The horror genre has always done quite well at the box office, but these 10 blockbusters are almost completely forgotten today. Unlike a lot of other genres which have inflated budgets and niche audiences, horror is cheap to make and has mass appeal. That's probably why it's been consistently lucrative since the birth of popular cinema over a century ago.

Franchise after franchise has sprung up over the decades, with some becoming multi-billion-dollar series. The quality of the films is often irrelevant, and a good monster will have fans screaming in and out of theaters on a yearly basis. Unfortunately, this means that horror is also one of the most disposable genres in cinema.

The vast majority of horror flicks are downright forgettable, even the ones that turn a huge profit at the box office. Monetary success and quality are frequently separated when it comes to genre cinema, and blockbuster status doesn't mean a film will live forever. In fact, some of the highest-grossing horrors of all time have faded from popular memory.

Some forgotten horror blockbusters are downright bad movies that deserve their fate, while others are simply lost to time for no good reason. Many retain a dedicated fanbase, but are often overlooked as blockbusters. No matter why these movies are no longer remembered, horror is the genre that produces the most overlooked hits.

10 Willard (1971) - $14 Million

Though Willard is the lowest-grossing film on the list, it was still a big hit in 1971. The touching and creepy story of a boy and his pet rat transcended its drive-in horror roots to become a surprise hit that even spawned a sequel. Considering where horror went in the decade, Willard seems quaint by comparison.

It's no surprise that Willard is a forgotten horror blockbuster, and most of its charms have worn off in the decades since its release. Willard was followed by a legion of imitators, but failed to embrace the shifting trends of horror that transformed the genre in the '70s. Nevertheless, it was a profitable little flick.

9 Exorcist II: The Heretic (1977) - $30 Million

Linda Blair holds a ceramic dove in Exorcist II
Linda Blair holds a ceramic dove in Exorcist 2

The abysmal follow-up to The Exorcist is only remembered for its failure, and it's tidy box office profit has been completely overshadowed. Most unnecessary sequels are unimaginative, but Exorcist II suffers from a glut of ideas. Nevertheless, none of those ideas are particularly good, and the movie is one big mess.

The movie was a hit, but vastly underperformed compared to its predecessor. It was quite expensive to make, so its $30 million gross was just enough to eke out a profit. There's a reason it took 13 years for another Exorcist sequel, and the franchise has been unable to replicate the original's success.

8 Jaws 3-D (1983) - $88 Million

Jaws probably never should have become a franchise, but the first sequel is an acceptable ripoff of the original. The same cannot be said for Jaws 3-D, the point where the shark attack series went completely off the rails. The 3-D film isn't necessarily forgotten, but it's huge box office gross is overlooked.

The third film continued the downward financial trend started by Jaws 2, but was much more successful than its successor later in the decade. Any film that makes nearly $100 million (in 1980s money no less) is a bona fide hit, but its success was likely inflated by the temporary popularity of the 3-D gimmick in the early 1980s.

7 Flatliners (1990) - $61 Million

Julia Roberts walks away from Kevin Bacon in Flatliners
Julia Roberts walks away from Kevin Bacon in Flatliners

With a hot young cast on the poster, Flatliners shocked on its way to a pretty nice profit in 1990. The sci-fi horror film had a heady concept and a somewhat goofy execution, and continued the trend of horror's aimlessness in the '90s. It's a difficult movie to properly categorize, which is probably why it isn't well-remembered today.

Julia Roberts alone was enough to guarantee that Flatliners would be a success, and her popularity helped carry the film to box office gold. One reason the movie is forgotten is because it tip-toes around its own concept, and doesn't offer much of a payoff. Anyone who has seen it once isn't likely to return to watch it again.

6 Wolf (1994) - $131 Million

Jack Nicholson snarls in a tree in Wolf
Jack Nicholson in Wolf

The later years of Jack Nicholson's career were pretty weird, and his starring role in Wolf is probably the weirdest of all. Mike Nichols' dark romance horror film combines the worlds of publishing and lycanthropy in a mixture that only works about half the time. Nicholson and co-star James Spader are the movie's saving grace.

