Following a Game of the Year nomination for Metaphor: ReFantazio last year, and the extremely positive reaction to this year's Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, turn-based combat has become a hot topic of discussion. One topic that gets brought up often in this discussion is whether the Final Fantasy series should go back to making turn-based games, now that this style of combat is having a bit of a renaissance. However, most debates surrounding this seem not to touch on one key detail about Final Fantasy's history with turn-based combat.
Recently, this discussion got so much traction that Yoshi-P, director of Final Fantasy XIV, addressed whether Final Fantasy 17 would have turn-based combat. He didn't exactly rule out turn-based combat in the next mainline Final Fantasy game, but remained non-committal about where the franchise would go from here. The general impression I get from most of these discussions is that many believe using turn-based combat in the next game would be Final Fantasy returning to form now that the combat style is more popular. However, that isn't necessarily the case.
Only 4 Of The 16 Mainline Final Fantasy Games Use True Turn-Based Combat
The Most Common Combat System In Final Fantasy Is The ATB System
It isn't necessarily untrue to say that Final Fantasy would be "returning" to turn-based combat. After all, the first Final Fantasy game did use true turn-based combat. However, when looking at the totality of the series, turn-based combat is far from the norm. Final Fantasy 4 through Final Fantasy 9 use what's known as the Active Time Battle system, which is often mistaken for turn-based combat, simply because it shares some of the same trappings.
Final Fantasy 10 went back to using a form of turn-based combat which is called Conditional Turn-Based Battle. Unlike in traditional turn-based combat, where each character takes a single turn in a determined order, faster creatures in FF10 would take multiple turns before slower creatures and characters had a chance to. Although still turn-based in the sense that you could spend as much time as you liked selecting your moves, it was still a bit of a departure from the previous turn-based system in the original three Final Fantasy games.
If we include FF10's CTB system as turn-based combat, which I think it is fair to do, that still means that only four of the 16 mainline games in the series feature turn-based combat. Following FF10, each game has had its own unique battle system, none of which have been truly or conditionally turn-based. The idea that the Final Fantasy series was turn-based for a long time stems from a conflation of its ATB system with turn-based combat.
Why ATB Combat Shouldn't Be Considered Turn-Based
ATB Combat Doesn't Actually Have Turns
Final Fantasy's ATB system is often mistaken for turn-based combat because it shares some of the same trappings, but there is a key difference. There aren't really turns in the ATB system, so much as a set amount of time you have to wait between actions. However, while you are selecting actions for one of your characters, the battle is still going on. You can be in the middle of selecting a spell for one of your characters, only to have them die due to an enemy attack, something that can't happen in a turn-based game.
Additionally, your actions take different amounts of time to resolve. Say you're playing Final Fantasy 6, and you select to summon Bahamut with Terra. Terra begins summoning, and you choose next to do a physical attack with Edgar. Because the time to resolve a basic attack is faster than the time required to summon, Edgar will act first, even though you selected a move for Terra before him. That's because there aren't actually turns in FF6, just time limits between the ability to take actions, and set times for how long each action takes.
Unlike in a turn-based game, you can't sit and deliberate on what moves you want to make. Instead, you have to keep making decisions as quickly as possible, both to maximize your action output, and to avoid getting killed by enemies who will continue to attack while you're selecting. Therefore, thinking that the bulk of Final Fantasy games use turn-based combat isn't really accurate.
Final Fantasy Returning To Turn-Based Combat Isn't A Bad Idea, But It Also Isn't The Norm
Turn-Based Games Are The Minority For The Franchise
I'm not against the idea of a new Final Fantasy game using turn-based combat. I'm a big fan of the Persona series, and I really enjoyed how both Metaphor: ReFantazio and Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 handled similar turn-based combat encounters in their own unique ways. The Final Fantasy series has a long history of innovative combat, so I'd love to see what Square Enix would come up with for a new turn-based game.
That being said, a new Final Fantasy game using turn-based combat shouldn't really be framed as a return to form for the series. With only four turn-based games, for FF17 to use the series' most common style of combat, it would have to use the ATB system instead. Innovative combat systems also make up an even share of Final Fantasy titles as the ATB system, and I'm not against getting something fresh when FF17 comes out either, so long as it brings something fun and interesting to the table.
- Created by
- Hironobu Sakaguchi
- First Film
- Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within
- Latest Film
- Kingsglaive: Final Fantasy XV
- First TV Show
- Final Fantasy: Legend of the Crystals
- Latest TV Show
- Brotherhood: Final Fantasy XV
- First Episode Air Date
- October 2, 2001









