Although it is still hard to forgive Netflix for one of its most controversial cancellations from three years ago, a horror masterpiece fills the void the canceled show left behind.

It is well known that Netflix has had a long line of TV cancellations. While some of these canceled shows have already been long forgotten, others remain painful reminders of what they could have become if they were given a second chance. Falling in the latter category, a multilingual mystery-box sci-fi series landed on Netflix almost three years ago.

In its first installment, the series even showed immense potential and perfectly paved the way for another season with a gripping cliffhanger. Unfortunately, Netflix pulled the plug on it after just one season.

It’s Still Hard To Forgive Netflix For Canceling 1899 After 1 Season

Emily Beecham's Mauram falling in 1899
Emily Beecham's Mauram falling in 1899

Created by the showrunners of Dark, Baran bo Odar and Jantje Friese, 1899 was one of the most highly anticipated shows of 2022. Like Dark, the series showed immense potential in its opening installment and hinted that it was leading up to something bigger and more scalable. Similar to Dark, 1899 riffed on many genre conventions but twisted them with gripping layers of horror and mystery box drama.

Unfortunately, before 1899 could reveal the true potential of its storytelling and become as widely appreciated as Dark, Netflix canceled it.

1899 was one of the most expensive shows produced in Germany. Although there was a lot of hype surrounding its release because of Dark's success, its viewer completion rate was less than Netflix had anticipated. Reports suggested that many viewers did not complete the show, which would have reduced the interest in season 2.

While it is understandable where this approach came from, it is hard not to see how Netflix settled for an immediate metric to measure 1899's performance. Unlike Squid Game, 1899 took time to garner a cult following and build a solid audience.

Similar to Dark, 1899 also would have garnered more viewers with each progressing season if only Netflix had given it a chance. As Dark establishes, Baran bo Odar and Jantje Friese also have their way of building up a large web of interconnected stories that reward patient viewers. 1899 would have given long-term viewers the same kind of payoffs that Dark once did if Netflix had not canceled it after just one installment.

From Fills The Void 1899’s Cancellation Left Behind

Harold Perrineau as Boyd Stevens with a bell in From
Harold Perrineau as Boyd Stevens with a bell in From

From is yet to reveal the truth about its central setting, but it seems obvious that, unlike 1899, it is not about simulations. However, like 1899, From, too, unfolds in a confined and mysterious setting where the main characters are trapped. A claustrophobic dread looms over the characters in both shows as they experience the collective trauma and grief of being shut off from the rest of humanity.

Similar to the "glitches" and "programmed rules" in 1899, From also establishes a lethal set of laws that define the reality its characters are trapped in. Like other renowned mystery-box shows like Lost, 1899 and From also do not shy away from leaving viewers with more questions than answers.

While 1899 was cut short before it could pay off its mysteries, From will fortunately get to end its run on a conclusive note. Only time will tell whether From will resolve all loose ends before it ends its run. However, so far, the show has had an incredible run and will likely sustain its strong momentum till the end.

Owing to this, it is hard not to see From as the perfect show for viewers who wondered what 1899 could have become if Netflix had never canceled it.

from-poster.jpg
From
830
9.5/10
Release Date
February 20, 2022

From is a series revolving around a mysterious American town that ensnares newcomers. Its new and old inhabitants attempt to maintain order while looking for an escape, all the while contending with haunted nighttime threats and perils from the surrounding forest.

Network
MGM+
Cast
Harold Perrineau, Catalina Sandino Moreno, Eion Bailey, David Alpay, Elizabeth Saunders, Scott McCord, Shaun Majumder, Ricky He, Chloe Van Landschoot, Pegah Ghafoori, Corteon Moore, Avery Konrad, Hannah Cheramy, Simon Webster, Elizabeth Moy, Deborah Grover, Angela Moore, Vox Smith, Paul Zinno, Kaelen Ohm, Robert Joy, A.J. Simmons, Samantha Brown, Benjamin Clost, Sam Haynes
Directors
Jack Bender, Brad Turner, Alexandra La Roche, Bruce McDonald, Jeff Renfroe
Writers
Vivian Lee, Kristen Layden, Brigitte Hales, Jeff Pinkner, John Griffin
Main Genre
Horror
Creator(s)
John Griffin
Executive Producer(s)
Anthony Russo, Joe Russo, André Nemec, Jeff Pinkner, Jack Bender, Mike LaRocca, John Griffin, Lindsay Dunn, Scott Rosenberg
Producers
Michael Mahoney
Seasons
4
Streaming Service(s)
MGM+