Mass Effect Legendary Edition might be almost a year old, but it's still on top of the franchise's devotees' minds, especially with the news of the upcoming Mass Effect 4. Players are revisiting the original trilogy, particularly Mass Effect 3, making sure they are up to date with Shepard's supposed last adventure.
Mass Effect 3 is an incredible game, thanks in no small part to Shepard's squadmates. Some, such as Wrex or Aria, are only available for specific missions, but the permanent squadmates are the ones that truly stand out. Their personalities are unique, and their banter with the commander and each other is near-perfect. And while every squadmate is memorable in their own way, some are far more likable than others.
James
It's not that James is unlikable. Indeed, none of the squadmates are. However, James is the one that's hardest to like. He'll often act overly casual with the Commander, which might make sense for the other companions, who have already gone through hell and back with Shepard, but James is brand new, so his behavior can rub some the wrong way.
Still, James is a great combatant, and his backstory is compelling enough. Because he is a new addition to the game, many players might find it hard to relate to him, considering they already have established and potentially romantic relationships with many of the other squadmates. However, James is still a worthy addition to the Normandy's crew.
Ashley
Unlike James, Ashley has been with Shepard since the very beginning. Virmire is one of the hardest choices in Mass Effect because players will have to deal with the survivor for the next two games. By the time the third entry comes, Ashley doesn't seem like the best choice.
She is a more than capable fighter to have around, but her personality can be off-putting. Depending on the situation, Ashley can come across as intolerant at best and xenophobic at worst. However, the more controversial parts of her personality have largely toned down by Mass Effect 3. Ashley is dependable and bold, making her one of the most memorable characters in the franchise.
Javik
Javik is a rarity in a world full of them. The last living Prothean, Javik is a bonafide instrument of war whose sole purpose is to kill the Reapers. His appearance in the game depends on completing the From the Ashes DLC, which means some players might miss him altogether. However, Javik is a worthy squadmate, not only because of his considerable power but also because he's a genuinely compelling figure.
It might take some time to warm up to Javik, but the guy has an odd charm. His comments are sometimes hilarious, although his constant use of "primitive" to describe other races can be somewhat icky. Citadel, one of the best video game DLCs of the 2010s, provides Javik with several opportunities to shine, and he makes the best of them.
Kaidan
The main complaint players often have about Kaidan is that he's boring. Indeed, Kaidan is the definition of vanilla, a serious and by-the-book soldier who lacks the same color as the other ME squadmates. Compared to Ashley, Kaidan is somewhat passive, meaning many players might choose to leave him behind on Virmire.
However, Mass Effect 3 showcases how much Kaidan has changed since his first adventure with Shepard. Whether players romance him or keep him around as a friend, Kaidan's participation in the third game reveals new layers to his previously one-note character. That he becomes available as a romance option for a male Shepard proves how different he is from the cookie-cutter version of him in the first game. Yes, he is as Canadian as ever, but he's also an invaluable companion and a great friend in times of hardship.
EDI
EDI might be the surprising standout of Mass Effect 3. Players first meet her in the second game, where she acts as the Normandy's all-seeing AI. However, she becomes a full-on squadmate once she takes over Dr. Eva Coré's body early in the third game. She retains most of her analytical and to-the-point traits, which, combined with her newly-acquired free will, turn her into one of the best characters in the franchise.
The part that synthetics play in the galaxy is a point of contention throughout the trilogy, but EDI is the perfect proof that they can be as valuable and complex as any organic companion. Her romance with Joker is also a highlight of Mass Effect 3. In fact, EDI and Joker are two of the characters fans would love to see in Mass Effect 4, provided Shepard didn't choose the Destroy option at the end of the game.
Liara
Speaking of Mass Effect 4, Liara is the only legacy squadmate confirmed to return for the new game. Makes sense, considering she's arguably the most iconic character in the franchise after Shepard. Dr. T'Soni is an invaluable member of the Normandy's crew, a compelling love interest, and an all-around great friend.
Liara is calm and collected, conducting herself with an air of regality that makes her unique among the squadmates. She's also Shepard's closest friend other than Garrus, meaning she shares a bond with them that's more intimate than any other. Liara is a staple of the Normandy and one of the best characters to have around. She has unique dialogue in nearly every mission, and her presence is always welcome.
Tali
Quarian pilgrim Tali'Zorah is a fan-favorite character in Mass Effect. She appears as a squadmate throughout the trilogy, a privilege only one other character shares. Arguably the kindest member of Shepard's crew, Tali is a walking ray of sunshine. She starts as naive and somewhat inexperienced before becoming a bonafide adventurer, thanks largely to her dealings with Shepard.
Tali is also one of the best romances in Mass Effect. Her awkward yet endearing personality is instantly likable, and her contributions to the team are unparalleled. Tali's mid-fight comments are also amazing, often providing laugh-out-loud insights into otherwise unremarkable things or situations.
Garrus
Garrus Vakarian is arguably the best companion in Mass Effect. If the player's Shepard is male, Garrus is the best bro in the world. If Shepard is female, Garrus is the best romantic partner. In short, Garrus is the best at nearly everything he does.
Most fans would say Garrus is the squadmate against whom all other characters are measured, and they would be right. Sarcastic yet calm and reassuring, Garrus is the one to have around in case of emergencies. His camaraderie with Shepard and the crew is incredible, and his self-deprecating personality makes him the most relatable of the Commander's squadmates.