Spoilers for Primal.HBO Max's three-season science fiction fantasy series did something bold that other TV shows should learn from. When a TV show ends, no matter how celebrated the ending, some people are going to have a problem. You can't make everyone happy as a writer or showrunner.

Sometimes, the viewers have a point, though, and maybe understand something about the characters or story that the writer missed, or perhaps purposefully ignored, not realizing how dearly held that "thing" was to the people watching. Showrunners can react to that feedback in a few ways.

Some double down, others acknowledge there could have been some changes but move on, and Genndy Tartakovsky retcons the whole thing. What Tartakovsky did with Primal's ending is almost unheard of, but it was absolutely the right move, and more showrunners should learn from his example.

At the end of Primal season 2, the main character, Spear, dies. After a climactic fight to save his friends and love, he dies. However, his romantic partner later has his child, and we flash forward to the future, where we see his partner, his T. rex friend, and his now grown daughter together and happy, but Spear is very specifically not present in the scene.

Some fans didn't want Spear to die. We'd spent two seasons watching him defeat everything from Megalodons to bear-riding Viking armies; nothing should be able to defeat him. So, for Primal season 3, Tartakovsky literally brings Spear back from the dead, and he spends most of the season as a zombie regaining memories.

At the very end of the season, Spear has returned to human form and regained his memory. The last shot is exactly the same as the one from season 2, except now Spear walks into frame. It's something you can only do in fiction, and sometimes, the retcon is the right choice.

Genndy Tartakovsky's Retcon Of Primal Reveals His Confidence In The Show

Mira watching her daughter on a T. Rex at the end of Primal season 2.

Genndy Tartakovsky has been a leading figure in animation for decades, and it's not as if he's always going back and retconning his work. However, it seems that Tartakovsky must have also been ruminating on Spear's fate at the end of season 2. Obviously, Tartakovsky didn't like how things ended.

Reframing the final scene from season 2 with Spear included means he knew exactly what he was doing with the retcon, and that actually shows how confident he was with his show. This isn't a case of Tartakovsky hemming and hawing about his series; it's him deciding he wants things to be different.

It's his TV show, and it's fiction. Where else can you go back and right things in this way? Tartakovsky knew that his story was strong enough to stand up to the reverberations a major change like this would make, and still be a worthwhile story. It's a retcon born from him deciding what's best for his characters and the show.

TV Shows Should Not Be Afraid To Retcon Their Decisions

Spear and Mira watching their daughter on a T. Rex in the Primal season 3 ending.

TV shows should not be so afraid to retcon their decisions. Sure, there's a point where you can't just go back and change everything, because then things will stop mattering. However, if a show made a mistake with a character, or with a finale and then comes back, showrunners have every right to shore up what they've built.

What's a worse tack is the fake retcon, where, through some convoluted story device, a decision or character arc is erased or forgotten, but still somehow part of the story. Primal shows that sometimes it's best to just cut and run, admit you're changing the story, and move forward.

primal-poster.jpg
8.8/10

Primal

Release Date
October 8, 2019
Network
Adult Swim
Showrunner
Genndy Tartakovsky
Directors
Genndy Tartakovsky
Writers
Genndy Tartakovsky, Darrick Bachman, Bryan Andrews, Nagisa Koyama
  • Cast Placeholder Image
    Aaron LaPlante
    Spear (voice)
  • Headshot Of Laëtitia Eïdo
    Laëtitia Eïdo
    Mira (voice)

Creator(s)
Genndy Tartakovsky