Action rhythm games are a growing genre in gaming, and two of the most popular first-person shooters to try it out - Metal: Hellsinger and BPM: Bullets Per Minute - have been addictively fun. However, both games diverge greatly from each other. Metal: Hellsinger was released on September 15 with positive reviews, and many fans of the game will be hungry for more rhythm-based gameplay. In 2020 another musically-charged FPS called BPM: Bullets Per Minute was released. However, the developers of both projects set out to make a fast-paced FPS rhythm game and went about it in very different ways.
One of the first rhythm first-person-shooters to spark gamers' attention was 2020's BPM: Bullets Per Minute. The game was initially released on the PC and developed by Awe Interactive, which started as a two-person team. Developers set out to make a game inspired by early shooter games like Quake and the original DOOM, but with rhythm gameplay mechanics similar to those seen in the hit indie game, Crypt of the NecroDancer. BPM launched with generally positive reviews and has since been released on PlayStation, Xbox, and Nintendo consoles.
During the 2020 Summer of Gaming Festival, developer The Outsiders revealed Metal: Hellsinger with a trailer featuring heavy metal vocals and FPS gameplay of demons being slain to the beat. The Outsiders is also an independent game studio. However, it is made up of a team of experienced game makers formally from studios like DICE and Guerilla Games (of Battlefield and Killzone fame). After a couple years of development and canceling its previous-gen iterations, Metal: Hellsinger released on September 15, 2022, on the Windows PC, PlayStation 5, and Xbox Series X|S. Making Hellsinger one of the few current-generation-only games on the market. Although players must slay to the beat in Hellsinger and BPM, playing them after a few minutes will reveal how different each feels to play.
Metal: Hellsinger & BPM's Musically Charged Gameplay Reinvigorates A Genre
Like most rhythm games, Hellsinger and BPM require players to perform actions timed to the game's beat. In these rhythm shooters, brackets converge toward the center of the screen around the player's crosshairs. Pressing a button to perform actions (like shooting, reloading, dodging) with the timing of the brackets is the key to success. Both games see score multipliers begin to grow with successfully timed button presses. However, BPM requires players hit buttons to the rhythmic timing to successfully shoot, reload, or dodge. This feature can be disabled by switching off the game's "rhythm detection" in the settings. Despite this, poorly timing a button press to the brackets can limit player actions and accessibility for some. In contrast, Metal: Hellsinger's rhythm and DOOM-like gameplay does not restrict attacks or abilities because of a missed note but instead rewards proper timing with bonus damage and bigger weapon sound effects. Hellsinger also introduces new layers to each song as its multiplier grows, eventually unlocking the powerful vocals of a level's music.
The weapons in each game also greatly influence how players experience the games and flesh out their rhythms. Hellsinger begins by introducing players to two weapons that will accompany players throughout the game's eight levels. The two starting weapons, a sword and a magical skull named Paz are incredibly helpful in getting players back onto the beat of songs with their quick rates of fire. But, as players progress through Metal: Hellsinger's fun and metal music-filled campaign, they will unlock four more weapons (bringing the game's total number of weapons to six), each with different rates of fire, range, and reload times that must be taken into account when slaying the hordes of hell to the music's beat. Each level begins by allowing players to customize their own weapon loadout. While Paz and the sword are always equipped, only two extra firearms can be carried simultaneously. Because each of Hellsinger's weapons has a different rate of fire to try to match the game's beat, this choice offers players the freedom to play at the pace they are most comfortable with. However, like the incredibly well-received game Hades, BPM is a roguelike with randomly generated dungeons. Hence, its gameplay and weapons operate much differently.
When a player starts a run on BPM, they start with a pistol. As players navigate the game's dungeons, they encounter monsters of different sizes. Still, all of them cause significant damage to the player's limited health. Health is difficult to come by, and some of the game's small but quick-flying enemies have the potential to ruin a player's run. A death means having to start BPM over from the beginning. But because most of the game is randomly generated, mighty weapons can sometimes be rewarded to players early on in the game, making the game much easier to clear. The game has around twenty different weapons players can find, and while each has its own stats, its range and damage are affected by the player's stats. Like the difficult RNG gameplay of PS5's Returnal, Bullet's Per Minute players must count on the luck of their run's random generation to deliver an overpowered weapon or to be able to increase their character's stats.
