork.
As the masked notes, not every superhuman celebrity in the DCU is a new creation, completely alien to their world and history. Some of the living, breathing superheroes on DC's Earth were already famous as fictional ones on their own world. Using detective skills befitting a man who survives only on pancakes, Rorschach deduces that Manhattan could have created them from his own memory (some of the life forms he intended to create in a world of his own making).
Yet Ozymandias goes a step further, suggesting that Dr. Manhattan a.k.a. Jon Osterman may have done more than just make superheroes to try to save the world. He just might have put himself into the experiment:
It's possible, yes. Jon may have wanted to start over with a new identity. A second chance.
Second chance at what?
Saving a world.
On some level, it's actually a more altruistic twist (potentially) than many DC readers would have expected, given the body count Manhattan tallied up on the way to Rebirth. The questions begin to multiply once considering Adrian Veidt's theory: did Manhattan become a hero from the very beginning? Is he aware of his new identity, or is he operating as a superhero AND mastermind of the universe? If his overall goal is truly to save the world... have we gotten the Rebirth threat all wrong?
Perhaps the most alarming question, and one fans must nevertheless ask, is if it makes the most sense for Dr. Manhattan to be the first superhuman in the DCU, as he was in his own world. Because if that's the case, the conclusion of Doomsday Clock #1 just got a lot more meaningful.
Put together the leads suggesting Dr. Manhattan came to Earth from another universe, and took the identity of a certified superhuman so he could "save a world" the right way. Add in the fact that Superman - confirmed in this same issue's news clippings to be the "first superhuman" to emerge - is a central figure in Doomsday Clock, and the theories form on their own. Issue #1 hopped to Superman for its conclusion without much explanation, but that tease may make more sense in hindsight.
We're not offering our own theory that Superman is "Manhattan's second chance," or weighing the evidence for and against (that will be conducted by fans everywhere, we're certain). But the question has now been raised, leaving fans wondering - more than ever before - just how much impact Doomsday Clock will have. The other stories in the larger Rebirth mystery have teased Manhattan operating from the shadows. Now, he may be standing in the spotlight... and be just as hidden.
Doomsday Clock #2 is available now.