Billy from The Irregulars displayed several scars across his chest in his first scene, but the show never fully explores their origin. The Irregulars, Netflix’s latest Sherlock Holmes adaptation, focuses on the adventures of a group of poor teenagers Watson hires to do the work that he and Sherlock cannot be involved in themselves. The Irregulars are desperately trying to make ends meet until their arrangement with Watson provides them with steady employment. While the Irregulars were only background characters in the original stories, this reinvention of Sherlock Holmes put their lives and hardships front and center, including their time in an infamous British institution that was the most likely source of Billy’s scars.
Billy was first introduced while participating in a boxing match to make rent money, where the shirtless fight revealed Billy’s jagged scars. The Irregulars later discuss that their last resort to survive is the workhouse, but Billy, Bea, and Jessie have already been in the workhouse and refuse to go back. Later, Billy also confronts the man from the workhouse who beat and mistreated him and Bea. This time in the workhouse is probably the explanation for Billy’s scars, as real historical workhouses were known for their terrible conditions.
Related: The Irregulars True Story: The Golden Dawn Secret Society Explained
It makes sense for Sherlock Holmes’ famous homeless network to have connections to the workhouse, since workhouses were the last resort of many people in poverty in Victorian England. The workhouses were known for forced child labor, mistreatment, malnutrition, and beatings. During the heyday of workhouses, Charles Dickens often highlighted their shocking conditions in his literature, lambasting the way they treated children and families most famously in Oliver Twist and A Christmas Carol, but Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes works were usually silent on the matter.
Mortality rates in workhouses were high, and the conditions were similar to a prison. The inmates were often relegated to hard manual labor, like crushing bone for fertilizer. Food was scarce, and in some workhouses it was reported inmates were fighting over scraps. Sometimes those who managed the workhouse were so openly cruel that they received prison sentences for mistreating children. Subject to conditions like that, it’s little wonder that the characters in The Irregulars would carry scars from the workhouse, both physical and psychological.
Billy’s scars are indicative of the extremely harsh circumstances for people in poverty in Victorian England. There are multiple explanations for his scars just within the workhouse, ranging from the beatings of the workhouse managers to fights with other inmates to an accident with the dangerous manual labor inmates commonly did. Unlike many adaptations of Victorian literature, The Irregulars doesn’t shy away from what it meant to be a child on the streets of London in Sherlock Holmes’ time.