Metal: Hellsinger & BPM's Stories Compared
BPM tasks players to take control of a Valkyrie, who must shoot through hordes of the underworld's minions and their bosses as they attempt to invade Asgard. Giant spider-like creatures, evil mages, large flying insects, and many other enemies try to halt the Valkyrie's progress. Because players are not granted a lot of health, many of the game's smaller enemies will do just that while the player focuses on the game's physically larger threats. If players can defeat a level's boss, the next stage begins, but unfortunately, unlike Elden Ring's world, many of BPM's dungeons look very similar. Each stage features an odd color palette covering every square inch of a level's dungeon-like environment. The roguelike has players encounter shops staffed by large but adorable animals who will offer new weapons at a price. Players can also unlock nine other playable Valkyrie by completing special objectives, all of which have unique abilities and sometimes a change of perspective. Awe Interactive decided not to focus on the story as much as they set out to create a rhythm FPS that was fun to play, even if players die a lot.
During Metal: Hellsinger's campaign, players take control of the mysterious entity "The Unknown" as she fights through eight layers of Hell to reclaim what its ruler took from them. Players literally fight the Devil in Hellsinger. However, unlike Bullets Per Minute, Hellsinger is not a roguelike video game. Players can complete a level and replay it to increase their standing on the game's online leaderboards. Battling through Hell can offer some variations in environments. Still, many of the game's settings and bosses start to feel recycled by the time players reach the campaign's final stage. That changes in the game's final boss battle which ends the campaign strongly and leaves it open for a sequel. However, Hellsinger does a great job of introducing new and intimidating enemies at a gradual pace to increase gameplay variation. Side missions present exciting challenges that unlock helpful gameplay perks that will prove beneficial in the game's challenging but fair hardest difficulty.
Metal: Hellsinger & BPM Put Music Front & Center
Like in the Final Fantasy series, some of gaming's best music often blends into the background to help build whatever mood the game developers are trying to elicit in the player. Many rhythm games over the years have integrated music into their gameplay, like the plastic instrument days of Guitar Hero and Dance Dance Revolution. However, when 2016's DOOM was released with Mick Gordon's score kicking up during the game's intense gameplay, things changed. The combination of heavy metal tones and power-fantasy-fueled gameplay inspired fans and game developers. Within a short time, the idea that blasting away enemies to the rhythm of exciting music was worth building a game around, and they were right.
While it was in development, Awe Interactive had initially planned to use different music from various musicians to create unparalleled sound and music for BPM. The studio chose to work with the talented composer's Sam Houghton and Joe Collinson because the musicians changed the developer's minds after providing a demo of their music for the game. Bullet's Per Minute's synth-rock tracks are fun to play the game too. However, those looking for something with vocals and a little harder, like metal, may be more interested in what Hellsinger has in its repertoire. The game's soundtrack is constructed by the composer-duo Two Feathers. It features the vocals from an impressive list of metal singers like Alissa White-Gluz of Arch Enemy and System of a Down's Serj Tankian. Both games require the player's skill to unlock every track, but Hellsinger mods will allow custom music tracks eventually. However, Metal: Hellsinger's developers deciding to have each song's vocals unleash after players do well is a great touch. It accentuates the players feeling of accomplishment with a musical goal to consistently work towards. A tactic that hopefully more rhythm games strive to emulate.
Metal: Hellsinger & BPM Show More Rhythm Action Games Are Needed
It all comes down to which game is more fun to play, which may differ depending on the player. Some fans of roguelike games may enjoy the challenge of BPM: Bullets Per Minute. In contrast, others may enjoy the heavy metal vocals and more varied playstyle in Metal: Hellsinger. Suppose fast-paced rhythm action games are one of your new favorite genres of games. In that case, it's entirely possible both games will be enjoyable. Hopefully, the ideas Awe Interactive and The Outsiders put into their games inspire the next exciting FPS rhythm game.