Lost is a wonderful TV show. It managed to capture the collective imagination of the general public, often generating upwards of twenty million viewers per week. It was also a rich show, both in terms of story, theme, and character. The mysteries driving the show were captivating, the philosophical themes proved thoughtful and academic, and most of the characters were written and performed with depth.
In fact, Lost is one of the rare shows in which each character was interesting and/or entertaining in their own unique way. Unfortunately, some were given less screen time than others...
Desmond Hume
Desmond is quite a big player throughout Lost, but some fans may be surprised at just how little he's actually in the show. Desmond is introduced in season two, but he only appears in the premiere and finale. He plays quite a large role throughout seasons three and four but essentially disappears from the show in season five. According to Lostpedia, Desmond only appears in 46 of the show's 121 episodes. It's a shame, because he really is one of the best, most intriguing, and most emotionally resonant characters on the show.
Mr. Eko
Eko is a character whose incredible potential was unfortunately cut short by a personal decision in the actor's life. Showrunners Damon Lindelof and Carlton Cuse reportedly had big plans for Mr. Eko, and he was intrinsically linked to the island's mythology throughout season two. Unfortunately, actor Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje didn't want to do the show anymore and was written off, leaving Eko's storyline tragically incomplete - and ultimately disappointing.
Walt Lloyd
Speaking of storylines being tragically incomplete, Walt's is perhaps the most incomplete. The first and second seasons promised lots of intrigue when it came to Walt, his ability to conjure animals, his "special-ness," and what seemed like an ability to project his body through space and time. Unfortunately, none of these storylines came to fruition, and Walt's failure to reach his potential as a character still proves one of Lost's biggest disappointments. While most of Lost's mysteries were answered (despite the common misconception), Walt's storyline remains frustratingly inconclusive.
Shannon Rutherford
The character of Shannon Rutherford, while not a particular fan favorite, showed a lot of promise. While she was mostly portrayed as a dramatic and shallow Mean Girl throughout season one, those personality traits could have proved the starting blocks for a fantastic character arc.
Shannon showed some depth in her flashbacks, and it was great to see another, more tragic, and ultimately more human side to her character. Unfortunately, Shannon's storyline was cut disappointingly short after she was killed by Ana Lucia.
Ana Lucia Cortez
Speaking of Ana Lucia, she is another character who deserved a bit more screen time. Played by the popular Michelle Rodriguez, it seemed like Ana Lucia would be staying around for a while, perhaps serving as Jack's tough female counterpart. Unfortunately, fans didn't take too kindly to her cold and abrasive personality, and she was quickly deemed one of the worst characters on the show. With just a bit more screen time and maybe another flashback or two (to flesh out her character a little more), Ana Lucia could have been turned into a great character.
Richard Alpert
Richard Alpert was one of the most intriguing characters on Lost. Unfortunately, he wasn't utilized very often. Fans were clamoring for more information on Alpert owing to a variety of factors, including his "Other-ness" (as witnessed by Ben's flashbacks), his unique interactions with Locke, and his lack of aging. That major mystery was gracefully answered in season six's Ab Aeterno, a shining light in an otherwise disappointing season and one of the greatest episodes the show ever produced.
Frank Lapidus
Played by the wonderful Jeff Fahey, Frank Lapidus proved a great source of comedic relief. Unfortunately, Lapidus never received much screen time, and fans never learned much about his personal life owing to a disappointing lack of flashbacks. Even though he's part of the Kahana crew, he is arguably the one given the least amount of screen time, with Miles, Faraday, and even Charlotte being given far greater importance in the story. More Lapidus would certainly not have been a bad thing.
Jacob & The Man In Black
Season six faced, and continues to face, a lot of criticism from the television community. One of these criticisms is the rushed story and the awkward way the show integrated Jacob and The Man in Black into the wider narrative.
Both Jacob and The Man in Black aren't seen in their human forms until the fifth season finale, and their personal story isn't given precedence until late into the sixth season. Personal feelings of the characters aside, this is far too late to delve into the island's mythology and the main antagonist's motives. These two desperately needed some fleshing out.
Rose & Bernard
Rose and Bernard were perhaps the greatest couple on the show. Their personalities prove amiable, and their respective storyline proved a mirror of both Locke's and Sawyer's. Rose knew that her cancer had gone away upon crashing on the island, mirroring Locke's ability to walk again. Meanwhile, both Rose and Bernard agreed to stay on the island, feeling much happier, safer (owing to the lack of cancer), and more content (much like Sawyer). They provided the show with a lot of heart, and fans could have used more of it!
Eloise Hawking
Much like Jacob and The Man in Black, the presence of Eloise Hawking could have done much in expanding on the island's mythology and ultimately make the ending more satisfying. As it is, Eloise is another character with far more promise and potential than what was actually given. Eloise is obviously a major player in the island's mythology, but she only appears in ten episodes of the show (according to Lostpedia). With just a bit more screen time, perhaps fans could have learned more about the island, its history, and how it worked.