Summary

  • Spinoffs of successful sitcoms can be risky and often fail due to changes in cast or the show's dynamic.
  • Rebooting a show without the original cast can risk changing the show too much and damage its appeal.
  • Spinoffs that don't understand what made the original character popular or try too hard to recreate the original show's humor can often fall flat.

Rumors have began to heat up once more about a potential spinoff or reboot of The Office, but showrunner Greg Daniels should learn some lessons from failed sitcom spinoffs of the past. Plenty of popular sitcoms have attempted spinoffs in the past, but for every Frasier or Young Sheldon which lasts for many seasons, there are dozens of failed attempts to launch a spinoff. Sitcoms are a delicate art, and disrupting the chemistry of the cast or the writer's room can ruin a popular show. This is why so many spinoffs fail, and the popularity of The Office doesn't make a spinoff a sure-fire hit.

Rebooting The Office without the entire cast would risk changing the show too much. Even the last few seasons of the show felt different when Steve Carell left. The large ensemble cast managed to keep things running relatively smoothly, but any more changes could damage the show's appeal. One of the ideas floated for a spinoff of The Office would see the documentary crew following a completely new subject. Such a creative approach could avoid too many direct comparisons to The Office, but this might also neglect what made the show so popular to begin with.

10 Joey

Spinoff from Friends

Matt LeBlanc as Joey in the Friends spinoff standing with a castmate
Matt LeBlanc as Joey in the Friends spinoff standing with a castmate

Friends relied on the dynamic between its six main stars, so a spinoff featuring just one of them was always going to be a different proposition. Joey failed as a spinoff because it didn't understand what made its protagonist so popular in the first place. Taking him away from his friends, and having him never even mention them, gave him a different role. Joey became more self-centered and less likable in the spinoff. It takes more than one popular character to make a spinoff worthwhile, especially if the character changes so much.

9 The Cleveland Show

Spinoff from Family Guy

The Cleveland Show tries to recapture Family Guy's humor, but with fewer cutaway gags and more timely pop culture references. In restrospect, Cleveland probably wasn't a great choice for a spinoff, since part of his character in Family Guy is that he's a slow-talking bore. In The Cleveland Show, he becomes the center of attention, and his friends are made to be extra eccentric to keep up with the quirky nature of Family Guy. Unfortunately, these friends are little more than stereotypes, and even Tim the bear becomes tiresome and predictable before too long.

8 The Green Green Grass

Spinoff from Only Fools and Horses

The Green Green Grass shouldn't be considered a total failure. It ran for four seasons, which is better than many other spinoffs. However, it couldn't compare to Only Fools and Horses in terms of popularity or impact. The original show works so well because of the comedic dynamic between Del Boy and Rodney, but neither of these characters made it to The Green Green Grass. The spinoff also moves the setting from Peckham in South London to the countryside. This gives The Green Green Grass a completely different feeling, and a new cast of supporting characters.

7 The Golden Palace

Spinoff from The Golden Girls

Fern and Rose in the lobby of The Golden Palace

The Golden Palace shows how delicately balanced a sitcom formula is, and even a minor change can ruin a popular show.

Bea Arthur left The Golden Girls at the end of the show, so The Golden Palace featured the rest of the cast continuing on without her. The Golden Palace only lasted for a single season after breaking up the cast. The remaining trio bought a failing hotel and had to run it together, but without Dorothy, the dynamic wasn't quite the same. The plot also felt rather contrived and inorganic compared with the original series. The Golden Palace shows how delicately balanced a sitcom formula is, and even a minor change can ruin a popular show.

6 That '80s Show

Spinoff from That '70s Show

That 80s Show cast
That 80s Show cast

That '70s Show worked with the backdrop of 1970s nostalgia, but it still relied on great writing and a cast of likable characters. That '80s Show leaned too far into 1980s pop culture references, and it didn't develop its characters well enough. The concept of a retro friendship sitcom wasn't all that made That '70s Show so enjoyable to watch. The more recent spinoff, That '90s Show, is closer to the original, so it could achieve more success than its predecessor. It has been renewed for a second season, so it's already one step further along than That '80s Show.

5 Buddies

Spinoff from Home Improvement

Dave Chappelle's guest appearance in Home Improvement
Dave Chappelle's guest appearance in Home Improvement

Dave Chappelle and Jim Breuer made just one appearance on Home Improvement, but it was enough for them to get their own spinoff. Unfortunately, Breuer was replaced before the show started filming. The entire point of the spinoff was to give Chappelle and Breuer's unique comedy dynamic a platform, so without this key ingredient, Buddies fell flat immediately. The show was canceled before the first season was even over. If the spinoff of The Office is going to take some characters from the original, it needs to consider how changes to the cast could spoil the chemistry.

4 Joanie Loves Chachi

Spinoff from Happy Days

The couple singing a duet in Joanie Loves Chachi
The couple singing a duet in Joanie Loves Chachi

Joanie Loves Chachi was devised a musical spinoff from Happy Days, but its stars didn't have enough musical talent to carry such a weak show. Joanie Loves Chachi took Scott Baio's wildly popular character from Happy Days, and it tried to create a completely different show that didn't play to his strengths. There wasn't much to link Joanie Loves Chachi to Happy Days, and it was canceled during its second season. Happy Days did generate some great spinoffs though, most notably Laverne and Shirley, which ran for eight seasons on ABC.

3 How I Met Your Father

Spinoff from How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Father is less of a spinoff, and more of a modern remake of How I Met Your Mother. The show only overlaps slightly with the original, with a few cameos from actors who appeared on How I Met Your Mother. Mostly, it's a new show based on the same concept of young people dating in New York. How I Met Your Father was different in some important ways that an Office spinoff should take into account. It featured a more diverse cast and a stronger female perspective than How I Met Your Mother.

2 The Tortellis

Spinoff from Cheers

Tony talks to Loretta in The Tortellis
Tony talks to Loretta in The Tortellis

Frasier remains the gold-standard of sitcom spinoffs, becoming arguably more popular than the show that spawned it, but it wasn't the first spinoff from Cheers. The Tortellis was the first Cheers spinoff, following Nick Tortelli and Loretta as they moved to Las Vegas. Nick and Loretta slotted in nicely with the rest of the Cheers characters, but they didn't have enough appeal to sustain an entire show by themselves. The Tortellis suffered without the charm of some other Cheers regulars, and there's a good reason it didn't last as long as Frasier.

1 The Ropers

Spinoff from Three's Company

Stanley and Helen in The Ropers
Stanley and Helen in The Ropers

The bickering couple were forced to develop a lot more understanding, and this weighed down their hilarious repartee too much.

Three's Company was based on the British sitcom Man About the House, and it also copied the show's approach to spinoffs. Mad About the House had George and Mildred, so Three's Company created a spinoff featuring their American counterparts, The Ropers. The spinoff followed the landlords from Three's Company in the next chapter of their lives. The bickering couple were forced to develop a lot more understanding, and this weighed down their hilarious repartee too much. This wasn't the only failed spinoff from Three's Company. Three's a Crowd only lasted for one season.