Ang Lee's 2003 film Hulk has some serious problems with its special effects, but the MCU's modern-day CGI problems prove that the film was doomed from the start. Hulk was one of the earliest large-scale superhero movies, and as the story of the Incredible Hulk, the film needed to focus on an entirely CGI character for much of its runtime. Sadly, the technology just wasn't there yet, meaning that 2003's Hulk looks pretty bad by today's standards.
Ang Lee's Hulk stars Eric Bana as the live-action Hulk a.k.a. Bruce Banner, with the film containing many of the elements frequently featured in the comics, including Thunderbolt Ross, gamma radiation, and more. Although the film was a moderate box office success, Hulk was met with mixed reviews, which have only gotten worse as time passed. One of the main criticisms of Hulk is its bad CGI, and while it still isn't great, it's clear that audiences and critics take major issues when CGI is not up to expectation, as seen with the MCU.
Newer MCU CGI Complaints Prove 2003's Hulk Was Always Going To Suffer
Back in 2003 when Hulk was released, Marvel was struggling, having just recovered from near bankruptcy in the 80s and 90s. Today, they are highly lucrative, with several releases in the last decade each earning well in excess of a billion dollars. Despite this, movies like Thor: Love and Thunder are criticized for CGI that isn't up to par, even though Marvel Studios has a near-infinite amount of resources. With Marvel's blockbusters still struggling to keep up with the times, it's completely understandable that a movie from two decades ago with a much smaller budget would fail to have groundbreaking CGI.
Even if Hulk did have a bigger budget, it still probably wouldn't have pulled off CGI that looks good enough to tell a Hulk story. Marvel movies feature fantastical characters, locations, and scenes, many of which are incredibly difficult to pull off in live action no matter the budget. Back in 2003, the top-of-the-line CGI still wasn't good enough to pull off an ultra-realistic Hulk, something that Hulk actor Josh Lucas has even admitted. While more money may have made the CGI slightly better, the subject and time period mean that it was doomed to suffer.
Phase 4's VFX Complaints Make The 2003 Hulk Movie More Impressive
Although the MCU proves that Hulk's CGI would have never worked, the criticisms of Phase 4 make the film slightly more impressive. Ang Lee was notoriously involved in Hulk's CGI, wanting to push the line further than any film had gone before. This can be juxtaposed with some of the MCU's modern producers and directors, who don't really care about having fantastic boundary-pushing CGI. If the modern MCU had directors that were as passionate about it as Ang Lee was in Hulk, Phase 4 could potentially win over the CGI critics.