Warning: This article includes MAJOR SPOILERS for Ponies season 1!

Peacock’s Ponies is a compelling espionage thriller with a propulsive ending that raises as many questions as it answers. Led by Emilia Clarke and Haley Lu Richardson, Ponies features an incredible cast that shapes the 1970s Cold War story. The plot follows two “people of no interest,” or PONIs, named Bea (Clarke) and Twila (Richardson), who are wives to CIA agents.

Right before Christmas, they learn that their husbands, Chris and Tom, were killed in a small plane crash. They’re going to be sent home without answers. However, they decide to team up and convince Dane, the CIA's head at the Soviet embassy branch, to take them on as spies. He agrees because he thinks the Soviets will never believe women were spies.

They start working with a Soviet asset named Sasha, who is providing them with technology and photos. Bea starts a fake relationship with a high-ranking KGB member named Andrei Visiliev, using the relationship to obtain information for the CIA. Meanwhile, Twila works with a Soviet “fixer” named Vera, who has connections. However, as expected, everything goes horribly wrong in this highly-rated spy story, leading to an entertaining ending.

What Really Happened To Bea & Twila’s Husbands In Ponies?

Bea and Twila sit on the couch talking in Ponies season 1
Peacock's Ponies season 1

The central mystery driving Bea and Twila is what really happened to their husbands. The only information that the CIA will give them is that Chris and Tom died in a plane crash. However, there’s no evidence of this flight or the crash. The reason for this is that there wasn’t a crash at all. This part seems to be true despite later revelations.

Vera informs Twila that she was on the plane with them, and they landed it at the Soviet Kompromat facility. She stayed on the plane while Tom and Chris exited, and they got shot by KGB soldiers. This is where it gets a little bit murky. It’s unclear whether Vera is actually a reliable source because of two things:

  1. Bea’s husband, Chris, was the mole, not Tom.
  2. Chris clearly didn’t die from a gunshot as she said because he’s alive at the end of the season.

It’s possible she was intentionally misleading Twila, and it’s possible she was just mistaken. Either way, her account of what happened has to be questioned. As soon as they get off the plane, the truth of what happened is still a mystery. We know Chris is alive and in Belarussia, and Dane seems aware of it.

It’s not clear whether Tom is alive or dead, whether he was shot, or whether he’s being held captive. Both options seem equally likely, given the history of the KGB. The only way to find out is if they renew Ponies for season 2.

The Identities Of All The Moles, Explained

Ray holds up a bug in Ponies season 1
Ray holds up a bug in Ponies season 1

Throughout Ponies, it’s never entirely clear who’s on which side. The writers did a good job of providing multiple red herrings who could have been a mole. The CIA questions Sasha’s loyalty as a double agent. I doubted Dane at one point, but his response to the blackmail rules him out as a mole. Shef seemed a bit sketchy for a while. Vera was a wild card, too.

By the end of Ponies season 1, the show reveals there have been at least two moles within the US embassy: Cheryl and Chris. One is relatively predictable, but the other is genuinely shocking.

From the start, Cheryl feels unnecessarily mean-spirited, which makes her suspicious. She reacts so strongly to Eevi’s presence that it raises red flags. She asks prying questions and forces herself into situations. Plus, her power within the embassy cannot be underestimated. She is the eyes and ears of the office, especially since the men seem to view the women as invisible most of the time.

The more shocking reveal is Chris, who is a seemingly nice and loving husband. Based on the flashbacks and the way characters speak about him, he never showed any red flags, though that in and of itself could be a red flag. The only person who seemed to dislike him was Manya. If Vera is correct, though, he has been feeding the Soviets information the entire time.

The big questions now relate to the backstory of both situations. When did Cheryl and Chris start working with the KGB? Why are they betraying their spouses and the CIA? Are they being blackmailed or doing it of their own accord? What kind of information have they been passing along? There are just so many things Ponies season 2 needs to clarify.

