Mass Effect: Andromeda, while attempting innovation, stumbled in its execution, leaving many long-time fans disappointed. To recapture the magic of the original trilogy and avoid repeating Andromeda's mistakes, Mass Effect 4 needs a significant course correction. This isn't about simply reverting to the old formula; it's about learning from both successes and failures. That's the only way the series can make long-time fans and newcomers happy.
There are plenty of examples of what developers can change and modify to make this Mass Effect much better than Andromeda and a worthwhile sequel. This isn't about setting itself up to fix Andromeda’s biggest issue, but about fixing multiple issues. The developers only have one chance to make a good impression, because a lackluster comeback could put the series back on hiatus.
10 Remove The Open World
This Is an Action RPG, Keep The Action Heavy



Mass Effect: Andromeda gave players a semi-open world to explore, with hubs for players to roam around. Mass Effect 4 would likely be better off without that. Dragon Age: The Veilguard does a great job showing that completely open worlds aren't always necessary, and the original trilogy had a lot of linear levels.
It seems best if the series just sticks to what worked well, because this was one of those things that turned off long-time players. The exploration was not as fun as it seemed on paper, and it just felt like it disconnected from the rest of the gameplay. Instead, the clear winner is missions where the storytellers can give a good narrative during play. There's no need for an open world in a Mass Effect game, especially when the focus should be on storytelling.
9 Bring Back Every Alien Race
Don’t Leave Any Out Again



Mass Effect: Andromeda removed so many alien races and gave the excuse that they were still traveling to the new galaxy. They then introduced new races, which were interesting but didn't feel as well-developed as the older ones. Now that the game returns to the Milky Way galaxy, the developers can bring back the races players know and love in Mass Effect 4.
They are pretty easy to get to know, too, as the three games didn't expand on them very much. Most players knew a lot about the nine Citadel races by the end of the first game, and the other non-humanoid species weren't around very often. This will give the game a feeling of nostalgia and normalcy, which was lost in Andromeda.
8 Acknowledge The Events of Mass Effect 3
We Want Some Answers



Mass Effect: Andromeda took the safe route and tried to mention the events of Mass Effect 3 as little as possible. In fact, the game makes it clear that everyone left before the arrival of the Reapers, so there's no way to know what was happening. This way, they didn't have to acknowledge anything and could create a new story. Mass Effect 4 can't do that.
Players were pretty vocal about wanting to know what happened after the Reaper invasion and if their Shepard was alive. Now that the developers are returning to the Milky Way galaxy, they need to acknowledge everything that happened. Players need to know if their choices had an effect and what happened in the time following the end of Mass Effect 3.
7 Renegade And Paragon Need To Return
It's The Best Morality System



The Paragon/Renegade system in the original Mass Effect trilogy, while simplistic, offered a compelling illusion of player agency. It wasn't just about choosing "good" or "evil;" it shaped Commander Shepard's personality, influencing dialogue options and even impacting squadmate relationships. A Renegade Shepard was blunt, aggressive, and often ruthless, while a Paragon Shepard was diplomatic, empathetic, and morally upright. This would be perfect for Mass Effect 4.
Mass Effect definitely needs to fix the Renegade system if it's brought back.
While not perfectly nuanced, this binary system provides a clear and consistent framework for player expression. Its removal in Andromeda left a void. Modern RPGs often favor complex moral grey areas, but the Paragon/Renegade system offered something different: clearly reflecting the player's chosen approach. The system didn't dictate morality; it provided a lens through which Shepard's actions were interpreted. A more modern return would improve the system rather than replace it.
6 No Vehicle Traversal
Don’t You Dare Say Mako



The Mass Effect series keeps trying to make the player enjoy vehicle exploration, and it hasn't worked yet. Every Mass Effect, either through the vanilla game or DLCs, has had some kind of vehicle driving and fighting parts. This has never been what the games have been loved for, and many times, players just want it gone. Without it, Mass Effect 4 would be a lot better.
This game needs to end the vicious cycle and just give up on any form of vehicle combat. The developers don't need to waste their time trying to give players a vehicle combat system. It's usually the worst part of any Mass Effect game and should be done away with here.
5 A Much Better Character Creator
Let Us Make Our Characters Well



