As the show has gone on, From has become an increasingly confusing psychological test for its characters. The Township has undeniably been under the influence of both good and evil forces, and parsing out which pulls to follow and which to ignore is the residents' ultimate challenge.

After the Man in Yellow transformed into Sophia, the mysterious being has consistently attempted to undermine the townspeople's confidence in their decisions, working to push them into a state of frustration and despair that knocks them off any course that may lead to their success in breaking the Township's brutal cycles.

In some instances, the Man in Yellow has been successful, such as when the voices in Sara's head manipulated her into killing her own brother. After learning from this experience, Sara's bearings were again shattered in From season 4 when ignoring the voices seemed to have a direct negative consequence.

However, the townspeople have also made undeniable progress over the course of the show. After a long-held complaint among fans that From's characters struggle to communicate with each other, season 4 saw the townspeople being much more open about their individual experiences. They have also learned a great deal about the Township, like the origin of the monsters and what lies in the forest.

As the Man in Yellow memorably pointed out, this knowledge has frequently come at a cost. Even so, some of the townspeople's greatest hardships were not a result of the Township's evil forces, but rather these poor choices that were entirely of their own doing.

Chasing The Loose Animals In Season 3

Boyd holds Tian-Chen's body after the monsters kill her in From season 3
Boyd holds Tian-Chen's body after the monsters kill her in From season 3

From season 3 opened with the townspeople facing an admittedly dire food crisis. A storm had ruined most of Colony House's crops, and what little they were able to harvest proved to be rotten, leading Donna to conclude that the food had been poisoned. The resulting panic caused many townspeople to raid Tian-Chen's food reserves in the diner, leaving the livestock as their only remaining food supply.

These circumstances made the season 3 premiere the perfect time for the monsters to do something unprecedented and free the animals after dark. With the town already on the verge of a panic, Boyd, Jade, Victor, and Tian-Chen ventured outside into what was clearly a trap. This decision resulted in the horrific killing of Tian-Chen, and, ultimately, proved unnecessary as more food soon turned up elsewhere.

Dale Going Through The Farway Tree

Kristi, Sara, and Two Townspeople Looking into the Pool in From Season 4
Kristi, Sara, and Two Townspeople Looking into the Pool in From Season 4
Image via Everett Collection

The Township's ancillary characters have often been prone to frantic, panic-induced behaviors that ultimately make matters worse for themselves and others. Patty, who previously had her face burned by From's nightmare killer dolls, would later be the only character to descend into full-blown panic in the season 4 finale, setting every other character on edge in the show's most dire moment yet.

The side character who made From's most blatantly bad decision, though, was Dale, who insisted on stepping into a Farway tree despite being told explicitly that there was no way of knowing where it would take him. Sure enough, he quickly found himself stuck in the concrete of the empty swimming pool, where he soon died.

Acosta Taking A Joyride In The Ambulance

Sara, Kenny, Ellis, Donna, and Dani in Colony House in From
Sara, Kenny, Ellis, Donna, and Dani in Colony House in From
Image via Everett Collection

The cop who arrived in the Township in an ambulance with Tabitha and Henry had her own moment of unthinking recklessness in From season 4. Frustrated with the townspeople's lack of answers, she leapt into the ambulance and took laps around the Township's never-ending loop at increasing speeds. She was eventually stopped by the tire strips, leaving the ambulance undriveable.

The only other thing that came of Acosta's going rogue was Kristi spotting Ethan alone near the crashed RV. Her concern for him was understandable, but in attempting to ensure his safety, Tabitha unwittingly interrupted Ethan's conversation with the late Jim about the Lake of Tears. The apparition of Jim hasn't been seen since, leaving the Lake of Tears mystery unsolved going into From season 5.

Building The Radio Tower

Jim talking on the radio in the rain in From season 1 finale
Jim talking on the radio in the rain in From season 1 finale

Before the season 4 mission to rescue the bones, the season 1 endeavor to build the radio tower was perhaps the Township's biggest collective effort to propel itself towards escape. Jim's determination and ability to galvanize the townspeople into some sort of action were commendable, but the experience ultimately proved that real-world tactics would be of no use in From's world.

In fact, the radio was more than simply useless. The endeavor seemed to anger the then-anonymous evil force that spoke to Jim on the radio and brought about a storm that destroyed more than just the radio. As has become the Man in Yellow's common tactic, the result of the radio tower ultimately destroyed the hope that building it had created, leaving the townspeople feeling worse than when they started.

Elgin Listening To The Kimono Woman

Nathan D. Simmons as Elgin Williams looking scared with the dead lady behind him in From season 3 episode 1
Nathan D. Simmons as Elgin Williams looking scared with the dead lady behind him in From season 3 episode 1

From frequently compared the Kimono Woman, who misguided Elgin in season 3, to the voices that led Sara astray in season 1. This cemented the idea that the Kimono Woman was among the Township's evil forces, and this was confirmed by her urging Elgin to trap Fatima in the tunnels where she gave birth to Smiley.

