Pixar might be one of the most beloved animation studios in history, but the Disney subsidiary is no stranger to box office bombs. Launching in the '70s, Pixar specialized in computer-generated imagery throughout the '80s. From the outset, CGI animation was what Pixar did best, and it eventually culminated in the first CGI animated feature film, Toy Story.

Partnering with Disney, Pixar began producing feature-length animated films full-time, and Toy Story was only the first of many gems. Known for their rich and humanistic storytelling, Pixar's philosophy fit right in with Disney's, so it was no surprise when the House of Mouse purchased the company in 2006. This only emboldened Pixar to make more movies, and hits abounded.

Though Pixar rode high for years, their reign of box office dominance did come to an end. The studio produced their first box office bomb two decades after Toy Story, and they have been inconsistent ever since. While many of their biggest financial failures have come because of the COVID-19 pandemic, others were impacted by their modern release strategy.

Dropping movies on Disney+ mere weeks after their theatrical run has certainly caused many moviegoers to simply wait, and the box office has paid the price. As has always been the case, box office numbers don't tell the whole story. Some of Pixar's best recent releases have been total bombs, while others certainly deserved their poor financial performance.

Lightyear (2022)

Buzz looks up triumphantly in Lightyear
Buzz looks up triumphantly in Lightyear

2022's Lightyear might be the worst of Pixar's financial disappointments from a filmmaking perspective, but it's hardly a terrible film. The movie is set within the fictional universe of the Buzz Lightyear toy franchise, and follows the titular character on a dangerous space mission. With Pixar's signature visual splendor, the movie is a feast for the eyes.

However, there is also a simplistic blandness that keeps it from ranking highly among Pixar's more original output. It's a bog-standard sci-fi adventure story, and the moral of the story is flimsy and uninspired. Lightyear's LGBTQ+ representation caused a stir in certain dark corners of the internet, but the movie was genuinely inoffensive on the whole.

Lightyear's biggest failure came at the box office, and the movie was an unmitigated disaster. Grossing $220 million against a $200 million budget (Box Office Mojo), the film lost upwards of $100 million. Lightyear is the worst of Pixar's financial failures as a movie, and its most shocking bomb because of its attachment to a larger franchise.

The Good Dinosaur (2015)

Arlo and the dinosaur look up in wonder in The Good Dinosaur
Arlo and the dinosaur look up in wonder in The Good Dinosaur

After years of success, The Good Dinosaur was the first Pixar film to ever bomb at the box office. The 2015 film reimagines prehistory and tells the story of a young and timid dinosaur who befriends a caveboy. The movie cleverly flips the script by making the dinosaurs the main characters, while portraying early man as animalistic and wild.

Naturally, The Good Dinosaur looks like a million bucks, and it continues Pixar's evolving visual style with unique character designs. Unfortunately, it's also not particularly engaging, and lacks a story hook that gives it that classic Pixar tone. Audiences responded accordingly and the movie bombed. However, it bombed despite making a lot of money.

The Good Dinosaur grossed $100 million more than its budget (Box Office Mojo), but that still wasn't enough to cover costs. Though its financial failure is staggering, it deserves credit for trying to be original. Even when bombing spectacularly, The Good Dinosaur is better than many of Pixar's franchise cash-ins.

Elio (2025)

Elio with the liquid supercomputer looking stunned
Elio with the liquid supercomputer looking stunned

Without any recognizable franchise to draw from, Pixar's Elio was left to twist in the wind. The film concerns a space-obsessed little boy who is abducted by accident when he is mistaken for the leader of Earth. The film underwent massive changes in the years leading up to its release, and Elio never really stood a chance.

Pixar's abandoning of the project is quite sad, and the sci-fi family comedy is yet another imaginative romp that bombed at the box office. While it may not be the best-looking Pixar movie of all time, it has a genuine story with appeal for both kids and adults alike.

Elio had the worst opening in Pixar history, and went on to make around $150 million against a budget near $200 million (Box Office Mojo). Like The Good Dinosaur, Elio is not one of Pixar's best efforts, but it's better than some of the studio's hits. It isn't the only original film to bomb in the post-COVID landscape.

