It is a strange and interesting time to be releasing a high-profile musical biopic. The genre has dominated prestige cinema for decades (think Bohemian Rhapsody, Walk The Line, Ray), to the point where audiences might have even grown weary of the formula (Springsteen biopic Deliver Me From Nowhere garnered a muted response). However, Michael could be like nothing we’ve seen before.
There has been a regular slate of Jackson-themed films and documentaries in recent years, and while many emphasized his incredible legacy, others chose instead to question it, demanding answers for the controversies that defined Jackson’s controversial final years. These contradictions get to the heart of why Michael is possibly the most fraught biopic to date.
In terms of the abuse allegations against Jackson that recently resurfaced, the world was forced to pay attention when Leaving Neverland aired on HBO in 2019, speaking with two accusers who alleged he abused them as children. The wider response to the allegations was mixed (not least Jackson’s estate, which successfully sued HBO $100 million for airing the documentary).
The long-awaited trailer for Michael debuted this week, a glossy affair hinting that the film might play it safe by sticking to the tried-and-tested biopic formula. A straightforward affair to rival the biopic-by-numbers path taken by Bohemian Rhapsody, and without anything close to the unconventional, therapy-through-fantasy conceit that brought Elton John redemption in Rocket Man.
However, first-look trailers can sometimes be deceiving. What we do know is that the journey of Michael to the screen has been fraught with obstacles. Delayed from its initial release date of early 2025 for more than a year, reports indicate that it was related to the film’s planned depiction of Jackson’s controversies that led to the delay. This biopic might not be so glossy after all.
"The Tracks Are Made; The Songs Are Ready. Let's Take It From The Top."
"I know you've been waiting a long time for this," legendary producer Quincy Jones says in the opening moments of the trailer. He’s speaking to his pop-star protege Michael Jackson, of course (notably portrayed by Jackson’s nephew Jaafar Jackson). However, Jones might have almost been addressing the audience directly, a sly nod to the film’s bumpy production.
Reports suggest the extended delay of Michael reaching theaters was related to its planned dramatized portrayal of Jordan Chandler, who Jackson was accused of abusing in 1993 (a settlement with the family was eventually reached, and Jackson was never criminally charged). The reports indicate this portrayal played a significant role in the film’s third act.
However, something overlooked during production was the legal ramifications of the portrayal, as it actually violates the terms of Jackson’s original settlement with the family over 30 years ago. Removing Chandler’s dramatization from the film represented a huge shakeup for production, leading to a rewrite of the film’s entire third act, as well as extensive reshoots.
These attempts to address the darker side of his life suggest the film might offer a more nuanced, less superficial take on the Jackson legacy. However, the production has also faced criticism that the dramatization was a disingenuous strategy to discredit allegations against Jackson. Dan Reed, director of Leaving Neverland, was particularly scathing of an early script.
“Jackson is only ever seen caring for children with childhood cancer, dancing with a little girl in a wheelchair, or tucking up multiple little boys, mostly his nephews, at sleepovers,” he told Variety.
The Studio Promises An Authentic Portrait
In response to claims that Michael will whitewash Jackson's history of allegations, studio Lionsgate has been resolute, promising in press releases that Michael will offer a “riveting and honest portrayal of the brilliant yet complicated man,” and that the film will cover Jackson’s “undeniable creative genius,” as well as his “human side and personal struggles.”
The film’s producer also promises an authentic portrayal of Jackson’s life, and he told Variety that he spent years researching the life of Michael Jackson in the lead-up to the film.
“Michael’s life was complicated. As a filmmaker, I look to humanize but not sanitize and present the most compelling, unbiased story I can capture in a single feature film and let the audience decide how they feel after watching it."
Director Antoine Fuqua has been along for the ride, and offered similar sentiments early in the film’s production. “He was a great artist. He was human. We’re gonna show the good, bad, and the ugly. We're just going to tell Michael based on the facts that I have.”
Striking An Impossible Balance
Currently, it is nearly impossible to predict what kind of biopic Michael will be. Will it gloss over the more difficult aspects of his life, or will it offer a balanced account? Furthermore, what would a balanced account even be? Consider that Jackson was never criminally charged with the crimes of which he was accused, though he remains guilty in the eyes of many.
Jackson always denied the allegations against him, including during the month-long criminal trial in 2005 for which he was acquitted. Supporters argue that Jackson had his day in court. His family and estate maintained Jackson’s innocence following his death in 2009, and to them and other supporters, the only honest portrayal is the one that asserts Jackson’s innocence.
However, the serious claims detailed in Leaving Neverland remain fresh in many people’s minds. Complicating this is the fact that the accusers, who appeared in the documentary, are currently embroiled in legal action against the Jackson estate for failing to protect them from the alleged abuse more than 30 years ago.
For the documentary’s director, Dan Reed, any film that fails to confront what he sees as the true nature of the allegations would be morally bankrupt and without credibility. “There’s too much of a stink — too much evidence, too many allegations — for anyone backing this narrative in the movie to have a clear conscience.”
What is beyond question is the spectacular nature of Jackson’s career. The “King of Pop” sold over 400 million records — including the best-selling album ever with Thriller — winning 13 Grammys, trailblazing the format of the music video, and breaking down racial barriers in popular music (the latter representing an astonishing achievement in particular).
Obviously, offering a “fair and accurate portrayal” of Michael Jackson's life means different things to different people, and it represents a more daunting task than any other biopic to date. We’ll have to wait and see how all these contradictions and competing narratives play out when the film arrives on April 23.