Summary
- The Emmys' insistence on classifying shows as either comedy or drama is outdated, as many shows today blur the line between the two genres.
- Winners like Succession and The White Lotus challenge traditional categorization, as they possess elements of both comedy and drama, highlighting the limitations of the Emmys' binary system.
- The Emmys' practice of categorizing shows based on episode length is an antiquated system that fails to adequately capture the complexities and nuances of modern television storytelling.
The winners of the 2024 Emmys have highlighted the biggest problem with the Academy’s insistence on separating every single TV show on the air into one of two binary categories. The 75th Primetime Emmy Awards saw some very deserving shows take home television’s most coveted prizes. From Succession to Beef to Abbott Elementary, some of the greatest shows of the past year came away from the 2024 ceremony with golden statues in hand. But this year’s Emmys also illustrated a recurring issue with their categorization.
As with any awards show, the 2024 Emmys came with a handful of egregious snubs. Ted Lasso didn’t win a single award for its third and final season and Better Call Saul set a new record for the most Emmy losses in history. But that wasn’t the only problem with this year’s Emmys ceremony. The Emmys’ insistence on classifying every TV series as either a comedy or a drama has become outdated in an age when most shows walk a fine line between the two.
Dramedy Shows Blur The Line Between Categories At The Emmys
From the acting awards to the writing awards, every Emmy is split into two categories: comedy and drama. Traditionally, half-hour TV shows are comedies and hour-long shows are dramas. It used to be easy to differentiate between the two: Mad Men, The Wire, and Game of Thrones are dramas; Friends, Seinfeld, and Frasier are comedies. But in recent years, the line between these two categories has been blurred. The Emmys classified Nurse Jackie as a comedy, but it’s more like a half-hour drama. Breaking Bad and The Sopranos were classed as dramas, but they both had plenty of dark humor.
Multiple 2024 Emmy Winners Could Be Considered A Drama & A Comedy
A lot of the big winners at the 2024 Emmys could be considered both a drama and a comedy. Succession is a dark, tragic saga about the deep dysfunctions within a family of rich one-percenters, but it’s funnier than most of the Emmy-nominated shows in the comedy categories. Its creator, Jesse Armstrong, cut his teeth as a sitcom writer, and each Succession episode has a higher quotient of jokes and one-liners than most official sitcoms.
The White Lotus was similarly nominated as a drama – and it does have plenty of compelling dramatic elements – but its “eat the rich” satire arguably makes it a comedy first and a drama second. The Bear, on the other hand, was nominated as a comedy, but it plays more like a drama with some laughs than a comedy with some emotion. The Emmys’ insistence on separating every TV show into one of these categories – and determining that category by the length of its episodes – is a very antiquated system, and the 2024 winners prove it.