Summary

  • Shadow of the Erdtree's foes pose a significant challenge, with powerful Fire Knights requiring strategy and multiple attempts to defeat.
  • The confined spaces of the Shadow Keep make dodging difficult, and Fire Knights' high Poise makes them tough to take down.
  • Avoiding Fire Knights is often the best approach, but their respawning nature means players must face them all to progress through the Shadow Keep.

There are plenty of strong enemies in Elden Ring’s new DLC, but one particular Shadow of the Erdtree foe seems unfairly powerful for a non-boss. Even though many people have already learned that boss fights are not always the deadliest parts of Shadow of the Erdtree, it cannot be denied that the DLC’s foes are extremely frustrating at times. Nevertheless, many Tarnished have experienced tougher fights than what might be expected at certain points.

Although Shadow of the Erdtree has had performance issues, its actual design is still more than enough to pose an enormous challenge. Its various bosses can, of course, be extremely powerful, prompting many to level up and upgrade their Shadow Realm Blessings no matter how much they may have prepared beforehand. Of course, Shadow of the Erdtree is not without flaws, which can make the game less enjoyable on occasion, but on the whole it clearly stays true to the consistently punishing reputation of Soulsborne games, even at points where it would be preferable to have a little leniency.

The Shadow Keep’s Fire Knights Are Akin To Respawning Bosses

Fire Knights Have Few Vulnerabilities

A Tarnished faces a Fire Knight inside the Shadow Keep from Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC.
A Tarnished faces a Fire Knight inside the Shadow Keep from Elden Ring's Shadow of the Erdtree DLC.

Completing the Shadow Keep is an important step in progressing through Shadow of the Erdtree, but doing so requires making it past many Fire Knights. Members of Messmer’s Army, Fire Knights, are powerful both at range and in melee and have high health. As a result, they can be very hard to defeat, to the point that it is not uncommon to drink several Flasks during each encounter. However, given that there can be several Fire Knights standing between one Site of Grace and the next, such a gauntlet seems tailor-made to wear the Tarnished down until they die.

The Shadow Keep dungeon actually has two entrances to find, which lead to the Main Plaza and Church District areas respectively.

A Fire Knight’s speed and agility are incredibly high as well, making it difficult to attack them without being hit multiple times in the process. Considering that Fire Knights can quickly whittle down a Tarnished’s HP, this is clearly far from ideal, but there seems to be little choice in the matter. Although some can be fought mainly at range, mostly those found around the dungeon’s exterior, most Fire Knights are instead found within the narrow spaces of the Shadow Keep’s interior. This makes it far easier for combat to see them enter melee range, where dodging is nearly impossible.

The confined spaces of the Shadow Keep make dodge rolls a remarkably dangerous maneuver, especially if the player’s spatial awareness is limited by them locking on to the enemy. It is all too easy for the Tarnished to find themselves trapped in a corner or even dodge backward over a ledge and suffer a deadly fall. Another point of note is the fact that enemy Fire Knights have extremely high Poise, more than it is technically possible to have when the Tarnished wears a full set of Fire Knight Armor themselves.

The Fire Knights Encourage Elden Ring Players To Avoid Them Whenever Possible

An Enemy That's Best To Skip

Because of their strength, it often seems the best way to deal with Fire Knights is to avoid them altogether. Unfortunately, while stealth can bring the Tarnished past some of the powerful soldiers, not all can be avoided. Some Fire Knights actively patrol their surroundings, whilst plenty of others guard the way deeper into the keep. Additionally, the fact that they are not even miniboses means that they all respawn as well, forcing the Tarnished to make it past all Fire Knights in one run to make it to the next Site of Grace.

On the other hand, it is possible to cut down on the number of Fire Knights the Tarnished engages by simply running away. While Fire Knights will pursue them with both blades and magic, it can be possible to avoid outrun enough Fire Knights to make the Tarnished’s Flasks last them until the next Site of Grace. But with so many Fire Knights to face, it is very easy to make a mistake, something which naturally can easily prove lethal.

Although it can be tempting to simply farm runes in Shadow of the Erdtree whenever a big obstacle appears, the difficulty spike created by the Fire Knights of Shadow Keep is not so easy to overcome. These enemies are incredibly strong in relation to their position in the DLC, especially given their environment and ability to respawn. Although this certainly makes the Fire Knights memorable new additions to Elden Ring, the fact that they are so easily a source of frustration, with none of the justification a difficult boss would have, makes their design feel all the more unfair.

mixcollage-08-dec-2024-02-50-pm-6945-1.jpg
Top Critic Avg: 95/100 Critics Rec: 97%
Released
February 25, 2022
ESRB
M for Mature: Blood and Gore, Language, Suggestive Themes, Violence
Developer(s)
From Software
Publisher(s)
Bandai Namco Entertainment, From Software
Engine
Proprietary
The player looking at the Erdtree in the distance in Elden Ring.

Multiplayer
Online Co-Op, Online Multiplayer
Platform(s)
PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series S, Xbox Series X
Genre(s)
RPG, Action