The Lost series finale came as something of a relief in 2010. After two untouchable seasons, Lost began to feel the weight of its many, many mysteries, and the lack of direction started becoming apparent. Lost still managed to deliver the goods during its less spectacular years. Season 3's ending felt epic, season 4's "The Constant" remains one of the greatest TV episodes of all time, and season 6 thrived due to the endgame finally being mapped out. Nevertheless, not even Lost's most dedicated fans could suggest ending with season 6 was premature.

There have been many rumblings of a potential Lost revival or reboot over the years. Nothing concrete has ever materialized, but given studios' increasing reliance on familiar IPs and Lost's era-defining legacy, it would be a miracle if another visit to the Island never happened. Lost's ending didn't overtly set up future stories, but one small detail could serve as the launching point for a sequel featuring new survivors and a fresh threat to the Island.

Hurley's Death Sets Up A Potential Lost Sequel Series

The church reunion scene in Lost's finale
The church reunion scene in Lost's finale

Everyone is dead in Lost's finale. Not in the "they were dead all along" sense, thankfully, but the flash-sideways timeline serves as a meeting place for the survivors to reunite one last time before moving onto the afterlife. It doesn't matter whether they die during the show, like Boone, or many years later, like Kate and Sawyer - all paths lead to the church in Lost's finale.

Curiously, Hurley is there too. After becoming the Island's protector, Hurley would have gained the power of agelessness, so he likely died centuries - perhaps even millennia - after everyone else at the big Oceanic reunion. But if Hurley can't perish from natural causes due to the protector's powers, that suggests he was murdered sometime after Lost's finale.

We know very little about Hurley's reign as Island protector. "The End" confirms he enjoys a close, fruitful relationship with his second-in-command, Ben Linus, and "The New Man in Charge" shows Hurley recruiting Walt to help the Island's dead souls move into the afterlife. Those details aside, Hurley's time on the Island is a blank period in Lost's timeline.

And yet, the fact Hurley dies at all implies that another "Lost" happens after Lost.

Another threat comes to the Island, whether that be scientists, explorers, or wealthy entrepreneurs looking to harness the Heart of the Island's strange energy. Hurley tries valiantly to protect it, just as Jacob did before him, but he ultimately dies in the process. Perhaps Hurley planned for such an occasion and summoned a new group of candidates to the Island in the hope of finding a replacement, exactly the way Hurley himself got hired.

The history of Lost's Island - which we see plenty of throughout the series - reveals two constants. Firstly, unscrupulous individuals always come to the Island for one reason or another. Secondly, every protector of the Island winds up getting stabbed. Unless both streaks are broken, Lost history suggests Hurley would have been murdered by a villainous visitor to the Island.

The only detail we can glean from Lost's finale is that Ben doesn't betray Hurley. Their final conversation exudes deep respect and friendship, meaning Ben stays right by Hurley's side through the trouble. Nevertheless, their conversation also makes no reference to the fate of the Island or what enemies they might have faced. The two pals merely congratulate each other on carrying out their respective roles as best they could. That alone means little - Jacob did his best too, and look how that turned out.

There's one especially bleak possibility behind Hurley's presence at the church in Lost's finale. If Hurley gets killed because he's unable to protect the Island, and there's no replacement waiting in the wings, the entire world would end after Hurley's death. Potentially, Hurley enters the church knowing exactly when and how the extinction of humanity happens, which is certainly a strange thought.

The More Mundane Explanation Behind Hurley's Death In Lost

Close up of Walt Lloyd played by Malcolm David Kelley, staring off into the distance, in Lost

There's no doubt that Hurley's death could be used as the starting point for a Lost sequel if such a thing ever materialized. Indeed, the death of the Island's protector would present a fascinating way to kick off the pilot episode and add a different spice to the revival.

Even if the Lost brand remains untouched, however, it's still possible to explain Hurley's presence at the church without creating further mysteries. When Hurley hires Walt for a "job" in "The New Man in Charge," Michael's son is potentially being lined up as Hurley's replacement as protector of the Island.

After all, Walt's connection to the Island was stronger than any of the other Oceanic 815 passengers. Hurley perhaps recognizes this, and uses his tenure as protector to educate and prepare Walt as a successor more suitable for the job. When the time comes and Walt is ready to step up, Hurley would step down, becoming mortal again (Alpert proves this is possible) and living the rest of his life as a normal person while Walt takes control of the Island.

Tellingly, Walt doesn't appear in the final church scene that closes out Lost's finale, which might serve as proof that, after being anointed by Hurley, he remains the Island's protector for the rest of time.

0372371_poster_w780.jpg
186
8.4/10
9/10

Lost

Release Date
2004 - 2010-00-00
Network
ABC
Showrunner
Damon Lindelof, Carlton Cuse
Directors
Jack Bender, Paul A. Edwards, Tucker Gates, Eric Laneuville, Bobby Roth, Greg Yaitanes, Daniel Attias, J.J. Abrams, Karen Gaviola, Kevin Hooks, Rod Holcomb, Stephen Semel, Adam Davidson, Alan Taylor, David Grossman, Deran Sarafian, Fred Toye, Mario Van Peebles, Marita Grabiak, Mark Goldman, Matt Earl Beesley, Michael Zinberg, Paris Barclay, Robert Mandel
Writers
Jim Galasso, Christina M. Kim, Graham Roland, Kyle Pennington, Brent Fletcher, Dawn Lambertsen Kelly, Janet Tamaro, Jeffrey Lieber, Paul Dini, Jordan Rosenberg
  • Headshot Of Matthew Fox
    Matthew Fox
    Jack Shephard
  • Headshot Of Evangeline Lilly In The UK Gala Screening of
    Evangeline Lilly
    Kate Austen

Creator(s)
J.J. Abrams, Damon Lindelof, Jeffrey Lieber