Summary
- Lost suffered from changes in its original plans, leading to mixed reactions from audiences and certain unresolved questions. Running a TV show for six seasons is a major challenge.
- Jack's character was supposed to die in the pilot, but the plan changed due to actor availability. His dynamics with Locke created some of the show's best drama.
- Kate was initially planned to be the leader of the survivors, but the change in plot left her with limited storylines and criticism for being immature.
As the show unfolded, it became clear that Lost wasn't planned from beginning to end at the start, and some of its earlier ideas would've changed the show drastically. For six seasons, Lost kept its massive audience on their toes, constantly throwing new mysteries into the pot while viewers were still trying to piece old ones together. When the series finally ended, the reactions were mixed, as audiences felt that certain questions hadn't been resolved.
Love it or hate it, it's undeniable that many of the original plans for Lost fell through, and the show suffered in some aspects because of it. Running a TV show for six seasons is a major challenge, and multiple unavoidable factors worked against Lost. While some changes worked against the show, other writing decisions actually benefited the series.
10 Jack Was Supposed To Die In The Pilot
Jack Shepherd is the hero of Lost, from the show's opening sequence, to the final conflict. Funnily enough, J.J. Abrams' original plan was for Jack to die in the pilot, hoping to shock audiences with an early plot twist. Before Matthew Fox starred in the role, Michael Keaton was actually interested in the role. After the plan to kill off Jack was changed, Keaton lost interest, as he wasn't into committing to a full TV series. Jack wasn't always the fan-favorite in Lost, but he's undoubtedly integral to the series, particularly in his dynamics with Locke that create some of the show's best drama.
9 Kate Was Going To Be The Leader
When Jack was meant to be killed off, the plan was for Kate to be the leader of the survivors. Following this change, Jack remained the star of the show, and Kate never took on a primary leadership role. Kate became the target of much criticism toward Lost, as it seemed like she never really had much to do. Actor Evangeline Lilly even expressed that she found Kate obnoxious after a while. Kate essentially became known for her romance plot lines with Jack and Sawyer, and was criticized for being immature and causing unnecessary trouble.
8 Claire Was A Surrogate Mother
Originally planned to be a surrogate mother for two friends, Claire's story changed to her having her own baby, which was to be put up for adoption. Discussed in the season one DVD extras, the plan for Claire changed sometime around the start of production. While it seems like both plot lines would've resulted in Claire having to decide to become a mother, surrogacy would've added to the show's philosophical questions about fate. In the series, Claire had some conflict about whether she wanted to keep her baby. If she was a surrogate mother, she might not have had this conflict, but would've been forced into it by circumstance.
7 Ben And Desmond Were Limited Roles
Two of the best characters in Lost, Benjamin Linus and Desmond Hume, were added in season 2. According to the Official Lost Podcast, these additions were actually only meant to be on the show for three episodes each. However, both characters and actors received extremely positive responses. Ben was brought back for five more episodes that season, and Desmond returned to be the flashback character in the season 2 finale. With Desmond's flashbacks, Penny and Charles Widmore were also introduced, who would become more important later on. While episodic television has its flaws, being able to adjust to audience reaction mid-season is certainly a positive.
6 Nikki And Paulo Had A Bigger Storyline
Nikki and Paulo were introduced to Lost in season 3, with the premise that they had been part of the survivors camp the whole time. This was met with backlash from fans, as they felt needlessly shoehorned in. While season 3 introduced strong characters like Juliet, Nikki and Paulo were widely hated, and killed off pretty quickly. While there was originally a bigger story planned for the characters, their flashback episode "Exposé," became their final appearance, that saw the two gruesomely buried alive.
5 The Heart Of The Island Was Going To Be A Volcano
In the third season DVD extras, Lost producers discussed the episode "The Man Behind the Curtain." The episode sees Ben's upbringing for the first time. In the episode's DVD commentary, the island's volcano was described to be very important. The original plan was for the Heart of the Island, the glowing cave where the Smoke Monster is created, to actually be in the volcano. On top of that, Jack and the Man In Black's final fight was supposed to happen in the volcano, with magma spewing around them, akin to Lord of the Rings or the Star Wars prequels. This didn't happen due to budget reasons.
4 More Flashbacks Were Planned
As the flashbacks of older characters began to grow boring, Lost introduced new characters to reveal backstories for. Season 4 of Lost was cut short due to the 2007-08 writer's strike, which unfortunately resulted in the science team of Daniel, Miles, and Charlotte all having their flashbacks condensed into one episode. Also revealed in the Official Lost Podcast, there was a plan for a Rousseau flashback as well. While Daniel and Miles had their flashbacks in season 5, Charlotte and Rousseau never had theirs.
3 Eko Was Supposed To Be End Game
Mr. Eko was one of the most interesting characters introduced from the tail-section of Oceanic 815. Originally planned to be on the show for at least four seasons, actor Adewale Akinnuoye-Agbaje decided to leave the show. Mr. Eko was originally the character that would begin having psychic visions, a plot that would eventually go to Desmond instead. Eko's supernatural abilities were teased in season 2, when he dreamed of Ana Lucia's gunshot wounds before finding out about her death. The character was intended to have a multi-season arc to discover his spirituality, becoming hugely important to the story and island's mythos.
2 The Smoke Monster Was Originally Mechanical
The monster was one of the show's biggest mysteries, both before and after audiences knew what it looked like. Eventually confirmed to be a pillar of black smoke, and later to actually be the Man in Black, all audiences originally knew was that it had a distinct, mechanical sound. The monster was originally meant to be a mechanical construct built by the Dharma Initiative. While this is certainly neat to envision and definitely would've built on the show's science fiction elements, the mechanical sound effects on a mystical creature are an amazing juxtaposition.
1 Walt Was Important
The most famous inconsistency in Lost is that Walt was made to feel incredibly important in season 1, then was essentially written off the show. While the details of what Walt's storyline would've been are unknown, he was established in season 1 with the idea that he would develop some sort of psychic power. Unlike most shows where one season is one year, the first four seasons of Lost only spanned about one hundred days. Walt's actor, Malcolm David Kelley, had a massive growth spurt in between seasons, making it difficult to bring him back as a regular in the early seasons, as he no longer looked 10.