How Andrei Vasiliev Discovers Bea’s True Identity

Emiliai Clarke at a desk in Ponies
Emiliai Clarke at a desk in Ponies

Bea and Andrei Vasiliev’s fake relationship feels like a ticking time bomb, given his propensity for strangling and stabbing women. As I mentioned in my review of Ponies for Screen Rant, I found myself holding my breath whenever Andrei was onscreen. However, Bea does a good job of keeping her cover, with the help of Sasha.

Unfortunately, Andrei discovers who Bea is when she slips up and lets her guard down. Dane warns Bea and Twila when they’re first brought on as spies that people die when they let their guard down. They don’t stop to think about it when they are told that the embassy secretaries will meet the KGB members.

Twila could have met them without any issue, but everyone believes Bea to be a Belarussian school teacher named Nadya. They both go through the line, shaking hands with KGB members without paying attention to who is in front of them. Had they kept their guard up, they might have escaped before Andrei saw Bea.

That being said, it feels pretty appropriate that this would be the flaw that catches them. Neither of them is a properly trained spy. They haven’t had it ingrained in them over time that they need to be hypervigilant constantly. Of course, they would eventually let their guard down.

How Andrei Vasiliev Is Rising Through The KGB Ranks So Fast

Andrei looks to the side in Ponies season 1
Andrei looks to the side in Ponies season 1

Andrei is seen as a major threat because of how quickly he has risen through the ranks of the KGB. He isn’t promoted on a normal timeline. By the end, it becomes clear that he’s moving so fast because he’s blackmailing everybody. He puts bugs and cameras on both the US citizens and his Soviet colleagues.

If anyone knew where he was hiding the tapes, they could destroy them and prevent him from moving up the ladder. However, Twila is the one in Ponies who figures out that he hides the tapes under the seal of the shampoo bottles. They are destroyed, though, when the bomb goes off in the CIA’s vault, as Twila placed the boxes of shampoo bottles there.

What Actually Happened To Sasha’s Sister

Bea and Sasha sit on a bench together in Ponies season 1
Peacock's Ponies season 1

The reason why Sasha is working with the CIA in Ponies is that he believes the KGB killed his sister. The Soviets were known for working with and then killing sex workers, which Twila learns about in episode 3. While Sasha didn’t think his sister was a sex worker, she was killed in the same way as the others.

However, there’s one statement during that episode that hints that Sasha’s sister, Galyna, wasn’t killed by the KGB. The woman in the brothel stated that she knew the women in the photos “except for that one,” pointing to a photo which we later learn is Galyna. The reasoning for this is finally revealed in the season 1 finale.

According to Andrei Vaseliev, the CIA killed Galyna in order to manipulate Sasha into working for them. I take everything Andrei says with a grain of salt because he’s good at manipulating others. However, it does actually seem plausible, since she didn’t match the profile of the other victims, and the Soviets aren’t the only manipulative ones in the Peacock original show.

How Ponies Season 1’s Ending Sets Up Season 2

Twila and Bea look shocked in Ponies season 1
Peacock's Ponies season 1

Peacock’s Ponies season 1 is a wild ride, and it ends on a pretty big cliffhanger that sets up the second season. The bomb Cheryl gave to the CIA started a fire that destroyed the vault and building, including some valuable technology and information.

Andrei Vasiliev escapes captivity and brings KGB agents in disguised as firefighters. They put guns to the heads of Bea and Twila. Since they’re the main characters, it seems clear that they’ll survive. The question is how.

We also learn late in the episode that Chris is both the mole and alive, which raises many questions about the character. On top of that, it’s unclear whether Sasha survived his stab wound. There are just so, so many questions that are left open-ended.

Ultimately, Peacock needs to give us Ponies season 2 because it’s a fantastic show and we deserve answers.

03234500_poster_w780.jpg
8.9/10

Ponies

Release Date
2026 - 2026-00-00
Network
Peacock
Directors
Ally Pankiw, Susanna Fogel, Viet Nguyen
Writers
Carolyn Cicalese, Susanna Fogel, David Iserson, Adrian Lester, Emilia Clarke, Haley Lu Richardson, Jordan J. Riggs, Rosa Handelman

Cast

Creator(s)
Susanna Fogel, David Iserson