Summary

  • Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 gracefully blends Kamala Khan's comic and MCU powers, showing Kamala embracing her mutation at her own pace.
  • The issue addresses Ms. Marvel's identity and power controversy, confirming Kamala's MCU hard-light powers while honoring her comic shapeshifting abilities.
  • Marvel fans need not worry about Kamala's powers changing entirely to match her MCU character, as the comic handles the transition with care.

Warning: Spoilers for Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 ahead!

Ever since the debut of the MCU's Ms. Marvel series, fans have speculated about what Kamala Khan's dramatically different powers on screen would mean for her original comic book iteration. Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 answers these concerns with surprising grace, acknowledging the different versions of Kamala Khan without invalidating either iteration of the character.

Iman Vellani, Sabir Pirzada, Scott Godlewski, and Erick Arciniega's Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 is heavily centered around the themes of identity and what Ms. Marvel's mutant powers mean to her on a personal level. Before Kamala can figure them out herself, she is ambushed by ex-Orchis agent Nikita Gaiha, who assaults Kamala's mosque with Ms. Marvel's reanimated pre-rebirth corpse.

Nikita Gaiha reveals Ms. Marvel's mutant power: her hard-light abilities from the MCU.
Nikita Gaiha reveals Ms. Marvel's mutant power: her hard-light abilities from the MCU.

The undead Kamala's mutant power turns out to be her hard-light manipulation abilities from the MCU. Furthermore, she is even capable of using her mutation in tandem with her shapeshifting powers from the comics.

Ms. Marvel Addresses Her Superpower Controversy

While fans in 2022 were initially excited to hear that Ms. Marvel would be joining the MCU with her own series on Disney+, there was consternation over the fact that her superpowers would be changed from her comic-book iteration to be more film-friendly. Instead of having stretching and shapeshifting abilities from Inhuman genes, the MCU version of Kamala Khan instead summons hard-light constructs from the "Noor dimension." These constructs replace what comic-Kamala would normally do with her own body, such as elongating her limbs or enlarging her fists.

This change was not helped by Kamala's sudden death and equally abrupt resurrection as a mutant in the comics. Many readers suspected that this was an excuse to change Kamala's powers in the comics to more closely align with her MCU self ahead of her appearance in The Marvels (2023) - a suspicion which has since been confirmed. However, despite her resurrection as a mutant in X-Men: Hellfire Gala (2023), the comics have refrained from revealing Kamala's mutation until now, let alone having her display any other powers aside from her regular stretching.

Ms. Marvel Can Have Her Superpower Cake And Eat It, Too

Ms Marvel fights her hard-light wielding doppelganger.
Ms Marvel fights her hard-light wielding doppelganger.

Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 elegantly walks the line between the comics and the show. While it confirms Ms. Marvel's mutant powers are her hard-light powers from the MCU, the book makes a point of Kamala rejecting outside labels or expectations; she will embrace her mutation when she is ready and no sooner. Similarly, the fight with her undead self emphasizes that her powers are not mutually exclusive, meaning that Kamala is not forsaking her original powers for her MCU powers. This is a tactful handling of the subject that acknowledges both iterations of the character without invalidating either version.

The difference between Ms. Marvel in the comics and the MCU has long been a source of suspicion and consternation among fans, but Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 lays much of it to rest. By acknowledging Kamala's powers from the MCU as later potential, not dogma, it allows the character to continue to grow (literally and metaphorically) as she has in the comics while also remaining accessible to her MCU self. The road to this point has been rocky, but the payoff is worth it: Ms. Marvel handles the comic debut of her MCU powers as elegantly as possible.

Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 is available now from Marvel Comics.

Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 (2024)

Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 cover featuring Ms. Marvel's powers going haywire.
Ms. Marvel: Mutant Menace #4 cover featuring Ms. Marvel's powers going haywire.
  • Writers: Iman Vellani, Sabir Pirzada
  • Artist: Scott Godlewski
  • Colorist: Erick Arciniega
  • Letterer: Joe Caramagna
  • Cover Artist: Carlos Gómez, Jesus Aburtov
3hwwh92kzbd7odwjx7nkmxnzsyo.jpg
16
7.1/10
7/10

Ms. Marvel

Release Date
2022 - 2022-00-00
Network
Disney+
Showrunner
Bisha K. Ali
Directors
Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, Bilall Fallah, Meera Menon, Adil El Arbi
Writers
Bisha K. Ali, Adrian Alphona, Aisha Bhoori, Fatimah Asghar, Kate Gritmon

Ms. Marvel is an action-superhero TV series set in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. The show follows Iman Vellani, a 16-year-old high school student in New Jersey who is a huge fan of superheroes and has difficulty fitting in at school. When Iman is gifted a mysterious bangle from her grandfather, she discovers it allows her to utilize cosmic energy and construct what she can imagine. Now an accidental superhero, Iman will try to rise to the challenge and make a name for herself as Ms. Marvel.