Far Cry's TV adaptation is already raising some eyebrows. Based on the video game series of the same name, the anthology TV series is currently in development at FX with creators Noah Hawley and Rob McElhenney. We don't know much about it yet, other than the recent announcement that it'll tell an original story instead of adapting one of the games.
However, fans are already taking issue with the TV series' approach to adaptation, particularly its attitude towards the source material. It's a tale as old as time when it comes to video game adaptations, but it still doesn't bode well for the future of Far Cry.
In an interview with Deadline (spotted by DiscussingFilm on X), co-creator Hawley is quoted as saying, "When you play a video game, you only really move forward through the gameplay section, and then you have these cut scenes that you can skip, so when you go to adapt those games you have to be aware that makes the human drama kind of irrelevant to the storyline."
Many have taken issue with the implication that constantly skipping cutscenes is a common practice, with user Kcin commenting, "Never in my life have I known anyone who skips cutscenes on a first playthrough of any game." Or, as user Gabriel commented, "Why else would I buy a game with a story if I didn't care?"
Others pointed out that, while some players may skip cutscenes in certain types of games, Far Cry specifically is too story-heavy, and tells too much of that story through cutscenes, to effectively skip them. "Michael Mando’s performance as Vaas and his monologue about the 'Definition of Insanity'? Troy Baker’s calm, sadistic performance as Pagan Min? Greg Bryk's chilling performance as Father Joseph Seed," as user Zack rattled off.
"Some of the Far Cry games have delivered wonderful storytelling, and as a Far Cry fan, I really hope this silly man actually plays the f***ing games."
Still others pointed out that this point reveals Hawley's unfamiliarity with Far Cry, as it's impossible to skip the cutscenes in some of the early games. This includes what's arguably the series' most iconic entry, Far Cry 3.
While there are undoubtedly players out there who skip every cutscene they come across, they're almost certainly not the majority. But what's more "insulting," some fans say, is this kind of casual dismissiveness of the source material, which seems to come up with every video game adaptation.
Personally, I'm of a mind that video games generally don't need to be adapted into movies and TV series; you inevitably lose a significant part of the storytelling when you take away the interactivity.
But good adaptations across every medium always stem from a genuine appreciation for the source material, warts and all, and a solid understanding of why others love it. You could say it over-relies on cutscenes to tell its story, but one of Far Cry's greatest strengths is its cinematicality; presuming that its fans are only there for the gameplay, and skip all the human drama, is bound to upset those most invested in its adaptation.