There was likely little to be done about what the pregnant Fatima was truly carrying, but given the monsters' limitations, Fatima's giving birth in the tunnels was key to Smiley's survival. Had Fatima instead given birth in broad daylight, surrounded by the townspeople, it's difficult to even imagine how differently that would have gone for the reincarnated monster.

Julie Abandoning Story-Walking

Randall holding a crying Julie in From season 4, episode 2
Randall holding a crying Julie in From season 4, episode 2
Credit: MGM+

The beginning of From season 4 saw Julie experimenting with her newfound story-walking abilities. Though her attempt to leave herself a "bookmark" failed, her efforts ultimately suggested that she simply had more work to do in understanding her important powers. Yet in the back half of season 4, Julie fell victim to the Man in Yellow's attempts to steer the townspeople away from productive action.

Before Tabitha and Jade entered the tunnels to rescue the bones, Julie tried to talk her out of it, insisting that "this place lies to you." She wasn't wrong, but the Man in Yellow lies to make the townspeople equally skeptical of the truth, which is what Julie had become when she began viewing her story-walking abilities as nothing more than "giving myself seizures."

Getting Drunk

Julia Doyle as Sophia smiling while drinking across from Robert Joy as Henry in From season 4 episode 6
Julia Doyle as Sophia smiling while drinking across from Robert Joy as Henry in From season 4, episode 6
Credit: MGM+ via MovieStillsDB

Drinking often goes badly for the townspeople, something established as early as From's pilot episode. The show opened with the death of Frank's wife and daughter at the hands of the monsters while Frank, a resident of the Township, was at the bar, too drunk to return home before nightfall.

The bar and its alcohol have proved destructive time and again, as a state of drunkenness long kept Jade from making progress in understanding the Bottle Tree, and Henry's drinking with Sophia made him vulnerable to the visions she subjected him to. Interestingly, drugs like marijuana and psychedelic mushrooms have conversely been painted as much less harmful, and, at times, even useful.

Ignoring Victor

Victor and Henry Counting Their Steps in From Season 4
Victor and Henry Counting Their Steps in From Season 4

Victor appears to have a wealth of information to a degree that even he is unaware of. As the only current resident who was a member of a previous cycle, and subsequently spent roughly 40 years completely alone in the Township, Victor undoubtedly has lived experience that could provide key answers to the townspeople's efforts to stop the cycle.

Indeed, when the situation is dire enough, or, conversely, he feels safe enough, Victor has been able to tap into some of his repressed memories and offer crucial information. Yet rather than giving this the attention it deserves, the townspeople largely dismiss what Victor has to offer, like his deeper understanding of the Township's passage of time and unique relationship with the Boy in White.

Killing Smiley

Smiley (Jamie McGuire) smiling at Boyd (Harold Perrineau) in From season 2, episode 6
Smiley (Jamie McGuire) smiling at Boyd (Harold Perrineau) in From season 2, episode 6

Like building the radio tower, Boyd's killing of Smiley proved to be a fleeting triumph that would later set the townspeople back even further than they were before. The death of Smiley was the direct catalyst for Fatima's fateful pregnancy, the consequences of which would only deepen with time. The experience did reveal the monsters' origin to Fatima, but this information was already coming to light elsewhere.

At the Bottle Tree, Tabitha and Jade similarly learned that the monsters couldn't be killed, something that shattered Boyd's hope to the point that he began planning for the possibility that the townspeople might be forced to take their own lives. This was even before From's season 4 finale, in which Fatima turned into a monster and sacrificed herself, an event that will surely destroy Ellis in season 5.

Leaving New People Unattended In The Clinic

Julia Doyle as Sophia praying in From season 4

Activity in the clinic in the immediate aftermath of new arrivals coming into town has often been significant, yet has just as often gone unnoticed by any of From's major characters. After being injured in his and Jade's arrival into town in the pilot episode, a bedridden Tobey was killed by Sara before she then left the clinic doors open for the monsters to kill everyone else inside.

In an act that interestingly mirrors this moment, Sophia asked for privacy only to kill the priest that she arrived with in the From season 4 premiere. Especially after Victor's reveal that the Man in Yellow arrived in a car like any other resident, it would be in the townspeople's best interest to closely monitor any new arrival into From's Township.

from-poster.jpg
830
9.5/10

From

Release Date
February 20, 2022
Network
MGM+
Directors
Jack Bender, Brad Turner, Alexandra La Roche, Bruce McDonald, Jeff Renfroe
Writers
Vivian Lee, Kristen Layden, Brigitte Hales, Jeff Pinkner, John Griffin
Boyd speaking angrily in From season 3 episode 10
  • Headshot Of Harold Perrineau In The World premiere event for Disney+ original series 'Rennervations'
    Harold Perrineau
    Boyd Stevens
  • Headshot Of Catalina Sandino Moreno
    Catalina Sandino Moreno
    Tabitha Matthews

Creator(s)
John Griffin