Detective Inspector Thomas Lynley and his headstrong sergeant, Barbara Havers, have been reimagined for a new era in the BBC and BritBox's slick procedural detective series, Lynley. Based on the Inspector Lynley books by Elizabeth George, this is the second TV adaptation of the 8th Earl of Asherton's investigative exploits, and it's difficult not to draw comparisons to the early aughts version.
This interpretation of Thomas Lynley's story is a decidedly less atmospheric affair than the original six-year run of The Inspector Lynley Mysteries, which starred the dashing Nathaniel Parker as Thomas and the steadfast Sharon Small as Barbara. BritBox's Lynley, which features Leo Suter and Sofia Barclay as Lynley and Havers, respectively, favors thrills and action over style, though that's not necessarily to its detriment.
Lynley will likely appeal to a wider demographic, as the stories move faster and are told from an unmistakable and understandably modern perspective. Like the earlier adaptation, Lynley features four feature-length episodes in its pilot season, allowing for an exploration of present-day policing, the unlikely but effective partnership between Lynley and Havers, and a few all-too-brief glimpses into their personal lives.
The Partnership Between Lynley & Havers Is Still The Best Part Of The Show
DI Lynley and DS Havers provide an interesting dynamic. Lynley is blue-blooded, next in line to take over his family's ancestral home. Havers, meanwhile, comes from a working-class background and walks around with an undeniable chip on her shoulder, especially when it comes to workplace authority and Britain's ever-present class divide.
When Havers and Lynley are forced into a partnership, it looks as though it'll end before it's even begun. Havers is less than impressed with Lynley's Oxford resume, but it soon becomes clear that their different life experiences make them a formidable team. Havers is good at sussing out liars, while Lynley works at getting people to trust him.
Suter and Barclay's on-screen chemistry works in the show's favor, and I enjoyed the development of their friendship. Of the two, though, Barclay's Havers is the more interesting character. That's not Suter's fault; while I'd argue his version of DI Lynley carries himself with less gravitas than his predecessor, he works with the material he's given, which isn't anything groundbreaking.
His romance with estate agent Helen (Niamh Walsh) feels a little too routine, and we barely get to learn anything about his family. In fact, aside from his partnership with Havers, Lynley's most intriguing relationship is the combative one he shares with Daniel Mays' DCI Brian Nies. The undercurrent of tension and vengeance between them is compelling and comes to a head in an explosive scene in episode 4.
Lynley's Stories Feature Some Interesting Twists, But Aren't As Memorable As They Could Be
The very first episode of The Inspector Lynley Mysteries, "A Great Deliverance," released in 2001, was an eerily filmed, harrowing, psychologically-driven tale of abuse and abandonment. It's one of those rare TV detective mysteries that really stays with you, a story where, even years later, you'll remember exactly whodunit once you see them pop up on the screen.
Lynley's first four mysteries don't leave a comparable impression, but each story has obvious merits. The second episode, for instance, features a clever narrative pivot, as what seems to be a cut-and-dry stalking mystery becomes so much more. The third culminates in genuine, tragic heartbreak, and the fourth features a high-stakes ending. The victims and their stories are convincing, and it's never too easy to guess the killer's identity.
The only thing that's truly lacking here is a clear, stylistic identity. The way Lynley is filmed feels straightforward, recognizable, and almost worryingly comforting in its familiarity. It doesn't truly have a distinct visual feel, unlike other similar detective dramas such as Vera or Shetland.
These examples cleverly utilize their settings. Vera features sweeping, empty vistas that reflect DCI Vera's own loneliness. Shetland explores its isolated islands and what it's like for small communities to be affected by violent crime. Lynley could have benefited from that type of visual storytelling. Aside from one mystery in the marshes and another on a hard-to-reach estate, the most memorable location was Thomas' considerable and boldly modern beachfront rental.
On the whole, Lynley is a solid enough addition to the vast canon of British detective dramas, featuring good performances and several intriguing twists. It doesn't bring anything wholly new to the table, though, which makes it all too easy to compare this version of Lynley to everything that's come before.
Lynley premieres on BritBox on September 4, with new episodes premiering weekly until September 25.
- Release Date
- September 4, 2025
- Network
- BritBox
Cast
-
Leo SuterDI Tommy Lynley -
Sofia BarclayDS Barbara Havers
- Creator(s)
- Steve Thompson