Warning: Spoilers For Primal Season 2 BelowPrimal season 2 episode "The Primal Theory" broke from the structure of the show in a major way and has led to a theory it's really set in a post-apocalyptic future. Primal creator Genndy Tartakovsky started his career on shows like Batman: The Animated Series, before going on to create classics of his own with Dexter's Laboratory and Samurai Jack - which won't get a season 6. Tartakovsky's talent for visual storytelling and creating great action sequences is hard to beat.
It also speaks to his versatility that he can be behind family-friendly movies like Hotel Transylvania or hyper-violent shows like Primal. The latter series debuted on Adult Swim in 2019 and is set in a fantasy world where a caveman dubbed Spear loses his family to a dinosaur attack, and he later befriends a female T. Rex named Fang. The unlikely friends help each survive the brutal world Primal takes place in, which is filled with giant spiders, snakes and sharks and other outlandish monsters - in addition to more human threats like a coven of witches.
The first season of Primal played like pulp fantasy at its finest, with the series featuring almost no dialogue and beautiful animation. The fact the Adult Swim (home of Aqua Teen Hunger Force) show depicts a world where Neanderthals, Vikings and dinosaurs all exist together is easily brushed aside as it seemingly took place in its own alternate history. However, Primal season 2 episode "The Primal Theory has put this into question, with the story taking place in England in 1890 and exploring a theory that mankind could devolve into more primal instincts under the right circumstances.
The "Primal Theory" Breaks Series Formula
"The Primal Theory" is a departure from Primal's formula in several ways, including the fact that Spear and Fang don't appear and it's the first time the English language has been spoken on the show. The episode centers on a group of civilized English gentlemen gathered at a historical society. One of their number Charles - voiced by Fate: The Winx Saga season 1's Jacob Dudman - posits a theory that even the most civilized, educated man will revert to their basest instincts under the right conditions.
Of course, the other members openly decry his "primal" theory as absurd, especially the host Lord Darlington. The latter is downright offended by Charles' assertion, though when they are attacked by a savage, apparently unkillable madman, this premise is put to the ultimate test and as the other scientists are killed one by one only Lord Darlington and Charles are left. Darlington is a former boxing champion and despite employing more "advanced" weapons like pistols and swords against his barely human attacker, he reverts to more basic weapons and finally kills the man with a sharp stick.
"Primal Theory" Sets Up A Far Future Twist
The episode is currently a one-off within Primal season 2, and it's unknown when - or even if - its events will be revisited. By the end of the "Primal Theory" Charles, who barely survived, is elated to see his thesis about humans reverting to savagery is correct in Darlington's case. Given the premise, Primal was always assumed to take place in a prehistoric setting, but a key line of dialogue from Charles has fans debating this.
The "Primal Theory" itself is established and confirmed within the space of a single episode, proving that yes, the most sophisticated of men can tap into their violent impulses when under threat. Perhaps in the world of Primal, there was an apocalyptic event sometime after 1890 that saw the human race reverting to a more primitive state of being, with dinosaurs and other extinct creatures (somehow) evolving back into existence. The animals depicted in Primal don't strictly conform to science anyway, which can be best seen in Fang's keen level of intelligence and the fact she doesn't just eat Spear.
The latter is also ridiculously resilient when it comes to injuries that would kill or cripple most people, suggesting he may have quite literally evolved a thicker skin. What kind of apocalyptic event could have led to the world of Primal is another question entirely. If this theory is correct, the show would have to take place in the far future for practically all traces of civilization to have disappeared, which could take thousands - if not millions - of years. It might also explain the more outlandish monsters Spear and Fang have faced like the Man Bats - no relation to the Batman villain - or the Night Feeder from the episode of the same name. Outside of the oddity of having civilizations that never existed together sharing the same world, nothing in Primal season 1 hinted it was set in the far future.
Other "Primal Theory" Theories
Primal being set in the future is the spiciest reading of "The Primal Theory," but it doesn't mean it's the only one. The episode really could just be a once-off tale set in the world of the show with no other story connections. Perhaps Lord Darlington himself is a descendant of Spear - which can be seen in some of his more primitive poses during the final battle - but even that's speculation. This episode underlines the themes of Primal in a sense, where Spear, Fang and their new companion Mira - voiced by Laëtitia Eïdo from the oft-rebooted Strike Back - always have to fight to survive, even though they'd rather be left in peace.
The slaughter they commit against a Viking settlement in season 2's "The Red Mist" is one example of their being pushed to extremes during what was supposed to be a rescue mission. Another possibility is "The Primal Theory" is creator Tartakovsky testing out his plan to make Primal more of a "brand," as he stated to Indiewire. This would allow him to apply the style of the show to other settings, and "... it can be about aliens, World War II. We’ll see if anybody is excited about it.”
The final theory being discussed is that perhaps Spear and Fang's story is also set in 1890. The mounted body of a sabertooth tiger is seen in "The Primal Theory's" historical society, which doesn't seem to be an ancient fossil. Primal could really dive into its pulp origins by having its own version of a "Lost World" where extinct animals and different eras of human civilization co-exist. If the world of the series is set in 1890, not everywhere in the world would be fully mapped out. Perhaps the main action of Primal is set on some far-off island like King Kong's Skull Island, or it's a similar environment to the MonsterVerse's Hollow Earth.