Turning Red (2022)

A girl walks down the street with a big smile in Turning Red
A girl walks down the street with a big smile in Turning Red

Even in their more imaginative recent releases, Pixar has certainly been guilty of playing things too safely. Turning Red goes in the opposite direction, and remains one of the studio's most creative endeavors to date. A precocious tween suddenly finds her life upended when she begins turning into a giant red panda whenever she gets nervous or excited.

Turning Red deftly approaches the touchy subject of puberty with aplomb, and is clearly aimed at the pre-teen demographic. However, this doesn't limit the movie's appeal, and there's something relatable for viewers of any age. Though it was released in 2022, Turning Red was still a COVID-19 victim, and wasn't released theatrically in the United States.

This led to the film earning only $21 million (Box Office Mojo), though it found its audience on Disney+. Turning Red is an imperfect movie, but it represents Pixar's commitment or originality, and it's safe to say there are no other films like it in the studio's catalog. It's unclear how it would have fared with a full theatrical release.

Luca (2021)

Luca in fish form look shocked as he transforms into a boy in Luca
Luca in fish form look shocked as he transforms into a boy in Luca

2020 and 2021 were bad years for the movie industry in general, but Disney and Pixar had some notable flops during the COVID-19 pandemic. Luca is one such bomb, and it tells the story of a young sea monster who experiences life on land in a small Italian village. Cute and visually appealing, Luca drew inspiration from various sources.

Without trying too hard, the movie expands upon the themes of its story. Luca is essentially a tale about fitting in, and it presents a relatable tale without getting bogged down in details. It scored high marks from critics, but its limited release meant that the Pixar hidden gem was never going to be a success.

The pandemic forced it onto Disney+ where it racked up billions of hours of views. Despite this, Luca has been overlooked compared to other films from that era. While it's a middling effort for Pixar, it's still one of the best animated films released in the early 2020s. Its simplicity is its greatest strength, something Pixar has struggled to recapture.

Onward (2020)

Two elf brothers look surprised at magical pants in Onward
Two elf brothers look surprised at magical pants in Onward

Before the COVID-19 pandemic came along and ruined everything, 2020 was set to be a banner year for Pixar. Onward premiered in early 2020 and follows two elf brothers who embark on a quest to recover a magical item that will allow them to see their father one last time. The movie blends traditional high fantasy with modern visual motifs.

Perhaps Pixar's most underrated movie, Onward earned $140 million (Box Office Mojo) from a depressed box office before being shuffled off to Disney+. There, it found new life as a sleeper hit, and audiences were better able to appreciate the movie's subtle character choices and richer themes. No modern Pixar film has been able to world-build like Onward.

It's unfair to judge a movie like Onward on its box office success, and the fact that it made over $100 million is a testament to its quality. Under ideal conditions, there's no telling how successful the film would have been. While still remaining true to originality, Onward closely replicated the feeling of Pixar's early days.

Soul (2020)

A man smiles while looking out a window in Soul
A man smiles while looking out a window in Soul

Soul is genuinely one of Pixar's best films, though the conditions of its release relegated it to obscurity forever. A middle school band teacher who dreams of being a jazz musician winds up in the afterlife, and has a heartfelt journey to find his true calling. Pixar's storytelling richness hit its peak with the lyrical gem.

Soul was the first Pixar film to feature a Black lead.

Without pandering to youngsters, Soul pulls out all the stops and delivers an ambitious plot that points back to its themes of acceptance and purpose. It leaves the viewer to decide which morals are most important to them, instead of forcing its agenda. It's such a specific story, but it still manages to be broad in its appeal as well.

Soul's actual theatrical release date didn't come until 2024, when it earned a respectable $120 million (Box Office Mojo). However, that still made it a massive bomb, falling short of its budget. Nevertheless, it will always remain an important part of the studio's filmography, and it will likely be a long time before Pixar makes another film quite like Soul.