While Gravity Falls is no stranger to deadly beasts and supernatural monsters, it is still a series suitable for children at its core, and those antagonists stay true to that tone–which is why the inclusion of a Slenderman cameo is so shocking, and decidedly dark.

Gravity Falls originated as a cartoon series that first aired on a Disney Channel, though upon watching the show, one will find that it is actually surprisingly mature. No parents need be concerned, however, as it is still appropriate for children, but the bits that clearly go over kids’ heads and the deeper cosmic horror that lies beneath the ‘goofy’ villains make the series a treat for viewers of all ages. In fact, when Gravity Falls came to its perfect conclusion on Disney XD, series creator Alex Hisch wrote a graphic novel that continued the adventures of Dipper and Mabel by telling the untold tales of some of their never-before-seen summer adventures–and one of them included the incredibly sinister Slenderman.

Related: Gravity Falls Creator Reveals Disney's Ridiculous Script Change Notes

In Gravity Falls: Lost Legends written by Alex Hirsch–with art by Joe Pitt, Ian Worrel, Asaf Hanuka, Dana Terrace, Jacob Chabot, Jim Campbell, Kyle Smeallie, Meredith Gran, Mike Holmes, Priscilla Tang, Serina Hernandez, Stephanie Ramirez, and Valerie Halla–Dipper and Pacifica are chasing a demonic creature named Mr. What’s-His-Face after it stole Mabel’s face. The duo followed it into an underground ‘paranormal black market’ where it was selling its stolen faces to the highest bidders. When Dipper and Pacifica are outed as being humans, another bidding war ensues as one of the other monsters is trying to sell them off–and among the bidders is none other than Slenderman.

Slenderman Has a Dark History, Making His Appearance in Gravity Falls Shocking

Gravity Falls Slenderman reference.
Gravity Falls Slenderman reference.

The lore of Slenderman originated on the website creepypasta, reportedly by ‘Something Awful’ forum user Eric Knudsen. Slenderman has become iconic within the online horror community, with his tall, faceless appearance, his black suit, black tendrils, and horrifically long arms. Slenderman is known for terrorizing people in the forest, primarily children. In fact, the fictional character even found itself at the center of a real-world crime involving an attempted murder in Waukesha, Wiconsin dubbed the 'Slender Man Stabbing', one which was committed allegedly in the name of Slenderman. While that horrific tragedy was in no way endorsed or provoked by the story of Slenderman, the character itself was linked to it from that point forward. Now, when one thinks of Slenderman, they think of that tragedy–a dark association that is now, by extension, connected to Gravity Falls.

Aside from the real-world impacts of the character, Slenderman’s presence is absolutely terrifying within this Gravity Falls story based on its fictitious lore alone. If Slenderman terrorizes children, and he wanted to buy Dipper and Pacifica, then that means the two beloved characters were incredibly close to suffering a horrifying fate. While Gravity Falls can get away with showing a lot of stuff that children won’t understand or fully appreciate, it is doubtful the series could show Slenderman in action–easily making his cameo in Gravity Falls the series’ darkest reference.

Next: Rick & Morty's Birdperson Twist Makes Phoenixperson Way More Tragic