The six-episode analog horror game The Fridge is Red is an SCP Foundation-inspired indie experience from developer 5WORD and publisher tinyBuild. Across each episode, players will travel through eerie, liminal spaces based on some of the most stressful life experiences, including job struggles, the loss of a loved one, and terminal illness. Though it lacks a clear overarching narrative, The Fridge is Red is not about the story, but the unsettling atmosphere created in each vignette. In atmosphere alone, it succeeds spectacularly. However, there are many drawbacks that prevent it from being a truly remarkable addition to the indie horror genre.
In each chapter of The Fridge is Red, players will explore seemingly mundane stages, including a home basement, an office building, a hospital, and a church and its catacombs, among others, and solve puzzles to complete fairly simple objectives. The twist, of course, is that these stages are often surreal and packed with strange, though not terribly disturbing, encounters, characters, and imagery. The first two chapters are unlocked by default, and players can unlock the remaining four chapters by picking up an object near the start of chapter two and each subsequent chapter.
The most striking thing about The Fridge is Red is its ambiance. The sound design is especially excellent, reminiscent of other beloved horror properties like PT, Silent Hill, or Salad Fingers. The liminal spaces presented are equally unsettling and reminiscent of No Players Online or the terrifying Internet meme The Backrooms. There is a sort of queasy feeling that comes from walking around a location so sparsely populated for such long stretches of time. The only place the sound design fails is in the voice acting, which sounds like it was done using Text To Speech and a modulator and feels like overkill to try and evoke a scary mood.
The story of The Fridge is Red is fairly weak, and though there are some good ideas presented, none of them ever really feel explored. The first chapter of The Fridge is Red, which is about a demonic fridge that gets closer to and eventually eats the main character if the player looks away from it for too long, sets the tone for the rest of the game. The remaining chapters explore other familiar horror tropes, like a haunted elevator ride, a haunted hospital, and being chased by a murderer through catacombs. It also leans fairly heavily on the "man pain" trope as, after the first chapter, the story follows a man who loses his wife and, presumably, his daughter. There isn't very much horror beyond a few jump scares that quickly become predictable.
Confusingly, each chapter ends with the same fridge from the first chapter appearing, no matter how little it makes sense to the rest of the chapter. It is possible this could be a play on the infamous superhero "fridging" trope, but that connection is unclear and tenuous at best. Because of this, regardless of how well-constructed the rest of the chapter is, the endings constantly cheapen the experience and make it feel a bit like a joke that has gone on too long and is not particularly humorous.
While in many cases long stretches of time held in suspense would improve the horror experience, there is a delicate balance developers must strike between keeping players in good, consistent suspense and dragging the game out to the point that it is no longer scary. The Fridge is Red skews toward the latter. Some puzzles and objectives are fairly straightforward, like finding all the letter magnets to name the demon fridge in the first chapter without being able to move around the room, or finding and collecting severed hands from vending machines after a horrific elevator ride.
However, many of the puzzles and experiences are less clear and more meandering, forcing players to search endlessly through dark, labyrinthine catacombs, drive a car down an empty road for an indeterminate amount of time, or try to follow nearly indecipherable hospital signs. This quickly turns The Fridge is Red from meaningful indie horror to more of a horror-themed walking simulator and causes gameplay to become somewhat tedious and repetitive.
As analog horror, The Fridge is Red tries analog-style graphics but ultimately falls flat. The strongest analog horror incorporates the inherently creepier aspects of the analog era, like VHS tapes and cassettes that could be corrupted and overwritten, and antenna radio that could be hijacked, seamlessly to create the horror experience. The Fridge is Red opts to use all of this sparingly. There are bunny-ear television sets with familiar static that provide clues to puzzles, and analog radios to be found and turned on amid all the Amnesia-style empty, but searchable, drawers. However, the use of analog-style graphics and film grain is mostly a cosmetic choice and makes the entire game extremely difficult to look at. While sometimes the graphics can make the experience eerier, such as with the dark, humanoid silhouettes with glowing red eyes that often represent characters, most of the time they detract from the ability to solve puzzles in The Fridge is Red and make the game more difficult and less accessible to play.
Overall, The Fridge is Red succeeds in creating a creepy atmosphere through the use of liminal spaces and excellent sound design. The world immediately pulls players in with its unsettling feeling and almost demands to be explored. However, The Fridge is Red misses the mark significantly due to the lack of consistent scares, often obtuseness of puzzles, and low-quality graphics. The Fridge is Red includes several great ideas, twisting the stress of everyday encounters into something surreal, but they never quite become fully fleshed out, and they become predictable when they all end in more or less the same manner. Players looking for a few hours of new horror content this October could certainly do worse, but The Fridge is Red lacks the depth and frights needed to contend with the best short indie horror games currently dominating the genre.
The Fridge is Red is available now for PC. A Steam code was provided to Screen Rant for the purpose of this review.