Mass Effect: Andromeda's character creator was better than the original trilogy's, but still not the best around. Today, character creators need to be really high-end or focused on giving players a lot to do and change. This isn't just about inclusion, but about letting players be exactly who they want to be with little effort in Mass Effect 4.
This time, the character creator should be more like Dragon Age: The Veilguard. That game is a good example of an RPG character creator today that doesn't go as far as Dragon's Dogma or inZOI. It's something that Mass Effect 4 has to get right because it didn't feel very good in Andromeda. A lot of the characters in Andromeda looked off, and that may be because of the limitations of the character creator.
4 More Music
It Was Quiet, Too Quiet



Mass Effect: Andromeda was noticeably quiet compared to other games in the series. Most Mass Effect games had music that played the moment something happened or just when the player was moving around. It was so often that the times without noise were even more important, and it felt like something big was happening.
Mass Effect 4 needs to bring back the music and ambiance that the trilogy had established well. It helps a lot with combat and with immersion. It's so unsettling when players need to go across areas, and it's quiet everywhere. This isn't the feeling a player should have from an RPG that mostly revolves around its intense action, so a soundtrack with a lot of background music will help a lot.
3 Bring Back the Power Wheel
We Give The Orders Around Here



The power wheel in the original Mass Effect trilogy was an important element of squad-based combat. This lets players have tactical control beyond simply aiming and shooting. This radial menu lets players direct commands to squadmates, impacting combat effectiveness and strategic depth. Players can quickly select individual squad members and assign them targets, ordering attacks on specific enemies, prioritizing threats, or focusing fire.
Beyond target designation, the wheel lets players pause the combat and make tactical decisions. Players can also instruct squadmates to move to specific locations. Finally, the power wheel lets players manage squadmate abilities. This was taken out so players could mostly focus on their own abilities. It didn't work well and felt much worse than the easy one to control in the original trilogy.
2 No More Puzzles
Andromeda's Puzzles Were Really Dull



Mass Effect: Andromeda's puzzles just weren't as engaging as the developer probably wanted them to be. Their shortcomings stemmed from feeling like they cut out the action and were a chore players had to complete. Many felt like arbitrary obstacles, disconnected from the overarching plot and character motivations, hindering the flow rather than enhancing it.
The solutions often lacked ingenuity, relying heavily on predictable patterns or easily identified visual clues, thereby minimizing player agency and problem-solving satisfaction. Instead of forcing puzzles, the focus should be on making a third-person shooter action RPG, like the previous games. Mass Effect: Andromeda is the most boring of the series because it tried to make this puzzle element a big component of a series that was not known for its puzzles.
1 Make Sure the Game Is Ready
Stop Releasing Broken Games



Mass Effect: Andromeda's troubled launch significantly damaged the franchise's reputation and was a big part of why the series went on a hiatus. There was no saving it after a clearly broken launch. This is a wound Mass Effect 4 must avoid. Andromeda's release was plagued by many issues stemming from insufficient time in development. Facial animations were widely mocked, creating an uncanny valley effect that broke immersion.
The negative reception stemmed directly from this lack of preparedness. The game felt unfinished, as if a significant portion of its potential had been unrealized. For Mass Effect 4 to succeed, it must learn from Andromeda's mistakes. A polished, bug-free release is crucial; anything less risks repeating the same critical and commercial failure that marred Andromeda's legacy. If Mass Effect 4 can do this, it will be a lot better than Andromeda.
-
OpenCritic Reviews
- Top Critic Avg: 72/100 Critics Rec: 40%
- Released
- March 1, 2017
- ESRB
- M for Mature: Blood, Nudity, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Violence
- Developer(s)
- BioWare
- Publisher(s)
- Electronic Arts
- Engine
- Frostbite 3
- Multiplayer
- Online Multiplayer
- Franchise
- Mass Effect






Custom Image by Katarina Cimbaljevic






















Mass Effect: Andromeda Multiplayer Character Selection Screen



























