Netflix had the perfect replacement for Stranger Things on its hands, yet failed to capitalize on this. Stranger Things is undoubtedly one of the biggest TV phenomena of the modern era. Largely considered one of the best Netflix shows of all time, Stranger Things has embedded itself in modern pop culture since its 2016 debut.
The hype for Stranger Things season 5’s story is testament to this, with audiences eagerly anticipating the finale of the show. In the decade since Netflix’s popularity exploded, one could be forgiven for thinking nothing has truly come close to matching the iconicity and long-lasting impact of Stranger Things.
However, one specific show released by the streaming giant would prove otherwise. As the wait for upcoming Netflix shows goes on and Stranger Things builds towards its final outing, it becomes clearer than ever that the streaming service’s true replacement for the hit show has been shortchanged.
Wednesday Season 1 Was An Even Bigger Hit Than Stranger Things
The show that could have served as Netflix’s replacement for Stranger Things was Wednesday. To this day, Wednesday season 1’s Netflix debut ranks as the second-strongest in the streamer’s history. This means that more people watched Wednesday’s premiere outing than any season of Stranger Things, despite the latter being more prevalent in the overall zeitgeist of modern TV.
|
Show |
Views (Millions) |
|---|---|
|
Squid Game Season 1 |
265.2 |
|
Wednesday Season 1 |
252.1 |
|
Squid Game Season 2 |
192.6 |
|
Squid Game Season 3 |
145.8 |
|
Adolesence |
142.6 |
|
Stranger Things Season 4 |
140.7 |
|
Monster - The Jeffrey Dahmer Story |
115.6 |
|
Bridgerton |
113.3 |
|
The Queen's Gambit |
112.8 |
|
Wednesday Season 2 |
112.2 |
This just proves how successful Wednesday really was. Of course, this popularity was evident in some ways. Jenna Ortega became an instant up-and-coming Hollywood star, with online crazes like the “Wednesday Dance” taking over social media. Stranger Things’ debut at the height of the streaming craze may have resulted in longevity, but Wednesday was the more popular show for Netflix.
Wednesday Was In A Perfect Spot To Become Netflix’s Next Stranger Things
If Wednesday’s immense popularity provided Netflix with the potential for anything, it was Stranger Things’ replacement. While Stranger Things would still have continued, Wednesday season 1 aired around the same time as Stranger Things season 4, after which the ending of the latter was already mapped out.
In the modern business of constantly trying to find the next big franchise, prioritizing Wednesday as much as Stranger Things after its immense debut could have meant that Netflix had two behemoths on its hands at the same time. After all, there are similarities between Wednesday and Stranger Things that prove the former could have become akin to the latter with more attention.
The premise of both involves a young female character exploring mysterious powers in a world full of monsters, enemies, allies, and deeper-rooted mysteries. These similarities are admittedly broad when directly comparing the two, but they are familiar enough to elicit that same warm, somewhat spooky, family-friendly allure.
This is without mentioning the 1980s nostalgia of both; Stranger Things emulates classic Amblin-style adventure, while Wednesday is a reimagining of a popular brand that audiences have been familiar with for over 50 years. Throw in a great cast, solid characters, and the immense popularity of both, and it becomes clear that Wednesday was in a prime spot to become the next Stranger Things.
Why Wednesday Season 2 Was Not As Successful As Season 1
Despite all of this, Netflix dramatically failed to make Wednesday as big as Stranger Things and capitalize on the former’s popular debut. What makes this clear above all else is the response to Wednesday season 2. This is not to say that Wednesday season 2 failed, far from it. However, it was clearly not as alarmingly popular as its predecessor.
Wednesday season 2 was still successful, amassing an initial viewership of 112.2 million. This means it goes down as one of Netflix’s best performers for original programming, just like its debut outing. Nonetheless, the drop-off between both was marked, over 130 million, even placing Wednesday season 2 beneath the most recent season of Stranger Things.
Stranger Things is a show that has gradually increased in popularity to become the pop culture staple it currently is, with Wednesday seemingly going the opposite direction. Instead, Wednesday debuted in immensely popular fashion, yet season 2 saw its impact diminish, for a few notable reasons.
Perhaps the main reason is the three-year wait between Wednesday seasons 1 and 2. Netflix jumped at the chance to continue Stranger Things’ initial popularity, with two more seasons being released in the next three years. The same cannot be said for Wednesday, with audiences having to wait three years for four more episodes, then two months after those for another four.
This is because of Netflix’s decision to split Wednesday season 2 into two halves, the first releasing in July 2025 and the second in September of that same year. This release strategy has become disliked by audiences in recent years. further contributing to the comparatively lacking impact of Wednesday season 2.
Had Netflix taken the same initiative it showed with Stranger Things and struck while the iron was hot, two more Wednesday seasons would have been released in quick succession after its 2022 debut. This way, the fact that Wednesday season 1 was the most popular Netflix release ever would have allowed subsequent seasons to grow as Stranger Things’ sequels did.
Wednesday Season 2’s Struggles Reveal A Bigger Netflix Problem
As repeatedly pointed out, though, Netflix did not push Wednesday as much or as quickly as it should have, emulating a wider problem with the streaming service. In the 2020s, especially, Netflix has gone above and beyond to market debut seasons.
From Wednesday and Squid Game to Sweet Home and One Piece, Netflix has made a din of noise in marketing, pushing these shows so that their opening seasons become massive hits. Frustratingly, the same energy is never kept for continuations of such shows.
Squid Game rivaled Wednesday as the biggest Netflix debut ever, only for season 2 to take over three years to produce, drastically reducing the show’s overall impact. While the viewership remained strong, the overall impact it made on audiences was much smaller. One Piece season 2’s release in 2026 marks three years before it returns to viewers’ screens.
How this will impact the show remains to be seen, yet Sweet Home's reduced viewership further supports the point; Netflix has a big issue with taking far too long to continue its biggest hits, which, unfortunately, impacted Wednesday to the point where it failed to become the streamer’s next Stranger Things, despite having all the initial momentum to do exactly that.
- Release Date
- November 23, 2022
- Network
- Netflix
- Showrunner
- Miles Millar, Alfred Gough
- Directors
- Tim Burton, James Marshall
- Writers
- April Blair










Cast
-
Wednesday Addams / Goody Addams -
Enid Sinclair
Wednesday follows the journey of Wednesday Addams as she attends Nevermore Academy, a boarding school for outcasts. Tasked with mastering her psychic abilities, she confronts a series of town murders and a haunting family mystery from 25 years ago, all while managing new social dynamics.