Wolf is a decidedly forgettable movie, but its $130 million box office gross is harder to ignore. Considering it cost $70 million to make, Wolf may have been a rare blockbuster that actually lost money in the long run. Nevertheless, it was popular enough to sell a lot of tickets, but has still faded into the background of horror history.

5 Gothika (2003) - $141 Million

Gothika falls squarely in the "forgotten because it's bad" category, and even Halle Berry can't save it. The mind-bending thriller was one trope after another, punctuated with shocking moments of gore and violence. Costs were relatively low, so Gothika's $141 million box office turned into a decent profit for Warner Bros.

Not all twisty shockers lose rewatch value after the secrets are revealed, but Gothika did. It squandered a lot of strong performances, and had a silliness that kept it from ever truly becoming the thrill ride that it promised. Horror was in a rough place in the early 2000s, and Gothika was one of many utterly forgettable financial success stories.

4 The Others (2001) - $210 Million

Nicole Kidman stands with a young child in a veil in The Others
Nicole Kidman stands with a young child in a veil in The Others

Nicole Kidman's haunting horror film, The Others, was once considered an Aughts cult classic. Taking a page from the Gothic horror of old, the spooky film stood out from the deluge of unoriginal films that were hitting theaters in the early days of the new millennium. Its cult status was never justified because of its humongous box office.

Any film that makes over $200 million against a sub-$20 million budget is not cult, but The Others is overlooked. It didn't have the staying power of other classic horror films, and it took decades for it to resurface in contemporary genre discourse. Its inclusion in the Criterion Collection means the forgotten box office smash won't be forgotten much longer.

3 Constantine (2005) - $230 Million

Keanu Reeves looking angry with his tie flapping in the wind in Constantine
Keanu Reeves looks angry in Constantine

Constantine was an overlooked comic book movie, and a forgotten box office success. The adaptation of DC's beloved horror comic utterly failed to bring the pulpy icon from page to screen, but it was a pretty good film on its own merits. The bombastic action horror drew in a big audience and over $200 million at the box office.

Bad reviews were one reason that Constantine was forgotten, but they weren't the only reason. The movie couldn't split the difference between its comic book audience and its horror audience, so neither were particularly pleased with the finished result. Cult classic status was assigned to the forgotten horror blockbuster almost immediately, but the sequel still stalled.

2 What Lies Beneath (2000) - $290 Million

Michelle Pfeiffer leans on Harrison Ford in What Lies Beneath
Michelle Pfieffer and Harrison Ford in What Lies Beneath

It sounds impossible for a $300 million horror movie to be completely forgotten, but that's exactly what happened to What Lies Beneath. The moody supernatural thriller starred Harrison Ford and Michelle Pfeiffer, and was directed by the legendary Robert Zemeckis. It wasn't a bad movie, but it was painfully average overall.

The stars made What Lies Beneath a hit, but there was nothing to keep viewers coming back for more viewings. The twist was bland and uninspired, and there was nothing else to discover upon rewatch. Nevertheless, What Lies Beneath cracked the top 10 at the box office for the stacked year of 2000.

1 Hannibal (2001) - $351 Million

Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter with a knife in Hannibal 2001
Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter with a knife in Hannibal 2001

Hannibal left such a sour taste in the audience's mouths that the long-awaited sequel was promptly forgotten. Released 10 years after The Silence of the Lambs, the adaptation of Thomas Harris' third Hannibal Lecter book was just as misguided as its printed source material. Even so, it made over $350 million at the box office.

That was enough to make it one of the highest-grossing horror films of all time, but it was overshadowed by its predecessor and successor in the Lecter franchise. Few franchises dipped so hard between installments, and Hannibal had none of the appeal of its Oscar-winning prequel. Red Dragon released the next year, and saw a significant dip in box office.

Sources: Box Office Mojo, The Numbers