Warning: This contains SPOILERS for Lanterns episode 2!
A new mystery is afoot in DC and HBO's Lanterns after episode 2 regarding who is a Manhunter in disguise, with several major characters in the series becoming possible answers. After Lanterns episode 1's ending, it seemed that John Stewart (Aaron Pierre) investigating Hal Jordan's (Kyle Chandler) death would be a central discovery, but the show immediately pivoted to a wrinkle in their earlier investigation in Rushville, Nebraska.
Lanterns episode 2 proved to be crucial to John as he was abducted by Antaan (Paul Ben-Victor) and his fellow aliens in disguise with the hopes of recruiting the Green Lantern in training to avenge them. Antaan reveals the truth of the Green Lantern's history in the galaxy and teaches John about the shape-shifting alien race known as Manhunters. According to Antaan, the last living Manhunter is tied to Rushville.
The extraterrestrial gives John 48 hours to uncover the Manhunter's secret identity, or else they will attack the town and kill most of the small town. Lanterns episode 2's ending wraps up before John can start this new mission, leaving the mystery to be uncovered as Lanterns' remaining episodes release.
It's unclear if John will identify the hidden Manhunter in episode 3 or beyond, but his suspect list becomes anyone in Rushville. So who could it be? We can rule out John or Hal, as well as Antaan, while Thaal Sinestro also isn't an option with his imprisonment off Earth. Let's run down all the different possibilities for which character is the Manhunter in Lanterns based on how likely the twist reveal seems.
5 Billy Macon
Of Lanterns' characters who could be central to the Manhunter twist, Billy Macon (Jason Ritter) is the least likely candidate. On one hand, the Manhunter taking on the cover of William Macon's son and the husband of the town's sheriff would make some sense. It'd give him plenty of protection, and he's allowed to mostly slide under the radar thanks to this.
But in terms of what would make for the best reveal from a narrative perspective, Billy being the Manhunter would be lacking. He's not important enough to the main story or characters at this point. Unless something shifts in the episodes ahead or Lanterns wants to pull the rug out on viewers by going with the Manhunter having an unassuming identity, Billy doesn't seem like the answer to this mystery.
4 Kerry Kane
There is a world where Lanterns drops a bit of a bombshell and makes Kerry Kane (Kelly Macdonald) the Manhunter. She was not born and raised in Rushville, moving there from Gotham "on a whim" as episode 2 revealed. This small detail for her backstory conjures connections to Batman, but it could be a clever lie by the Manhunter to explain her sudden appearance in Rushville from the start.
It would make some sense for the shape-shifting alien to work their way to being the sheriff of a small town, ensuring that they would always be in the know about any investigations that could trace back to them. Furthermore, one could explain that Kerry's knowledge of how Macon was identifying aliens didn't come strictly from keen observation skills, but rather intergalactic experience avoiding such detection.
Kerry being the Manhunter would be a shocking twist, especially for Hal, but it does not seem to be fully in the cards. John is searching for the Lantern in 2016, yet he and Kerry are still friendly after the 10-year time jump to 2026. He could befriend the Manhunter and keep Kerry's identity a secret from Antaan or not even figure it out. But those options seem less likely.
3 William Macon
Lanterns is still in the early stages of putting its whole story together, but one thing that is clear already is that William Macon (Garret Dillahunt) holds lots of secrets and isn't an ally Hal and John can rely on. His position as the show's primary villain to this point makes him an obvious candidate to be the Manhunter and the linchpin to Hal and John's investigations.
The show has already shown William is aware of aliens in Rushville and sees them as a threat. He suggests he's doing what is necessary to protect his town, but his alien hunting mission takes on a new light if he is the Manhunter. He'd be eliminating any extraterrestrial threat that comes to town, including those that could be seeking to find and kill him.
A twist of some fashion does appear to be on the horizon with William, but being the Manhunter John is looking for is only one option. There have long been theories that William's last name is Hand, not Bacon, making him the longtime Green Lantern villain known as Black Hand. That may ultimately be where William's fate lies, leaving Lanterns with the chance to make someone else the Manhunter.
2 Macon's Benefactor
There is always the chance that Lanterns introduces a new character who is then revealed to be the Manhunter in the weeks ahead, but rather than making someone the characters aren't even aware of tied to this mystery, the show could utilize the mysterious benefactor William Macon answers to. Both episodes so far have teased this overarching presence, with Hal even questioning if they are real or just a cover for William in episode 2, which he denied.
If this benefactor is a different person, they would make a lot of sense as the Manhunter. The individual has made anyone associated with them sign extensive NDAs to protect their secrets. This person is also responsible for pushing William to keep an eye on alien activity in Rushville. And as detailed in episode 2, William's mysterious boss is also the source of the alien-detecting technology they deploy.
This would hardly be the first time a TV show has teased the real villain and kept them off-screen, only for them to enter the picture later on. Something similar even happened with True Detective season 1, which Lanterns is heavily inspired by. There, HBO's detective series only had the killer in three episodes, with their first appearance not coming until episode 3. Assuming this benefactor will appear in future episodes, they are a strong possibility, although not who I'd consider most likely.
1 Zoe Macon
So far, Zoe Macon (Poorna Jagannathan) has only been featured as John's romantic interest and William's wife. Lanterns has still done a good job of establishing that she is powerful but mysterious, giving her a compelling case to be the Manhunter on a number of levels.
It would be an incredibly smart move by the Manhunter to be with William, as making this life as Zoe gives her the ultimate cover. He would never suspect her, but she has all the knowledge of his plans, allowing her to avoid detection when necessary. There is no safer place for the Manhunter than at William's side, presumably as his most trusted relationship.
There is also the fallout storywise to consider. For the Manhunter reveal to be really effective, it needs to shake up the leads. Hal might not care that Zoe is an alien, but John would. He has a growing connection to her emotionally and romantically that would complicate this matter. He even tells her during their conversation in episode 2 that he sees her and understands her, which he believes. Yet, he might not even truly know who he's been talking to.
John would likely be less willing to tell Antaan the Manhunter's identity if it is Zoe, which could allow Lanterns to pull back more layers of this character as it explores what he'd do next. That makes Zoe the prime suspect in my mind. This twist would check a lot of boxes when it comes to what it would mean for the characters and story. There are other paths Lanterns could ultimately still go down, but Zoe makes the most sense to be the Manhunter in hiding.
Disagree? Share your theories in the comments!
- Release Date
- August 16, 2026
- Network
- HBO
- Showrunner
- Chris Mundy
- Directors
- Alik Sakharov, James Hawes, Stephen Williams, Geeta Patel
- Writers
- Damon Lindelof, Chris Mundy, Tom King, Vanessa Baden Kelly, Justin Britt-Gibson, Breannah Gibson
Cast
-
Kyle ChandlerHal Jordan -
Aaron PierreJohn Stewart
- Franchise(s)
- DC Universe
- Creator(s)
- Tom King, Chris Mundy, Damon Lindelof