Warning: the following contains mild spoilers for The Flash movie.
The Flash movie has been the subject of controversy for years thanks to multiple writer and director changes and controversy surrounding Ezra Miller, and now in its opening weekend, director Andrés Muschietti had to come out to defend the film's visual choices and VFX quality following criticisms over leaked scenes. As with most blockbusters today, The Flash is a VFX-heavy movie, and some of the effects work better than others, but there's also some key style and aesthetic decisions behind the look of the film wrongly catching flack as "bad VFX," when there's something else going on entirely.
The visuals of DCEU movies have been polarizing from the franchise's inception with Man of Steel, which was criticized for Zack Snyder's lower-saturation high-contrast visuals, which only became darker in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. The criticisms eventually led to major reshoots for both The Suicide Squad and especially Justice League, leading to studio edits of the movies that were far brighter visually with funnier tones. While the visual tone of The Flash isn't under attack, the film's various stylistic choices result in a very non-traditional look that's polarizing audiences, resulting in criticisms of the film's CGI quality, despite CGI not always being the culprit for the film's look.
The Flash's Ultra-Wide Camera Lenses Create a Unique, but Warped, Aesthetic
One of the foundational visual choices made with The Flash that impacts nearly every frame of the movie is the movie's choice of wide-angle lenses for much of the cinematography. Most movies typically use lenses with focal lengths between 35mm and 70mm with exceptions on both ends of the spectrum. The longer the focal length (the bigger the number) of a lens, the more zoomed a shot will be, giving a narrower field of view is, while the shorter it is, the wider the field of view. Below 35mm, the field of view becomes so wide that the image begins to warp in a bubbly "fish-eye" effect.
The lenses used on The Flash, combined with the RED Raptor camera's ultra-wide sensor achieved focal lengths equivalent to 8mm, creating an especially unique look where objects in the middle are particularly large and fall off significantly as they approach the edge of the frame. This is a stark stylistic decision similar in nature to the "blurry" look Zack Snyder achieved in Army of the Dead where he used a 50mm lens with a particularly shallow depth of field. Understandably, as with any non-standard visual choice, critics and audiences have a divided reception to this particular look, but many that don't realize the reason for the look are incorrectly blaming the appearance on "bad" CGI or VFX.
While the look inherently has an effect on the CGI since the VFX are designed to match the look created by the lens, the issue people have with the look is ultimately rooted in the bubbly wide-angle aesthetic. This is particularly impactful when it comes to the face-swap technology used for much of the movie while two versions of Ezra Miller's Barry Allen are interacting on screen. Inherently, one character's head will always be closer to the center of the frame, meaning one character's head will be larger than the other in a look some may confuse with the infamous floating head effect seen in the later MCU movies with Iron Man.
Even without any VFX present, this look doesn't appear as natural as a 35mm-70mm lens, but since the audience is aware that there's VFX being used, it becomes an easy way to explain why something doesn't look natural. This results in some hasty assumptions that the look of scenes where things look stretched or warped is due to shoddy work in the VFX department, when it may actually be quality VFX work in order to match the natural warping created by the lens choice. Obviously, this style choice may not be to everyone's liking, but it's important to note it's just that: a style choice.
The Flash Has One of the DCEU's Brightest and Cartoonish Saturated Color Palette
While much of the earlier DCEU was criticized for having a darker, desaturated color palette compared to Marvel, The Flash is actually brighter and more colorful than the MCU in many aspects, particularly in scenes with especially blue skies. While the color of many Marvel movies tend to have a problem with an abundance of gray skies and cement-toned scenery, with colors reduced to character costumes or more fantastical elements. The Flash has some of the brightest and highest saturation scenes in the DCEU, giving it a more cartoonish aesthetic. Once again, while this is a stylistic choice to complement the movie's tone, the visual effects are designed to match that look.
This can be particularly jarring for anyone expecting The Flash's heavy Man of Steel influences to match the more grounded tone of Man of Steel, and while that tone is present at times, The Flash has its own distinctive tone more consistent with Barry Allen's portrayal in Zack Snyder's Justice League where he's doing things like eating hot dogs in slow motion, which is inherently a much more cartoonish feel than anything in something like Man of Steel or Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.
Granted, this bright and saturated look can be a disservice to the look of the movie in places like the third act in the desert where there's excessive brown ground and blue sky filled with CGI ships and Kryptonians locked in battle, but this is more a problem with the larger expectations of comic book movie tropes. It's important to note that third acts set in darker environments that try to avoid this kind of CGI overload are equally derided, so this isn't even a problem necessarily inherent to The Flash.
The Flash's Speed Force and "Chrono Bowl" Scenes Have Intentionally Stylized VFX
Finally, there's the Speed Force and "Chrono Bowl" scenes, which director Andrés Muschietti had to come out and address due to pre-release criticisms over leaked scenes. When Barry Allen transitions into the Speed Force and enters the Chrono Bowl, he sees different parts of the multiverse. The first time he enters the Chrono Bowl it shows alternate scenes of him with his family and other events seen in the movie, but later on in the third act it shows different DC universes including glimpses of Nic Cage's canceled Superman Lives movie and Christopher Reeve's Superman, Helen Slater's Supergirl, and more.
The scenes depict stylized CGI versions of the characters, which is obvious in the context of the movie, since the first Chrono Bowl scene depicts the characters from the actual movie in this fashion and the full Chrono Bowl scene in the third act includes stylized versions of actual live-action footage such as a shirtless Henry Cavill from the Justice League vs Superman scene in Justice League; however since the leaks of some of the cameos were initially leaked out of context on social media in low-quality cell-phone footage, the CGI in those scenes was compared to Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson's infamously bad CGI Scorpion King from The Mummy Returns.
Muschietti had to clarify why the scenes look that way, specifying "...we are in the perspective of the Flash. Everything is distorted in terms of lights and textures...It was part of the design so if it looks a little weird to you that was intended." The Flash isn't the only DCEU movie to do this. Zack Snyder's Justice League has a similar moment from Cyborg's POV when he enters a digital world depicting the financial system, which could be similarly twisted out of context to be "bad CGI" when in fact it's not supposed to be realistic because it doesn't exist within the same reality as the rest of the movie.
Granted, this doesn't absolve The Flash of all criticisms of its look. As with any VFX-heavy blockbuster, the sheer amount of VFX work makes it nearly impossible for any movie to arrive in theaters with 100 percent polished VFX and CGI, especially considering how over-burdened and under-paid most VFX studios are; however, a number of atypical stylistic decisions made with The Flash from the wide-angle lenses to the color palette to the stylized Speed Force scenes are resulting in some unfair criticism of the quality of work put in by the movie's VFX artists when the actual cause of the complaint is a polarizing visual style.